Telkom's latest price increases questioned

Why they are increasing anything is beyond me. Technology is getting cheaper, not more expensive. Just because you are allowed to do something, doesn't mean that you have to do something. I think more and more consumers are becoming more educated w.r.t. Telkom, and telecommunication in general. Nobody think Telkom is doing us any favours.
 
The ASA concept is pretty cool though - I can advertise whatever I want to to attract customers, and as soon as someone complains, I just pull the ad. Seems to be a lack of accountability to me - but maybe I'm missing something?
 
The ASA concept is pretty cool though - I can advertise whatever I want to to attract customers, and as soon as someone complains, I just pull the ad. Seems to be a lack of accountability to me - but maybe I'm missing something?
The latest Lolly Jackson/Teazers case is a good example of what you are saying. Advertise what you want and as soon as someone report you, you achieved what you want.
 
There is an Ad at the moment on Radio about telkom and the "next generation". Its all about life changing as a result of increased speeds etc. I'm sure if a complaint was lodged with the AASA about false promises TELKOM could be made to withdraw this ad also
 
Firstly I don’t think Telkom is in the wrong here. To advertise an average figure is acceptable, and there will obviously be individuals who fall outside of such a figure (some less, some more). Telkom also gave a breakdown of most relevant increases and decreases which should serve to keep customers informed.

I agree that the idea that the principle that if an ad is withdrawn it is cool should be relooked. I think a ruling on these ads is needed and it should be logged with other complaints. The ASA’s power comes in sanctions against companies, and here rulings against offending ads are considered.
 
Telkom's average price claims have always been intended to hide the real cost increase.
 
Firstly I don’t think Telkom is in the wrong here. To advertise an average figure is acceptable, and there will obviously be individuals who fall outside of such a figure (some less, some more). Telkom also gave a breakdown of most relevant increases and decreases which should serve to keep customers informed.

I agree that the idea that the principle that if an ad is withdrawn it is cool should be relooked. I think a ruling on these ads is needed and it should be logged with other complaints. The ASA’s power comes in sanctions against companies, and here rulings against offending ads are considered.

With hugely disparate communities, it IS a problem. Same thing happened with Eskom. An average CONSUMER is taken, which means the AVERAGE is a shack dweller living on the breadline. This makes people in "real homes" the "not average". And these people have huge increases.
My electricity went up over 60%, not 33%, because I am "not average".

It is misleading.
 
Can anyone figure out why his rental went up by 36%?
 
Firstly I don’t think Telkom is in the wrong here. To advertise an average figure is acceptable, and there will obviously be individuals who fall outside of such a figure (some less, some more).
Maybe, but since Telkom undertook to amend its advertising and not use the same claims in the future, they will not be able to "specifically refer to an overall price increase promoting a basket of services" anymore.
At least that would be my understanding. If they can't do that anymore one could see it as a partial victory over Telkom.
 
telkom is here to make money not friends
 
Last edited:
Maybe, but since Telkom undertook to amend its advertising and not use the same claims in the future, they will not be able to "specifically refer to an overall price increase promoting a basket of services" anymore. At least that would be my understanding. If they can't do that anymore one could see it as a partial victory over Telkom.
This is an interesting point that I did not consider. I wonder if a similar ad with next years' price changes will be considered a breach of the ASA rules?
 
This is an interesting point that I did not consider. I wonder if a similar ad with next years' price changes will be considered a breach of the ASA rules?
Will u or someone else be diarising this and holding them to task when they do it again next year? :D

You have my support :)
 
Firstly I don’t think Telkom is in the wrong here. To advertise an average figure is acceptable, and there will obviously be individuals who fall outside of such a figure (some less, some more). Telkom also gave a breakdown of most relevant increases and decreases which should serve to keep customers informed.

I agree, but: the basket should be an average basket. Decreasing the price of something that 1 person uses by 50%, and increasing the price of something that 1000 people use by 40% does not equate to an average price drop of 10%.
 
Why they are increasing anything is beyond me. Technology is getting cheaper, not more expensive. Just because you are allowed to do something, doesn't mean that you have to do something. I think more and more consumers are becoming more educated w.r.t. Telkom, and telecommunication in general. Nobody think Telkom is doing us any favours.

I am sorry to say but you are incorrect. Thanks to Cosatu they have to increase their wages to employees, this means they just shift that increase to the consumer. Welcome to economics.
 
Why they are increasing anything is beyond me. Technology is getting cheaper, not more expensive.

A reasonable point.

Telkom decided to capitalized on the ASA’s long standing principle “that where an advertiser provides an unequivocal undertaking to withdraw or amend its advertising in a manner that addresses the concerns raised, that undertaking is accepted without considering the merits of the matter.

I am not sure I personally agree with that philosophy. It allows unscrupulous advertisers to push the boundaries and get away with almost anything. :(
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X