ADSL, modem or router?

DjPapzin

Member
Joined
Jan 23, 2016
Messages
19
Reaction score
1
Location
Mafikeng
Hi there,
I recently got a ADSL, so after researching, I found out I need a router and a modem to finally connect to the internet. My question is, do I really need both or I can just get a modem only? I'm intending to use the internet on my computer only.
 
Hi there,
I recently got a ADSL, so after researching, I found out I need a router and a modem to finally connect to the internet. My question is, do I really need both or I can just get a modem only? I'm intending to use the internet on my computer only.

It is a router that is needed. Modem are for analogue lines, DSL is digital and there is no modulation and demodulation. The digital signal is superimposed on top of the analogue line
 
More accurately, the routers that are on offer generally include the modem portion (i.e. have an ADSL port). You can also get so-called WAN routers which have an Ethernet port instead of the ADSL port.

In the past, it was possible to get e.g. USB-ADSL modems, but these are few and far between nowadays. Most people, when referring to ADSL modems, are talking about an ADSL-Ethernet device, with just a single Ethernet port. These are actually also ADSL routers, because they allocate a private IP address to the host(s) connected to the ethernet port, and "route" that IP address out over the ADSL interface.

The major difference, then, between a single port ADSL-Ethernet router, and the more featureful ADSL routers with 4 ports and WiFi, is exactly that. The bigger devices allow wifi clients to connect to them, and support more than one ethernet client connected directly to the router. If you want to be able to do this with a single port ADSL-Ethernet router, you would need to provide your own ethernet switch, and your own wifi access point.

More sophisticated users may prefer to get an ADSL-Ethernet router, and provide the rest of the portions themselves, as this allows them to choose precisely the features that they want, which may not be available in the mass-market combination devices. For instance, they may want more than 4 gigabit ethernet ports, and not care about wifi. So, buying a cheap 8-port gigabit switch, and a single-port ADSL-Ethernet router would suit their purposes better than a combined device.

In your case, I'd suggest getting a simple ADSL router, including Wifi, because at some point in the future, you are likely to want to let your phone connect to ADSL rather than using 3G all the time. These are available quite inexpensively, around R300-R400, which is not much more expensive than the cheapest single-port ADSL-Ethernet routers.
 
.. a simple ADSL router, including Wifi, .. These are available quite inexpensively, around R300-R400, which is not much more expensive than the cheapest single-port ADSL-Ethernet routers.

This is R379 excl VAT & delivery charges (probably R100 to Mafikeng) -

TP-LINK W8961N Wireless N ADSL2+ Modem Router
https://shop.dbg.co.za/td-w8961n.html

.. plus OP can get 10% discount when quoting username on MyBB.

Otherwise, cheapest I've seen recently are R500 each at :

Dion - there's one in Rustenburg (https://www.dionwired.co.za/storefinder) -
a 400km round trip according to Google! ; they have the TP Link 8960N model at that price until the 5th April.

Kloppers have the D-Link 2740 - unfortunately, nowhere near Mafikeng
https://kloppers.co.za/about-kloppers-our-stores

The online option at Uniterm would be the best, I think.
 
The term DSL modem is technically used to describe a modem which connects to a single computer, through an Ethernet Port, USB port, or is installed in a computer PCI slot. The more common DSL router is a standalone device that combines the function of a DSL modem and a router, and can connect multiple computers through multiple Ethernet ports or an integral wireless access point. Also called a residential gateway, a DSL router usually manages the connection and sharing of the DSL service in a home or small office network.

It is a router that is needed. Modem are for analogue lines, DSL is digital and there is no modulation and demodulation. The digital signal is superimposed on top of the analogue line

With ADSL, the modem and the DSLAM communicate by a protocol called discrete multitone modulation (DMT), which is a form of frequency division multiplexing.[2] The modem only uses frequencies above 8 kHz, to avoid interfering with normal phone service. The bandwidth of the line between 8 kHz and about 1 MHz is divided into 247 separate channels, each 4 kHz wide.[2] A separate carrier signal carries information in each channel. Thus the system acts like 247 separate modems operating simultaneously.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DSL_modem
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X