Optimism on prices ‘was naive’

Well problem is gov refuse to get involve openly/regulate yet expect competition with a few protected entities which are out there to make money. You can't have both esp if you have alot to gain from them, tsunami or not.
 
Mr. Guavamint also has his fingers in the SNOT pie. I wonder if SNOT is not set up for failer so Telscum can 'shine'.
 
If someone did some research into Goverment links in all the FreeBEE parts of the SNO I am sure the full picture will be come known.
 
Bah

I have a feeling it just gonna be another Cell C same service, a little crumier & possible more expensive than the rest. I won't be signing any contracts that's for sure..............
 
Basically with SNOT the government (and anc struggle buddies) has baked itself another pie to put it fingers in. Do you think theyll let SNOT actually compete with telkom and lose their precious dividends?
 
Anyone who thought that the introduction of SNOT was going to bring down telecoms prices in a drastic manner was indeed being naive. Why would SNOT do that? This is just another company whose main aim is to make a profit, they're not a charity. SNOT knows that if they offer their (maybe slightly better than Telkom) services with more-or-less the same prices as Telkom, they're also gonna get insane profits simply because (apart from Telkom)there isn't any other company competing with them. It is in their own (and Telkom's) interests to keep telecoms prices high.

We all know what needs to be done. The telecoms sector needs to be opened up completely, not just to two telecoms operators which the Government has shares in. However, opening up the telecoms sector would allow other companies (which the Government won't have any shares in) to operate. And as we all know, the Government won't have that. Is it a coincidence that Sentech (which is a parastatal) will soon be allowed to operate as if it is a TNO? Of course not!
 
mozez said:
Anyone who thought that the introduction of SNOT was going to bring down telecoms prices in a drastic manner was indeed being naive. Why would SNOT do that? This is just another company whose main aim is to make a profit, they're not a charity. SNOT knows that if they offer their (maybe slightly better than Telkom) services with more-or-less the same prices as Telkom, they're also gonna get insane profits simply because (apart from Telkom)there isn't any other company competing with them. It is in their own (and Telkom's) interests to keep telecoms prices high.
I agree.
mozez said:
We all know what needs to be done. The telecoms sector needs to be opened up completely, not just to two telecoms operators which the Government has shares in. However, opening up the telecoms sector would allow other companies (which the Government won't have any shares in) to operate. And as we all know, the Government won't have that. Is it a coincidence that Sentech (which is a parastatal) will soon be allowed to operate as if it is a TNO? Of course not!
This is where we differ. I believe that is only viable in the long term - too much would need to be done otherwise it would be chaos. We need a regulator that actually regulates. We dont need a 101 committees - we need 1 person sitting in Ivy's chair who's willing to say do this now not imminently.
 
the only way we can get out of this is opening up the industry to any one who is interested. Very quickly you will empower small SME's to set up networks in local areas and offering services which they persieve as offering the best profit potential. There will obviously be big player like IS/UUNET but they can focus on providing backhaul and international conncectivity.

The SNO/Telkom business model is dated you don't need to provide all services to all people if you do there will be too much potential to cross subsidise like Telkom is doing now.
 
My point is smaller guys will probably penetrate the last mile much quicker than any big companies and provide better service. IS/Verizon will, should they be allowed to self provide probably focus on their lucrative corporate clients at first.
 
that's where the unbundeling of the Telkom local loop would come in handy. As i see it should telkom be forced like in the uk to give the smaller players access to the local loop they would only need to get links to whomever they choose as thier upstream provider(s). So at a given exchange you may have 5 smaller players playing in the smae market. In time due to competition the players will start investing in local fibre/wireless solutions to compete with their local competitiors.

This is all day dreaming in south africa though :)
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X