Why the outrage only over Lwandle?

Vox Populi Vox Dei

High Tory
Joined
Mar 6, 2004
Messages
54,136
Reaction score
38,940
Location
Cape Town
I always suspected that the Ses’Khona movement had a political angle to it and Helen Zille confirms my view. This movement is not really fighting for the rights of the poor but rather are using it to make the Western Cape ungovernable.

The 2016 local election campaign has begun and many are cashing in on human misery, writes Helen Zille.

Cape Town - Snug in my sheepskin slippers under a fluffy knee-blanket, I write about the past week’s evictions, acutely aware of the situation of the people I am writing about.

They were forcibly removed last week, in two mass evictions – one in Alexandra, Gauteng, and the other in Lwandle, Western Cape. Many more people may have suffered the same fate in different parts of South Africa, but their stories did not make the news.

Both removals involved extreme human misery.

While the Alex evictions passed largely unnoticed, scores of commentators competed to be heard above the roar of condemnation that accompanied the Lwandle evictions.

...

During a fact-finding visit to the site, provincial officials encountered Andile Lili and Loyiso Nkhola, the leaders of the ANC’s “ungovernability” campaign (also known as the “Poo Protesters”) in charge of the situation. On further investigation, the officials found that Ses’Khona had an office on the site: a sturdy structure that had somehow escaped demolition. According to some evictees, they had been required to pay R25 each to Ses’Khona (disguised as a membership fee) in order to obtain a plot (and a T-shirt in ANC colours). This account was confirmed by the Ses’Khona organiser on the site, Vuyiswa Swentu.

It is clear that Ses’Khona is merely continuing its “ungovernability” strategy. They have openly called for land invasions in Cape Town and are now actually facilitating them by identifying “vulnerable land”. Then, in return for a “membership fee”, they encourage people who do not meet the housing allocation criteria (because they are too young or have already benefited before) to move on to the land.


Stripped of all the rhetoric, the truth is that Ses’Khona, in the most cynical way possible, is creating human misery (that we then prioritise over “legal niceties”), to advance their “ungovernability” agenda. And legitimate beneficiaries are sidelined once more.

If Sisulu really means it when she states that “we do not tolerate, condone, nor encourage any illegal occupation of land in our country”, she would find out what role the ANC’s Ses’Khona storm-troopers are playing in facilitating these invasions and creating “human misery” for their own “ungovernability” agenda.

Does this then imply that we should welcome the committee that the minister unilaterally announced to investigate the situation surrounding the invasion and evictions on the Sanral land?

Unfortunately, this committee does not pass even the most rudimentary scrutiny.

It includes Ses’Khona’s own lawyer, Barnabas Xulu; ANC stalwart Annelize van Wyk, who pre-judged the matter from the start in a Twitter tirade blaming the city; Nonhle Dambuza, an ANC MP; and a former ANC MP, Mampe Ramotsomai, who was reportedly arrested after 15 000 Mandrax tablets were seized from her home in 2001, before the case mysteriously vanished from public view. The committee is to be chaired by Denzil Potgieter, who has previously been chastised by a judge for conducting an “improper” inquiry set up by Marius Fransman against a DA council.

If Minister Sisulu was serious about establishing the truth, she would have set up an inquiry in consultation with the mayor of Cape Town; and she would also inquire into evictions countrywide.

But that is not the purpose. The 2016 local election campaign has begun. That is the prism through which to understand the Lwandle occupations and evictions.

Abahlali baseMjondolo hit the nail on the head.

http://www.iol.co.za/pretoria-news/opinion/why-the-outrage-only-over-lwandle-1.1702249#.U5oEcHLa7Po
 
Helen Zille is good at playing the blame game. Whenever there is protest, she blames it on the "ungovernability campaign". Did she ever stop to think that maybe these people are genuinely suffering and genuinely have grievances? Yes, Andili Lili does stir a lot of sh*t (excuse the pun) but he wouldn't be able to "control" these people if it was not for their unhappiness. I'm seriously tired of everything being blamed on the ungovernability campaign. Also, I'm pretty sure I read somewhere that Lili is no longer part of the ANC?
 
Helen Zille is good at playing the blame game. Whenever there is protest, she blames it on the "ungovernability campaign". Did she ever stop to think that maybe these people are genuinely suffering and genuinely have grievances? Yes, Andili Lili does stir a lot of sh*t (excuse the pun) but he wouldn't be able to "control" these people if it was not for their unhappiness. I'm seriously tired of everything being blamed on the ungovernability campaign. Also, I'm pretty sure I read somewhere that Lili is no longer part of the ANC?

They've been re-instated.

http://mg.co.za/article/2014-03-24-poo-throwers-welcomed-back-in-the-anc

Anyway, blame being placed on 'protesters' whose own explicitly stated goal is ungovernability seems fairly reasonable.

There are naturally people who have a legitimate grievance, but this whole situation is ridiculous. SANRAL got an eviction order, not the City. Who do the ANC and government blame? The City.

They jump up and down to blame the City and the DA, and then get right on finding a solution, but when it happens in ANC areas they don't give a flying fsck.

Case in point:

http://mg.co.za/article/2014-06-12-...-for-not-providing-accommodation-for-evictees
 
They've been re-instated.

http://mg.co.za/article/2014-03-24-poo-throwers-welcomed-back-in-the-anc

Anyway, blame being placed on 'protesters' whose own explicitly stated goal is ungovernability seems fairly reasonable.

There are naturally people who have a legitimate grievance, but this whole situation is ridiculous. SANRAL got an eviction order, not the City. Who do the ANC and government blame? The City.

They jump up and down to blame the City and the DA, and then get right on finding a solution, but when it happens in ANC areas they don't give a flying fsck.

Case in point:

http://mg.co.za/article/2014-06-12-...-for-not-providing-accommodation-for-evictees

This is why I'm so tired of politics. Everyone plays the blame game and the grievances of the people are an after thought. Politicians only take note once the media blows the situation up

I guess in a perfect world the ANC or DA will say, "yes, we fckd up, but this is how we will correct the situation" in response to grievances
 
This is why I'm so tired of politics. Everyone plays the blame game and the grievances of the people are an after thought. Politicians only take note once the media blows the situation up

I guess in a perfect world the ANC or DA will say, "yes, we fckd up, but this is how we will correct the situation" in response to grievances
Do you honestly think in this situation the DA should be saying "yes , we fckd up .. " ?
 
Last edited:
Helen Zille is good at playing the blame game. Whenever there is protest, she blames it on the "ungovernability campaign". Did she ever stop to think that maybe these people are genuinely suffering and genuinely have grievances? Yes, Andili Lili does stir a lot of sh*t (excuse the pun) but he wouldn't be able to "control" these people if it was not for their unhappiness. I'm seriously tired of everything being blamed on the ungovernability campaign. Also, I'm pretty sure I read somewhere that Lili is no longer part of the ANC?

Where you ever late for work because of these protesters? Well I have. If not, then you have no idea about what you are talking about. Sit in traffic and see the commuters next to you in a taxi starting to stress as they fear the may loose their work. How about having your bus stoned or your car while you have your kids with you.

Also we have limited resources and first come, first served should be the order of the day but it is not because this lot are queue jumpers.

And on the toilets, oh wait, it was found that there was a hidden agenda. They demanded a certain type of toilet be installed. There would have been financial gain to certain individuals/comrades had the municipality gone ahead with this demand.

Zille is not playing the blame game, she is stating facts. I subscribe to City of Cape Town Council emails and I get the facts. I don't believe everything I read in the news.
 
Just when you think the ANC can't stoop any lower they pull a stunt like this.
 
Last edited:
Where you ever late for work because of these protesters? Well I have. If not, then you have no idea about what you are talking about. Sit in traffic and see the commuters next to you in a taxi starting to stress as they fear the may loose their work. How about having your bus stoned or your car while you have your kids with you.

Also we have limited resources and first come, first served should be the order of the day but it is not because this lot are queue jumpers.

And on the toilets, oh wait, it was found that there was a hidden agenda. They demanded a certain type of toilet be installed. There would have been financial gain to certain individuals/comrades had the municipality gone ahead with this demand.

Zille is not playing the blame game, she is stating facts. I subscribe to City of Cape Town Council emails and I get the facts. I don't believe everything I read in the news.

I travel by train. Also my inlaws had car thrown at with stones while two year old was in car so I know all about protest. I also mostly travel via the N2. Yes the way they strike and protest is bad, and the violence is not needed. neither is the poo for that matter. But what I'm saying is that we should understand the reason for the protests. To blame it on some conspiracy to make the western cape ungovernable is a bit far fetched. I'm not saying there isn't opportunistic politicians out there, but what I am saying is that there is definitely some unhappy residents out there.
 
Do you honestly think in this situation the DA should be saying "yes , we fckd up .. " ?

The DA could have handled it better. For three days the DA put up their hands and said its not their problem its a SANRAL issue, only got involved once media and ANC started to play blame game. As far as I'm concerned, the DA, ANC and SANRAL is all to blame for this.
 
Why the outrage over the outrage? This is African politics, where the voters are simply fodder who continue to vote for their own misery, then blame their suffering on the white man (or woman in this case).
 
I travel by train. Also my inlaws had car thrown at with stones while two year old was in car so I know all about protest. I also mostly travel via the N2. Yes the way they strike and protest is bad, and the violence is not needed. neither is the poo for that matter. But what I'm saying is that we should understand the reason for the protests. To blame it on some conspiracy to make the western cape ungovernable is a bit far fetched. I'm not saying there isn't opportunistic politicians out there, but what I am saying is that there is definitely some unhappy residents out there.

The reason for the protests is all political. Its not to improve the lives of the majority but only that of the elite comrades. Follow our local opposition and see how they threaten to disrupt our City and our province. The claim its all in the name of the poor but they do more harm and no good.

You never see the residents of our City who have a real cause to protest actually do so, its always a minority with its own agenda.

I believe the ones in need are too busy surviving to bother playing politics. When I was homeless I spent my energy on finding a place to stay and in order to do that I had to find work instead of throwing bricks at cars on the road. When we had no food in our house I went out after school to work instead of burning down the school down. When I was unemployed I went out to look for work instead of defecating on the national road.

Thats what real people do.
 
To blame it on some conspiracy to make the western cape ungovernable is a bit far fetched.

Except that the people involved in starting these protests (Andile Lili and Loyiso Nkhola) have explicitly stated that they intend to make the province ungovernable under the DA.

... but what I am saying is that there is definitely some unhappy residents out there.

There are unhappy residents in all provinces, except for some reason it's not a problem when they're unhappy outside the Western Cape. Weird huh?

For three days the DA put up their hands and said its not their problem its a SANRAL issue...

Which is the truth.

The DA could have handled it better.

What better way to "handle" the truth than by telling the truth? Or are you suggesting that the DA starts outright lying just like the ANC?

Begone, ANC sockpuppet.
 
Last edited:
The DA could have handled it better. For three days the DA put up their hands and said its not their problem its a SANRAL issue, only got involved once media and ANC started to play blame game. As far as I'm concerned, the DA, ANC and SANRAL is all to blame for this.

You sure don't read the facts do you.

The City (not the DA) has no legal mandate to do anything here. The issue is evictions on private land. Even the ANC is getting unnecessary blame here.

This is also not the first eviction off this land by SANRAL BTW. Media was also vocal on the previous evictions but seemed to be more honoust. I love the poor journalism of current events where they make claims that the shacks were set alight by the police, actually it was residents who would rather see their possessions go up in flames than end up in the hands of others - but that does not sell the news.

The real issue here is SANRAL conveniently evicted residents who all happened to vote ANC (see the voting results for the local voting stations) after the election. They did it at a very inappropriate time which allowed individuals to use it for political gain.

But if you really care about this lot, then let them come and set up their shack in your backyard.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X