TechSense - Helping You Build Computers

Vegeta ZA

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 4, 2008
Messages
113
Reaction score
1
Location
Centurion
Hey Everyone,

My cousin and I have been working on a site to assist those who are not up to date with the current pc hardware.

There are builds of different budgets up already and we will be adding more soon.

Here's the link:
http://techsense.cu.cc/

We welcome any feedback and suggestions to help improve on our site. Cheers!
 
The workstation PC has some strange choices. It appears to be a gaming PC with workstation cards thrown into the mix. Two low-to-mid-range AMD Firepros that don't even have ECC memory (a must for many workstation applications) is a strange choice. So is a 1500w PSU for a rig that will hardly use 300w. Storage is another concern.

A non-WS series board, non-ECC memory and a CPU that doesn't support ECC memory are also strange choices. That case is more for a gaming rig than a workstation, it's very bulky without giving many features for all that bulk especially compared to something like a Corsair 900D. That said, something much would probably make more sense for a workstation.

A motherboard such as the Asus X99-E WS is qualified to work with a MASSIVE range of hardware likely to be seen in a workstation, including Red capture cards, Xeon Phi accelerators and more.

The Xeon E5-2630 v3, an eight core processor with Turbo up to 3.2 GHz, would allow for not only more multithreaded horsepower but also ECC memory. ECC memory, such as this Crucial 32 GB kit, is an absolute must for any mission critical workstation (i.e. all of them).

The Firepro W7100 is the same price as two W5100s and will have about the same power consumption, takes one less slot, has zero performance hit in tasks that can't use multiple cards AND is actually faster than two W5100s with perfectly linear scaling. The W8100 is a better choice as it adds ECC memory to the mix and offers four times the performance on a W5100, but at a price. All of these cards fall flat when using applications that don't support AMD cards, such as the Adobe suite (which is a likely use for a workstation).

Yes it's fun to have an SSD capable of over 2 GB/s transfer speeds, but your storage is very limited and there's NO failover whatsoever. Put four of the Samsung 500 GB SSDs in RAID 5 for a 1.5 TB partition with more than half the speed of the Intel 750 SSD as well as a larger capacity and then four of these WD Red 3 TB drives in RAID 5 for a further 9 TB of storage.

Add to that a Corsair Carbide 330R or similar and a Corsair RM550 PSU and you're good to go.

Yes, it's more expensive than the rig you specd out (R 70,919) but it has significantly more CPU and GPU power, a LOT more storage, redundant storage and ECC on both the system RAM and GPU RAM.

If you want to cut costs, replace the Firepro W8100 with a W7100 (lacking ECC memory so not the wisest choice), and the SSDs with the 250 GB model. You're then at R 59,718 for much more CPU power, slightly more GPU power, ECC memory, 62 % of the SSD storage at 74 % of the speed with more than eight times the total storage along with redundancy.
 
Last edited:
Whoops, I made a typo. Corrected.

It's also far from an ultimate workstation build, here's something just slightly better :p

This is about what I put together when someone asked why I don't upgrade to DDR4 and I explained it would cost me in excess of R 100,000. If I'm spending an enormous amount on swapping to DDR4, I'm wanting a system which is faster overall, not the same but with DDR4. I leave off the graphics cards as I would reuse my Titans, the money spent upgrading to full blown Quadros is NOT worth it.

Xeon E5-2650 V3 2.30 GHz 10-core processor (3.00 GHz Turbo) R23,577
Xeon E5-2650 V3 2.30 GHz 10-core processor (3.00 GHz Turbo) R 23,577
ASUS Z10PE-D16 WS Dual LGA2011v3 Motherboard R 10,772
Crucial 32 GB (4x 8 GB) DDR4-2133 ECC Registered RAM R 5,304
Crucial 32 GB (4x 8 GB) DDR4-2133 ECC Registered RAM R 5,304
Quadro K5200 8 GB Graphics Card R 35,909
Quadro K5200 8 GB Graphics Card R 35,909
Samsung 850 Evo 500 GB SSD RAID10 R 3,011
Samsung 850 Evo 500 GB SSD RAID10 R 3,011
Samsung 850 Evo 500 GB SSD RAID10 R 3,011
Samsung 850 Evo 500 GB SSD RAID10 R 3,011
WD Red 6 TB Hard Drive RAID5 R 4,749
WD Red 6 TB Hard Drive RAID5 R 4,749
WD Red 6 TB Hard Drive RAID5 R 4,749
WD Red 6 TB Hard Drive RAID5 R 4,749
Corsair 900D Full Tower R 5,467
Corsair AX1200i PSU R 4,546

Total R 181,355

Hmmmm - R 63,180 to upgrade to two ten core CPUs with a downgrade to 32 GB RAM. Let's see what the fiancee says - if you don't hear from me ever again it was her :D
 
Last edited:
I don't agree with those builds.

Nobody will, and nobody will agree with anything you or I put together either. They're starting points, and for starting points they aren't bad. The workstation build is a different story though as the choice of components would be better suited to a gaming rig.
 
Yes, not everyone will agree to the PC builds on the site but as I have mentioned, the site is there to help people who aren't very clued up on these things. So to them, it will be useful and that's our aim.

Appreciate the feedback, [XC] Oj101
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X