'Do away with ADSL capping’

asking for Telkom to drop capping policy is far fetched...

Increasing cap (15-30Gb) and unlimited local I'll accept. Prob with uncapped policy is that Telkom's exchanges will get congested and all of us will have a very unpleasant ADSL experience and complain even more.
 
someone give that man a medal. plus one other argument to use is that port shaping was put in place to stop abuse. now that we pay per gig surely those who abuse will merely be charged more so why is shaping still around?
 
They should do something similar to what they do overseas now...

Free uncapped no-port priority AFTER HOURS !!!!!

(or maybe just apply that thinking to local only bandwidth???)
 
No cap works well with the shaping system. That way p2p hoggin resources is less likely to occur.

Removal of port shapping requires a international cap at the very least to ensure again users to abuse with p2p and even then local should not be capped/shaped and reasonably priced and allocated.

The current trickle of bandwith has people using it as little as possible much like dial up which = not problem adsl was designed to solve etc and makes adsl = dial up.

Increasing bandwidth esp local = more local content for cheap which is good. Do EET
 
Last edited:
derekc said:
asking for Telkom to drop capping policy is far fetched...

Increasing cap (15-30Gb) and unlimited local I'll accept. Prob with uncapped policy is that Telkom's exchanges will get congested and all of us will have a very unpleasant ADSL experience and complain even more.

Telkom have more than enough money to upgrade their equipment. If they can't provide the service to their current customers they should be forced to stop selling it to new ones until they can and then, finally, when its clear to everyone that telkom can't provide the services they legally have to they should lose their license.

We will never progress if we keep pandering to telkom's incompitance.
 
yup...problem is Telkom wants to squeeze every cent from investments they make. This is evident from the fact that they have huge warehouses in centurion housing ancient exchanges. Some of them still have vacuum tubes.
 
derekc said:
asking for Telkom to drop capping policy is far fetched...
ICASA doesnt have to ask.
RazorSA said:
(or maybe just apply that thinking to local only bandwidth???)
The idea that local should be different is going to be the end of me - it's the WORLD wide web. Not the world-wide-until-you're-capped-then-local web. Its like going to the library but only being allowed to read south african books.

I want access to the internet on my terms and not just parts of it.

Unbundle the local loop and nationalise the landing points - end of what telkom wants.
 
Last edited:
bwana v.11 said:
The idea that local should be different is going to be the end of me - it's the WORLD wide web.
Very, very well said. My sentiments exactly. ;)
 
RazorSA said:
They should do something similar to what they do overseas now...

Free uncapped no-port priority AFTER HOURS !!!!!

(or maybe just apply that thinking to local only bandwidth???)

For those that cant remember we had uncapped local. Also afaik telkom got a sh!tload of bandwidth of sat3 but only using about 30% of it or something along those lines
 
Believe it or not there are lots of providers in 1'st world country that do in face "cap" their users be it by throttle or complete dismissal of service even though its not on paper.

A guy I know in canada (and one in america) has gotten warnings from the service provider for doing HUGE ammounts per month, they give three warnings then terminate your service.

Australia has capping aswell and I see in the UK some charge u per gig after (except its something rediculously small).

Of course South Africa takes this to the extreme giving extremely small ammounts of bandwidth whilst other country's its all fair use ammounts provided.

I would see local traffic not counting at all towards your cap for starters, this would increase interest in local web hosting as many websites use overseas web server for .co.za content due to it being cheaper to host in the US than it is here. I think multiplying the cap options by 5 whilst same price would be fair, eg 2 gig = 20 gig, 3 gig = 15 gig etc...
 
Last edited:
KinsZA said:
I think multiplying the cap options by 5 whilst same price would be fair, eg 2 gig = 20 gig, 3 gig = 15 gig etc...

Huh :confused:

Nope does not sound fair to me at all...
 
I feel that they should only start to enforce capping when you abuse your line with huge downloads and the such.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X