Synthetic meat

Nerfherder

Honorary Master
Joined
Apr 21, 2008
Messages
36,405
Reaction score
10,311
Location
/\/¯¯¯¯¯¯\/\
Not sure if this should be in Food/cooking, PD or heath but I think that it releates to health and lifestyle the most... so here goes.

So as an avid meat eater I often find myself being the target of vegan/vegetarian ambushes. I love a good debate - however after years of engaging them I have actually managed to concede a few points:

1: Our farming methods are ****ed. Massive wastage and cruelty and poor quality and it takes up too much land.
2: We eat too much meat - this is a new thing... and we waste even more
3: Meat complicates our lives in terms of hygene and handling and it gives us a massive carbon foot print.

Basically weather we like it or not meat is not a viable/sustainable option for the future.

The vegans are extreemists though and what they fail to see is that the problem is waste... and human existence. No matter what we do we screw up the world.
Thats besides the point.

The main thing i'm considering now is that in the future we wont be able to get meat. It will be too expensive and with the limited resources avaialble its not going to make sense for us to grow animals purely for consumption.
Meat is going to become an extream luxuary and even then a rare thing to get hold of. Basically game and wild animals.

I became convinced of this while watching a program on future food the other day. Two options stood out as things that are going to be realites:

1: Mycoprotein
2: Test tube meat
3: Soylent green :whistle:

Test tube meat is still pie in the sky, insanely expensive but one day the tech will be cheap enough to use in the mainstream.
Mycoprotein is on the other hand a reality. You can walk into PicknPay right now and get it off the shelf. Its a bit on the expensive side but its an option that exists right now.

When I first saw Quorn advertised it sounded like mashed up veg made to look like meat products (Like frys etc) then I saw how they make it and I realised this is something else entirely.
Mycoprotein is the ingredient common to all Quorn™ products. It's a completely meat-free form of high quality protein and is also a good source of dietary fibre. It is low in fat and saturates and contains no cholesterol or trans fats at all. Mycoprotein is made in fermenters similar to those found in a brewery.

This is a completely new food type. Basically a fungus that they grow in vats, basted on what they add will make it like chicken or beef. Raw it looks like pink slime.
Whats interesting is that when vegans bleat on about vegan options being better for the enviroment they mean this - It uses the least mount of water, space and resources and is high in fiber and protien while low in colestrol.

After reading about this type of thing in The Expanse series I realised that its definately the way of the future and the best way to grow food in space. So being the science minded person I am I went to go check it out.
I was shocked, if you served these "chicken" nuggets at a party I doubt anyone would know its not meat. If you compared it with Mcnuggets most people would probably say the Quorn is the real meat.
I don't think i'll move over to the darkside just yet but its good to know my brain can be tricked in to eating fake meat.
 
My only concern is Alzheimers/dementia

And then all the other things that we have evolved to require.
 
What do you mean ? Will synthetic meat cause this ?

Vitamin B12, Folate and centuries of evolution.

Don't get me wrong, In our household we have 1 to 2 days a week meat free, we eat a healthy bix of red and white meats and also have other protein sources (soy, lentils etc).

I think we are many years away from anything close to meat being an upper class luxury but also agree that we need to streamline the production and ethical side of it.

Oh, and as synthetic meat has not been in our diets very long, I have no idea if it will have any unintentional side effects.
 
Last edited:
It's not a super deep discussion but a decent cursory introduction to the idea and where it's at:

[video=youtube;lOQPuIZePH8]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOQPuIZePH8[/video]
 
2: We eat too much meat - this is a new thing... and we waste even more
It would be nice if a lowered demand for meat could mean a higher demand for more reasonable farming conditions for animals. It's quite doable for most people to eat meat 3/4 days a week (or less) as opposed to the almost twice daily consumption a lot of people seem to do.
 
It would be nice if a lowered demand for meat could mean a higher demand for more reasonable farming conditions for animals. It's quite doable for most people to eat meat 3/4 days a week (or less) as opposed to the almost twice daily consumption a lot of people seem to do.


Its completely doable, its a fairly new thing that we eat meat twice a day or even every day.

During WW2 this was the norm. With meat rations most had meat less than once a week.

I do think that we should persue a more ethical and sustainable approach to meat that we could still keep it in our diet. Reality is that the world is not changing fast enough though.
 
I do think that we should persue a more ethical and sustainable approach to meat that we could still keep it in our diet. Reality is that the world is not changing fast enough though.
Convenience > Ethical considerations.

If you're prepared to walk into KFC and eat a deep-fried battery-farmed never-see-daylight piece of chicken - you're doing so because it's convenient (& it tastes good). Even the most momentary of ethical considerations regarding the life of those chickens (or cattle, pigs etc.) should be enough to deter one...but it isn't. So I'm not sure how you encourage the ethical agenda when even with what the public knows about battery / intensive farming - we still eat it. Synthetic meat might just be the alternative we require when the ethical consideration isn't a strong enough driver for change.
 
Convenience > Ethical considerations.

If you're prepared to walk into KFC and eat a deep-fried battery-farmed never-see-daylight piece of chicken - you're doing so because it's convenient (& it tastes good). Even the most momentary of ethical considerations regarding the life of those chickens (or cattle, pigs etc.) should be enough to deter one...but it isn't. So I'm not sure how you encourage the ethical agenda when even with what the public knows about battery / intensive farming - we still eat it. Synthetic meat might just be the alternative we require when the ethical consideration isn't a strong enough driver for change.

I know. I actaully like to seperate these two arguements as you are correct, they do work against each other.

I think the economics of the situation will be the first to really affect us. The poor wont be able to afford meat, the rich will be disgusted by the conditions the meat is made in.
At some point ethical and economic reasoning will hopefully work together to fix this mess.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X