dualmeister
Honorary Master
Winter.
-
Join the MyBroadband community
South Africa’s biggest forum. Discuss, discover, and connect with thousands of members.
-
Question of the Day: How frequently are you watching FIFA World Cup 2026 matches?
Whisk(e)y Lovers thread(II)
- Thread starter DramBuddy
- Start date
I've had the Craigellachie and Edradour on a bottle split and they are brilliant!!! Just bought a full bottle of the Craigellachie .
heartbroken
Expert Member
So after spending a lot of money on whiskey this year, my friend and myself decided to set a new challenge. To find the best value for money bottle around the R500 mark.
It's been quite enjoyable, we take turns buying a bottle and then trying to convince the other that it's a good value buy - a cheaper bottle scores more "points" if perceived to be good.
We did a few bourbons - makers, wild turkey, buffalo trace, then he did a Tullamore XO and I countered with a Tumnavulin (which at R390 currently impressed a bit). I think he is getting a Shackleton for his round. Outside of the mainstream suspects, what can I get next? Was thinking maybe a benriach curiositas or a 12 yo.
I need to win this, there is a Coal Ila on the table for the winner.
It's been quite enjoyable, we take turns buying a bottle and then trying to convince the other that it's a good value buy - a cheaper bottle scores more "points" if perceived to be good.
We did a few bourbons - makers, wild turkey, buffalo trace, then he did a Tullamore XO and I countered with a Tumnavulin (which at R390 currently impressed a bit). I think he is getting a Shackleton for his round. Outside of the mainstream suspects, what can I get next? Was thinking maybe a benriach curiositas or a 12 yo.
I need to win this, there is a Coal Ila on the table for the winner.
Do a black bottle, its a cheap easy drinking irish whiskey.
dualmeister
Honorary Master
Not something you expect to see at your local Tops.
Shackleton is a really boring dram. I've had it since I first really got into whisky (because of the price) but you can see how far I got. Pretty much anything would beat that out.
What's the upper limit of 'around R500'?
Glen Scotia 15 if you can find a bottle left at Checkers is your answer.
Attachments
Pieter Loose Goose
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Oct 17, 2019
- Messages
- 126
- Reaction score
- 83
The only time ever I saw a Smokehead release in a bottlestore was the normal 43% version at our local Checkers.
I must say, the overwhelming nuttyness of the high voltage (which is bottled at 58%) is something I keep on coming back to. I really enjoy the high voltage, but I feel it is a bit overpriced, only have a bottle because I got it on a sale on Takealot for just under R600.
Pieter Loose Goose
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Oct 17, 2019
- Messages
- 126
- Reaction score
- 83
Black Bottle is actually Scottish, lol.
A bottle store near me actually still have the old style bottle in stock. I'm not sure if the blend is the same as the new style bottle, (never tried any of them) as they apparently changed the blend and used less Islay whisky in the new blend
dualmeister
Honorary Master
Got my "normal" Smokehead at my local PnP.
Yes I remember that Takealot deal you lucky bastard
Bar Keeper Cape Town had the High Voltage on the shelf.
Last edited:
Oops. It tastes like an irish haha!! Yeah think its a bit diffrent since the update. The old bottles were quite good I was told
Get a bottle of Naked Grouse. Best value for under R500 imo. Combo of Macallan, Highland Park and Glenturret.
I have seen it around for R300 per bottle on some PnP specials. Currently R335 (and in stock) at WAW.
Naked Grouse
Brand: Famous Grouse Category: Whisky Type: Blended Malt Region: Scotland Alcohol: 43% alc/vol An interesting addition to the Famous Grouse range, this was aged in first fill sherry casks, and is based around malt whisky from Highland Park and Macallan. Very simply, this is a superb...
wildaboutwhisky.com
Wow that's a great find.I highly recommend grabbing this. Same price as launch price 6 years ago. A fantastic dram at a give away price TBH...
Liquorshop
www.liquorshop.co.za
I see they still have the Springbank 23 too! Someone decided to do a stock take and found some hidden bottles...
Messugga
Honorary Master
G
The Glendronach 18 isn't a terrible price either. One of my favourites but a bit tricky to find these days.
20 years old (unless there are two?)
I'd be interested in picking that up. Not available at any Checkers in KZN, it seems. Contemplated driving 60km for the Mortlach 14 and Glenlossie 15 (in Scottburgh). Benriness is out in Vryheid. I'm mad but I'm not 3 hour drive for whisky I've never tasted mad.
Will wait it out and see if The Glendronach pops up. Fingers crossed.
Pieter Loose Goose
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Oct 17, 2019
- Messages
- 126
- Reaction score
- 83
Get a bottle of Naked Grouse. Best value for under R500 imo. Combo of Macallan, Highland Park and Glenturret.
I have seen it around for R300 per bottle on some PnP specials. Currently R335 (and in stock) at WAW.
Naked Grouse
Brand: Famous Grouse Category: Whisky Type: Blended Malt Region: Scotland Alcohol: 43% alc/vol An interesting addition to the Famous Grouse range, this was aged in first fill sherry casks, and is based around malt whisky from Highland Park and Macallan. Very simply, this is a superb...
You have to like a sherry bomb though as it is heavily sherried as it was matured in virgin sherry casks.
But I agree, this is a really tasty and affordable budget blended malt, I always have one on hand
heartbroken
Expert Member
Thanks for the responses!
I think I am going to go with the Naked Grouse, walked passed it several times in favour of something else, but I think now is the time to try. I am not a big sherry fan, but my friend is, so might score me a few bonus points!
I think I am going to go with the Naked Grouse, walked passed it several times in favour of something else, but I think now is the time to try. I am not a big sherry fan, but my friend is, so might score me a few bonus points!
Benriach 12 (Rachel Barrie release) is an absolute winner and you will find it for less than R500. Don't know if you have tried the Glenmorangie 10 (round the low R400 mark) or even Bains Symphony at R370 but a limited release. For me the winner would be Ardbeg Wee Beastie which is now sub R500, but do you guys like peat?
On the bourbon from, Woodford Reserve is fantastic and <R500, as is Bulleit but you cannot beat JD Rye at round R300 (don't even think that it tastes anything like normal JD, which I can't stand).
I'm not a fan of the Ben Nevis but you can grab a sample when you fetch the Ardbeg split from me.
Messugga
Honorary Master
Nope, 18 Allardice is there as well.