Canon 50D vs 1DMark2n vs 7D

I just had both out and the build quality of the 7D is good, but the 1D is just better and the weathersealing on the 1D just looks way better to my eye. Battery and CF/SD slot seals are Rubber seals that look like they can do the job while on the 7D it's a I don't know probably a foam rubber type seal, not solid rubber. On the little joystick there is a visible seal on the 1D while I can't see anything on the 7D. Just pressing a button on the 1D feels more solid.

The 7D is fantastic however and the autofocus is awesome. I would still go for it but just know to not treat it like a 1D. :)

The joystick is sealed:

http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/canoneos7d/page3.asp

The 7D has better sealing than the 40D/50D by Canon's account, and I can tell you from experience that the the 40D and 50D can take a lot of splash. When I was in NY last year, I went out for the Halloween parade, and because I knew there was going to be a lot of people, I didn't take anything other than just the 50D around my shoulder. Well, it started raining, as in big hard hitting drops - the kind we get in Jo'burg during thunderstorms. It rained most of the evening, enough that my press pass disintegrated and mostly all the paper I had in pockets (map etc). Camera was over my shoulder all this time, and it was absolutely soaked on the outside. I was stuck in this massive mob of a crowd, with no chance of getting to cover, so I was outside in direct rain for a bout two hours. When I got back to my hotel, I wiped it down, and removed the lens and opened the battery compartement to check if it got wet. It didn't. Not even the bits under the pop-up flash had any water in.

Similarly, my Scotland trip rained from beginning to start, so the 40D got wet all the time for days on end - no problems.

I think the only thing that makes a difference is L glass (i.e. sealed glass). I wouldn't try that with the 18-200 IS (I had a rented 24-105L in NY).
 
Last edited:
I know it's there, but on every single button on the 1D you can see the seal. Just makes me feel at ease I guess.

Reality doesn't always match perception, eh? I tend to trust seams more than rubber seals. Rubber seals break eventually. :)
 
Something else coming up? I noticed the 50D price dropped a bit over here. £650 is the cheapest right now!
I'm just not sure what it is I'm looking for right now. I knew I wanted the 400Ds, I knew I wanted the 1DMk3, but there's nothing that is drawing me solidly to any of the bodies I'm looking at now.

Maybe if they have a 7D refurb in stock I'll take it . . .
 
But surely that's different - when you bought the 400D and 1DmkIII you were looking for a primary camera.
 
I was actually going to suggest that, but surely that would mean looking at a 1D of sorts?
Apart from sports I think the 7D would cover most of what I would need but since I haven't used one I cant be sure. I'm generally comfortable enough buying on spec but it is a sizeable chuck of change.
 
I'm not naive enough to believe you actually save anything buying duty free.

OK, let me rephrase that: Duty-free window shopping?

I have actually seen some better-than-highstreet deals in Dixons at T3. They sometimes discount stock of discontinued products. I saw a previous model (at the time) MBP there for about £200 less than I could get it anywhere else, including on-line.
 
OK, let me rephrase that: Duty-free window shopping?

I have actually seen some better-than-highstreet deals in Dixons at T3. They sometimes discount stock of discontinued products. I saw a previous model (at the time) MBP there for about £200 less than I could get it anywhere else, including on-line.
I've got a willing buyer landing in NY in less than twelve hours. ;)
 
The 400mm f/2.8 is a lock but I need to find out if it comes with a hard case like they should do.
 
Ok so the 400mm wasn't a lock so I'm looking at the 300mm f2.8 with IS, the 1.4x tc and since I need to make up some of the gap the 7d.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X