killadoob
Honorary Master
How are these speakers, i want to change my 2.1 for the 5.1
What si your budget vincent?
What si your budget vincent?
South Africa’s biggest forum. Discuss, discover, and connect with thousands of members.
After testing and wearing them in, I can definitely recommend these speakers! Had Z4s to compare them with. Listened to a variety of music (IDM/glitch, post-rock, rock, indie, dubstep, classical-influenced) and played a game of Starcraft 2. Will do a more in-depth review in a new thread soon.
All in all, I was sad going back to my Z4s. Music experience is much better on the Krators, without a doubt. Will be ordering mine on Monday.
I'll start with the negatives:
-Left speaker's mid driver did not work properly out of the box. After re-plugging it in, it was 100%. I felt a bit sceptical at that point!
-Volume controls (as well as bass and treble) on the side of the right speaker. A remote would have been great (so used to having one). One would have to use software/keyboard/etc. volume controls unless they lean forward to adjust the volume on the speaker.
-The 4" sub drivers do not produce deep bass that some genres would demand, especially DnB, dubstep ,hip-hop etc., although mostly the bass is above acceptable. The difference in longer bass notes was especially noticeable, although I am used to my boomy Logitech Z4 sub which handles low, long bass much better (due to being 2.1 and the sub being a few inches bigger I guess).
-Driver finishes could be better. Of course, they are no KRK Rockits though.
-Cabling could be a bit thicker.
-No speaker covers (black ones would be nice) although the look did grow on me.
-Regarding warranty, the info seemed to made it clear that speakers are normally repaired instead of swapped-out. Not sure how accurate that is, but I know that Logitech would swap out with no questions asked.
And the positives:
-Music listening is a lot better than 2.1. You really notice the difference that the mid drivers make, the fuller sound. I heard sounds and melodies that I had not heard before on the Z4s.
-Excellent for Starcraft 2 and games that aren't too bass-heavy. I really enjoyed the sounds and directional accuracy in the game I played. FPSes and other bassy games would be a lot more immersive with 2.1. For games that don't need too much bass, Then I think these would be fantastic.
-Very accurate tweeters and treble can be adjusted. I kept it at half-way.
-Bass can be adjusted, also kept at half-way.
-Well built and they feel solid.
-RCA inputs.
-Line in on side of right speaker for iPods etc.
-Good packaging.
How are these speakers, i want to change my 2.1 for the 5.1
What si your budget vincent?
Hi doob
At the moment my budget is around R1000 - though I haven't given that much thought.
What drew me to this set was the price. After reading up the Z4 though, I am now reconsidering.
Surely a 5.1 system should produce better sound quality than a 2.1 regardless of the make?
...so good 2.x speakers will be better for music than cheaper 5.1...
Thanks mate - that clarifies things. In your opinion, would the Z523 suffice for music etc.?
White speakers are fail with a black pc.
My ignorance of speakers is depressing.
P.S. The X530's bass is wholly unstable? So much as to make it a bad purchase?
The Z4s are totally superior to the Z523 (Z4 replacements), but the Z523 will be about the best you can get for their price. If you can deal with the white Z4s you really should get them. Better sub, satellites, and volume/bass control. I actually bought a set of Z4i just because my Z4 are so good, that are still in the box.
The X530 are rated pretty highly in terms of value for money, but the Z523 will be better for music.
Hi Postman. I've since read a few reviews on the Z4... and, well they rock
I've found a black set for R885 and plan on finalising the purchase tomorrow.
http://www.vexon.co.za/Audio/Speake...tt-RMS-PC-Gaming-Consoles-Remote-Control.html
Your help was much appreciated, thanks!
Hey Postman
Z4i :/ What got me excited was the numerous hits on PriceCheck. I've contacted a few other stores and am awaiting reply.
If someone still has them in stock I'll let you know, though it seems the 523's are in order.
Where you located?
I work in PC retail and I can honestly say the newer Logitechs are rubbish compared to the previous generation ones. They sound very hollow and the new airhole design does nothing for them.
X530's are still around for good reason
Divoom's are cheap but decent for the price.
I am not a huge fan of Creative speakers, they look cheap and don't sound so great.