Bank Charges in SA

Naztyb

Active Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2008
Messages
88
Reaction score
3
Location
Gauteng
Hi

Can anyone tell me why SA banks charge such high service fees. I returned from the UK not too long ago and there I had a UK bank account. I didn't have to pay a cent for any transaction including saswitch ATMs. We only ever paid for transactions on the money machines in food stores etc.

I get the feeling that this is just another way that we as SAs get abused by our services and banking sectors.

:mad:
 
Yep, in SA everyone takes their slice. Here they refer to it as the "Value chain approach" I call it a bunch of BS. I hate the whole idea behind Dealer -> Reseller. And all that crap but not much you can do about it because the people slicing off of the top by adding "value" make sure to keep it that way.
 
Hi

Can anyone tell me why SA banks charge such high service fees. I returned from the UK not too long ago and there I had a UK bank account. I didn't have to pay a cent for any transaction including saswitch ATMs. We only ever paid for transactions on the money machines in food stores etc.

I get the feeling that this is just another way that we as SAs get abused by our services and banking sectors.

:mad:

Welcome back. We get fccked because we got the good weather. It all evens out you see.
 
LOL! If u have R50 in a a8sa savings account, the service and other fees eat it up. 30 years if you had a lil bit of money in a UNITED savings account you got interest on it. Hows that! They ate up all the building societies and now offer worse services.
 
Despite that, welcome back to SA and welcome to the mybroadband forums, Naztyb! :)

Either you take up a bundled offering (a single monthly fee that covers most transactions) from your current bank or you move your banking elsewhere, where there's a lot less RIP-OFF factors, like at:

Capitec
MTN Banking (if you're an MTN customer)
Pick 'n Pay Go Banking

For more info, check their respective websites.

SA banking blog article / discussion:

http://mybroadband.co.za/blogs/2008/04/14/sa-bank-with-the-biggest-online-presence/
 
I transfered some money overseas. R276 fee over and above normal bank charges. Then the exchange rate on the day of transfer was R14.80/GBP. They charged me 15.25/GBP. Ended up paying over 5% of the transfer amount in fees and rip-offs.

It is theft.
 
In the US it sucks too, for me at the moment anyway, no banking costs, everything is free except if you draw money from another bank's ATM, then its like $2 and i have overdrawn my account 4 times this month, and that is $35 immediately and $7 per day until you are in the positive.

Real Chinese math.
 
LOL! If u have R50 in a a8sa savings account, the service and other fees eat it up. 30 years if you had a lil bit of money in a UNITED savings account you got interest on it. Hows that! They ate up all the building societies and now offer worse services.

Yeah, I remember a time when the bank "borrowed" your money, used it to make more money, and "shared" the profit with you in the form of interest. When I was a kid my parents took me to open a savings account. It took me well over a year to break through the R100 balance (pocket money + selling stuff + washing cars + mowing the neighbour's lawn, etc). And all the way I was earning interest. And not the pissy little 1% pa or whatever they pay these days. And it didn't cost money to deposit money.

At some point during my school days I opened a standard bank account because my parents was using standard bank and and when they sent me money it cleared immediately, instead of being lost in a black hole for three days. I stopped using it when I left school - there was still some money in, but not a lot. Several years later, I worked for a company who used standard bank, and there was always a f-up on pay day for everyone who wasn't with standard. So I started using that account again. Well, the first time my salary went into it, I couldn't draw it - my account was in the red! Turns out they've been piling on all sorts of costs just for the privilege of having a savings account. I worked out, at the rates they were charging just to have an account, and the interest they were paying on that particular account at the time, one needed to have R6000 in the bank for the interest to cover the bank charges. That's *without* any transactions. :mad:

Now, for a tale of a different kind. Before I came to the UK the agent who organised my visa hooked me up with an offshore account with a local bank. It's the only type of UK bank account you can easily get without actually living and working here and having utility bills to prove you are in fact a living human being. The account in question cost ÂŁ7 per month, had no other bank charges, but didn't pay much interest, but at least you got interest from the first pound onwards. One morning I wandered into the bank to get a copy of my passport certified. The lady at the counter looked at my card and asked me why I'm using this particular account. I've just never thought of changing - their service was good and I don't get nasty surprises at the end of the month. She asks if I live and work in the UK. Yes, I say. Nooooo! You can get an account that will cost you much less.

OK, I'm confused. My bank wants to save me money? :confused: Well, they set me up with a current account. The entry level one was much cheaper per month, had a better interest rate, and a few extra benefits, including some limited travel insurance. I ended up going for an account a few stops up, which is also ÂŁ7 but pays 6.5% pa, and has benefits including:
* Full international travel insurance for me and my partner
* Full AA breakdown cover
* Cellphone insurance for up to ÂŁ450
and a host more that I didn't even to bother reading through because nothing really interested me. Either ways, the above alone would cost me way more than ÂŁ7 per month, so I'm scoring all the way.

The only transaction fees I've ever paid was when I used my card in S.A. - ÂŁ1 per transaction.

Yeah, S.A. banks are shafting us.
 
"Can anyone tell me why SA banks charge such high service fees."

Because they can. If another bank entered the market and charged reasonably, we would all go to them. Its another monopoly.:sick:

Just think why Barclays bought ABSA. A license to print money which they cannot do in the UK:mad:
 
Buy bank shares while they are cheap now to make your charges back.. :D

That's what I have done. Get some money back. Standard Bank shares are cheapest they have been in about 2 years and well might get cheaper. Aside from the long term upside in the price, you get about a tax free 4.5% dividend.

The guys are absolute thieves. Charged me "commission and transmission fees" of R590 to send R150,000 (in US$) offshore. Up from R550 less than a year ago!

Plus I pay R210 a month for my account! But I have a personal monkey to take care of stuff for me. :)
 
Last edited:
Using the ESO (Electronic Service Option) (I think) with my FNB Cheque account, I never pay more than R85.00 per month. It's really been a big difference from a few years ago when I paid close to R200.00 per month with the equivalent account at Nedbank.

In fact last month, my bank charges were R55.00 in total. That included the R10.00 mandatory service charge.
 
Our Banks have more ATM's blown up and cash in transit heists than most countries.
It makes handling cash expensive.
 
Ya the UK is good, I pay nothing for internet banking,nothing to withdraw money (using any banks atm),nothing to use your card to pay for items.nothing when transfering money between accounts.
 
Hi

Can anyone tell me why SA banks charge such high service fees. I returned from the UK not too long ago and there I had a UK bank account. I didn't have to pay a cent for any transaction including saswitch ATMs. We only ever paid for transactions on the money machines in food stores etc.

I get the feeling that this is just another way that we as SAs get abused by our services and banking sectors.

:mad:

Just for interest sake... why did you return?

If it was me i would do everything in my power not to return to SA.
 
I hate bank charges - in fact I probably use my Barclays Connect Card more than my FNB cheque card.
 
Hi

Can anyone tell me why SA banks charge such high service fees. I returned from the UK not too long ago and there I had a UK bank account. I didn't have to pay a cent for any transaction including saswitch ATMs. We only ever paid for transactions on the money machines in food stores etc.

I get the feeling that this is just another way that we as SAs get abused by our services and banking sectors.

:mad:

Yes it is crazy. But things can be ok if you choose the right bank. My bank costs with ABSA was ~R230 per month. I moved to FNB and I only ended up paying R66 /month with more transactions. The great thing about FNB is that I get around R75 worth of e-bucks per month -so it is a CD every second month which I would have bought anyway, meaning my effect bank costs dropped to zero.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X