Draconian DRM Revealed In Windows 7

LazyLion

King of de Jungle
Joined
Mar 17, 2005
Messages
107,596
Reaction score
10,237
Location
District 9
http://tech.slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=09/02/16/2259257

TechForensics writes "A few days' testing of Windows 7 has already disclosed some draconian DRM, some of it unrelated to media files. A legitimate copy of Photoshop CS4 stopped functioning after we clobbered a nagging registration screen by replacing a DLL with a hacked version. With regard to media files, the days of capturing an audio program on your PC seem to be over (if the program originated on that PC). The inputs of your sound card are severely degraded in software if the card is also playing an audio program (tested here with Grooveshark). This may be the tip of the iceberg. Being in bed with the RIAA is bad enough, but locking your own files away from you is a tactic so outrageous it may kill the OS for many persons. Many users will not want to experiment with a second sound card or computer just to record from online sources, or boot up under a Linux that supports ntfs-3g just to control their files." Read on for more details of this user's findings.

Re — Photoshop: That Photoshop stopped functioning after we messed with one of its nag DLLs was not so much a surprise, but what was a surprise: Noting that Win7 allows programs like Photoshop to insert themselves stealthily into your firewall exception list. Further, that the OS allows large software vendors to penetrate your machine. Even further, that that permission is responsible for disabling of a program based on a modified DLL. And then finding that the OS even after reboot has locked you out of your own Local Settings folder; has denied you permission to move or delete the modified DLL; and refuses to allow the replacement of the Local Settings folder after it is unlocked with Unlocker to move it to the Desktop for examination (where it also denies you entry to your own folder). Setting permissions to 'allow everyone' was disabled!

Re — media: Under XP you could select 'Stereo Mix' or similar under audio recording inputs and nicely capture any program then playing. No longer.

Why am I not surprised? :(

If this is true... I for one will not be forking out over R1000 for a broken OS. :mad:
 
how is this broken ? you shouldn't pirate in the first place :p

there is always the virtual pc solution....
 
that is rather sucky. XP for life it is then.....
 
OK, reading some of the comments in the comment section, this guy is known for posting some pretty whacky stuff. They are lambasting him for not giving any screen shots of back-up sources. So take it with a pinch of salt.

Anyone want to conduct their own tests? ... and post the results here for us?

btw, Necuno... this has nothing to do with piracy. The tester owned all of the content that he was copying. Fair Use.
 
That isn't even an article, or any not worthy piece of information. I agree with the commenters, that guy's a n00b.

Why did he need to copy a hacked dll if he owned the software? With what program did he try to record audio?

All in all, I'd say his stupid cracks aren't functioning on W7. N00B!!
 
Ja, I would wait a bit and see what gives.

After all the beta of Windows7 went off without any hitches - and now this guy pitches in...

I'm a linux fan, but even so I'll take this report with an extremely large pinch of salt until it is proven beyond any reasonable doubt that it indeed is the case...
 
They are lambasting ... So take it with a pinch of salt.

is This a Win7 thread or a cooking class?:confused:

I hope it's NOT true though - don't like to be shut out of my own system and stuff.
 
This sums it all up pretty neatly :

Agreed. For all we know, the problems this guy is having with his sound card are due to a driver bug or incompatibility rather than an intentional crippling of the audio, while the problems he's having with Photoshop and the problems with his Local Settings folder are due to introducing foreign code that messes up Windows in ways that Microsoft could not have anticipated.

Besides... why would the current version of Photoshop be coded against undocumented features in still unreleased Windows 7?

I am Willing to abandon Windows over draconian DRM, but I want evidence of that before I'll lambast Microsoft for it.
 
Boy am I glad that I finally took the plunge. Learning about the mac, messing with ubuntu. It took a long, long time to wean myself off but I've finally kicked the habit. I'm just so grateful there are alternatives. Up to recently I felt like a battered wife, hating Windows but still using it. Such a relief. (not trying to troll, just stating how I feel. For those who want to stay on Windows, my condolences.)

ROFL
 
Adobe CS 2 (Piratebay issue) running fine on Windows 7 here. No probblems with mp3 or other media files either. And it really pains me as an out and out linux fanboi to say it.

I want win7 to break. I want to prove what a piece of shirt it is but the damn thing just wont break. :mad:
 
DRM or not?

I recently added one of my old backup drives to a Win7 configured PC just to find I cannot access any of the "My documents and settings folders" Even after changing ownership and Modifying permissions. Placing the disk back in a XP environment on another PC gave me back my file access again without issues.

I think there is a learning curve to go through rather than anything else. I love Win7 and in future will just bring over files via the network

Now thats another topic/story altogether, The "Network". :eek:
 
Last edited:
I don't think people should be calling these "lock out" issues DRM. I doubt DRM has anything to do with it and, as he admits in his update, the Photoshop issues was unrelated. Most likely security measures.
 
If there were any substance to the story we'd have heard the serious testers scream from Day One of the 7000 beta. We all know the media content owners have for years been pressuring MS for more stringent DRM protection for their content, something Apple has had for ages. And, yes, there absolutely has to be better security management, which unsurprisingly and indeed correctly should shut out modified or unregistered DLLs, as well as less secure legacy file and folder permissions (where ownership should be taken under the tighter security regime). Etcetera.
 
The "DRM" issue is not unique to Windows 7. I'm currently having a similar experience with Win Server 2008 SP1 - it is just refusing to copy a specific .exe file to anywhere in the filesystem, claiming I have insufficient permissions, even when logged on as Administator.

I take his claims with a shovel of salt. No, wait, he is shoveling salt...
 
If there were any substance to the story we'd have heard the serious testers scream from Day One of the 7000 beta. We all know the media content owners have for years been pressuring MS for more stringent DRM protection for their content, something Apple has had for ages. And, yes, there absolutely has to be better security management, which unsurprisingly and indeed correctly should shut out modified or unregistered DLLs, as well as less secure legacy file and folder permissions (where ownership should be taken under the tighter security regime). Etcetera.

Umm it's Microsoft which is the one which does not allow you to convert DRMed WMV/A files to non-DRM'ed ones. Itunes allows you to burn DRM files to CD
and those you can re-encode as DRM-FREE AAC, OGG, MP3 or FLAC files.
ITMS now sells DRM free music, while MS has screwed over it's content partners and customers by having the Zune reject PlayForSure,
while the recent Microsoft mobile song store in the UK does not allow you to transfer purchased songs from old to new cell phone.

Jobbs has called Blu-Ray a 'big bag of hurt' while MS has jumped aboard with Hollywood approved DRM in Vista and no doubt 7.

Come on Arthur :).
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X