SSD vs SATA II HDD

aka.Goliath

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 25, 2011
Messages
134
Reaction score
1
Location
Randburg, Johannesburg
I want to upgrade my HDD that my OS is installed on. Besides the price, What are the performance differences between SSD and SATA II HDD? I know how SSD are really so fantastically fast but how does SATA II compare to it with its 6G/s transfer rate? Or have I got this a bit confused?
 
The 6G transfer rate refers to the maximum bus speed. First of all it's all marketing speak and there's no way you'd get anything near 6GB/s on any SATA bus in existence today. Second, an SSD would get much closer to the actual transfer rate, both types of drive are limited by their own internal technology rather than the bus speed, so even if you had SATA 16TB/s, your data would only move at the speed of the drive you were reading from.

So, yes an SSD would be much, much faster. Will you actually notice it? That depends. If you have a lot of RAM, your system responsiveness will be exactly the same, but Windows and programs will load (start up, install) significantly faster, as will any games you install to the SSD. Is it all it's cracked up to be (the cheapest way to increase your PC performance dramatically)? Again it depends. If you have too little RAM, then yes, an SSD will make a big difference. If you have 4, 8 or more GB of RAM, no, it will be hard to notice apart from much faster loading times and benchmarks. In short, it's nice to have, but if I could choose again, I'd rather have put the money towards a nice Dell Ultrasharp monitor or something and waited for prices to drop a lot more.
 
SSD's are a big improvement over HDD's when it comes to random read & writes, since their latencies/seek time are much much lower than that of the HDD's.
 
The 6G transfer rate refers to the maximum bus speed. First of all it's all marketing speak and there's no way you'd get anything near 6GB/s on any SATA bus in existence today.
Please take note that SATA 3 (6Gbps) has a maximum rated transfer speed of 6 Gigabit per second, and NOT 6 Gigabyte per second! The latest SSD's are very close to the maximum of SATA 3 (6Gbps), with maximum read and write speeds in the order of 550MB/s and 500MB/s respectively.

I'd highly recommend SSD's on office PC's, but not so much on personal PC's where time isn't directly related to money ;)
Make no mistake, its still awesome to have a SSD in a gaming / normal PC, but I'd say its more of a luxury in that case :D
 
Please take note that SATA 3 (6Gbps) has a maximum rated transfer speed of 6 Gigabit per second, and NOT 6 Gigabyte per second! The latest SSD's are very close to the maximum of SATA 3 (6Gbps), with maximum read and write speeds in the order of 550MB/s and 500MB/s respectively.

I'd highly recommend SSD's on office PC's, but not so much on personal PC's where time isn't directly related to money ;)
Make no mistake, its still awesome to have a SSD in a gaming / normal PC, but I'd say its more of a luxury in that case :D

Well those are the really stupidly expensive ones, your normal "fast" SSD gets about 275MB/s (OCZ Vertex 2 etc) but point taken. Still, how does that make it better for an office PC (which needs far less power than a gaming PC)? Most computers people work on in offices are definitely not held back by their hard drives...
 
Well those are the really stupidly expensive ones, your normal "fast" SSD gets about 275MB/s (OCZ Vertex 2 etc) but point taken. Still, how does that make it better for an office PC (which needs far less power than a gaming PC)? Most computers people work on in offices are definitely not held back by their hard drives...
The 550MB/s ones aren't even that much more than the 280MB/s ones.

Software developers and graphics designers will benefit a great deal by getting a SSD.
Not everything can always be loaded into memory, which is where the SSD's come in really handy.

I'm running Windows 7 from a HDD and Ubuntu 11.04 from a 30GB OCZ Vertex 2 SSD, and pretty much everything is faster in Linux.
The loading & compilation times are miles apart between Windows 7 & Ubuntu, just due to the one running off a SSD and the other one not.
I'm using RAM drives on both operating systems for my temp folders.
 
Judging from the Wiki article you're actually worse off in an office environment (of all places) with an SSD due to the lack of encryption and permanent deletion options.
 
IMHO the SSDs are a "nice to have" rather than a "need to have" Also, remember that you are talking about a drop in capacity too, so its nice to use as a boot drive and not much else. The smaller capacity drives are reasonably priced, but they are small capacity. Personally, if I had the money, I would get one, simply for the speed up in boot times and application loading times, but they are still far too expensive and could never justify it.
I think that for laptops they are nice, because you generally don't have a lot of storage on a laptop (just your critical stuff) but speed is important, also, because they access the information so much faster and they don't have to be running constantly, the battery drain is much lower than a conventional hard drive. (yes, i know that you can spin down the normal HDD, but then it takes a LOT longer to spin up to read data, and with most modern operating systems that are constantly doing background tasks, the amount of "spin down" time is very low)
 
After a lot of reading and some playing around with an SSD in a notebook I decided to get the new 600GB 10000rpm Velociraptor for my new desktop - but I don't have all the parts yet (ie short of RAM), so cannot provide feedback as yet.

But it was much cheaper than a SSD.
 
After a lot of reading and some playing around with an SSD in a notebook I decided to get the new 600GB 10000rpm Velociraptor for my new desktop - but I don't have all the parts yet (ie short of RAM), so cannot provide feedback as yet.

But it was much cheaper than a SSD.
Paying R2k+ for a 600GB HDD is absurd. Not even the VelociRaptor can come close to the SSD's in terms of random read & writes: http://images.anandtech.com/graphs/graph4346/37926.png
The VelociRaptor does very well with sequential read & writes. The only thing that I know of that makes use of that (sequential read) is watching videos or playing mp3's.

You'd be much better off with a 120GB SSD + 1.5TB green drive combination.
 
well if you compare the raptor vs ssd for gb per R1, then your raptor will win, but with slower speeds and also noisier too.
speed - ssd
bang for buck - raptor
 
well if you compare the raptor vs ssd for gb per R1, then your raptor will win, but with slower speeds and also noisier too.
speed - ssd
bang for buck - raptor

Raptor also more power hungry.
 
Paying R2k+ for a 600GB HDD is absurd.

I imported it, so paid a lot less than R2k (USD200*6.7+VAT) - so, yes, cost was a serious consideration.

My experience with SSD's (Samsung, Intel) has not been great, so I don't really trust them as yet.
 
Last edited:
One shouldn't compare the built-in SSD's with the SATA 3 (6Gbps) ones that you can buy now.

$200 for that VelociRaptor is an awesome price, but it is still quite a lot to pay for a HDD.

I'm perfectly happy with my 120GB 5700rpm HDD in my laptop, just because I use it for web browsing and watching videos.
 
One shouldn't compare the built-in SSD's with the SATA 3 (6Gbps) ones that you can buy now.

$200 for that VelociRaptor is an awesome price, but it is still quite a lot to pay for a HDD.

I'm perfectly happy with my 120GB 5700rpm HDD in my laptop, just because I use it for web browsing and watching videos.

Point taken, maybe I will get an SSD later and then use the VelociRaptor as a scratch disk. BTW this VelociRaptor is also Sata 3.
 
The VelociRaptor can't even saturate SATA 2, so making it a SATA 3 drive is simply a marketing gimmick.

I'm quite sure that you'll be very happy with your VelociRaptor :)
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X