You can view the page at http://mybroadband.co.za/vb/content.php/7873-Live-Mandela-legacy-Obama
South Africa’s biggest forum. Discuss, discover, and connect with thousands of members.
Obama just gave one of the most powerful speeches I've ever heard. "Mandela freed not only the prisoner but also the guard"
Trevor Noah
2 hours ago via mobile
IIRC he said "Mandela freed not only the prisoner but also the jailer"
Pedantic, I know.
But that was a beautiful sentiment that he shared. It was one of the most poignantly insightful speeches I've heard in a long time...
Do you think that Obama actually wrote this speech?
Do you think that Obama actually wrote this speech?
I wonder if Mandela would approve of Obama's insistence on using drones which sometimes murder civilians.
Hmmmm.....
![]()
The willingness of Democrats to embrace and defend this power is especially reprehensible because of how completely, glaringly and obviously at odds it is with everything they loudly claimed to believe during the Bush years. Recall two of the most significant “scandals” of the Bush War on Terror: his asserted power merely to eavesdrop on and detain accused Terrorists without judicial review of any kind. Remember all that? Progressives endlessly accused Bush of Assaulting Our Values and “shredding the Constitution” simply because Bush officials wanted to listen in on and detain suspected Terrorists — not kill them, just eavesdrop on and detain them — without first going to a court and proving they did anything wrong. Yet here is a Democratic administration asserting not merely the right to surveil or detain citizens without charges or judicial review, but to kill them without any of that: a far more extreme, permanent and irreversible act. Yet, with some righteous exceptions, the silence is deafening, or worse.
How can anyone who vocally decried Bush’s mere eavesdropping and detention powers without judicial review possibly justify Obama’s executions without judicial review? How can the former (far more mild powers) have been such an assault on Everything We Stand For while the latter is a tolerable and acceptable assertion of war powers? If Barack Obama has the right to order accused Terrorists executed by the CIA because We’re At War, then surely George Bush had the right to order accused Terrorists eavesdropped on and detained on the same ground.
That the same Party and political faction that endlessly shrieked about Bush’s eavesdropping and detention programs now tolerate Obama’s execution program is one of the most extreme and craven acts of dishonesty we’ve seen in quite some time. By stark contrast, right-wing leaders, pundits and bloggers are being commendably consistent: they cheered for Bush’s due-process-free eavesdropping and detention programs and, based on exactly the same reasoning, they now lavishly praise President Obama for extending that mentality to assassinations.