Education Department bugger up again!

Fazda

Honorary Master
Joined
Apr 24, 2009
Messages
11,414
Reaction score
35
Location
/\/¯¯¯¯¯\/\
This is just one more example that shows that the people running Education in this country have not got the slightest idea as to what is going on in the classroom!!

http://www.iol.co.za/index.php?set_...7338C503191&newslett=1&em=166117a1a20090520ah
By Angelique Serrao

In just two weeks, all Grade 9 pupils across the country will be expected to write national exams - exams that teachers and pupils were not told about.

Previous minister of education Naledi Pandor announced last year that there would be a national exam set for Grade 9 and they would get a General Education Certificate qualification at the end of the year.

Grade 9 is an important educational year as many pupils leave school at this stage as they turn 16.

But teachers say they were informed about this exam only last week - 24 days before the exams are to start on June 1.

Grade 9s have written end-of-year exams in previous years, but the new exams - known as SATs (Standardised Assessment Tasks) - are now being written in the middle of the year. [ MORE ACRONYMS!!!:rolleyes:]

Teachers in Gauteng spoke to The Star this week, saying they couldn't believe they were informed only last week about the SATs; that they were not prepared for the tests; and that once the pupils found out about them, there would be "panic and pandemonium".

A teacher who spoke to The Star on condition of anonymity said teachers felt the department of education "had lost the plot" on this issue.

"As a teacher, I'm not against changes to the Grade 9 CTA assessment programme, but I do object to the short notice period we've been given and the lack of consultation," she said.

'We simply won't be ready'
"I find it very concerning that the people in charge of our national education policy think it's acceptable and feasible to make such big changes at such short notice. I think it's going to be a disaster if they force us to go ahead with the SATs. We simply won't be ready."The maths teacher said many educators teach their subjects in different orders, so there were three large sections in the SATs that pupils had never been taught.

The teacher also said the Gauteng department was making available only one set of copies for each school, so now schools had to make photocopies for every Grade 9 pupil in all eight subjects. This was a huge expense that schools had not budgeted for.

What worried the teacher the most was telling her pupils about the exams so late - especially as they count for a quarter of the year mark.

Education Department spokesperson Dr Granville Whittle said the Grade 9 assessment had been moved to the second term to try to avoid the backlogs that occur at the end of the year.

"This is the first year that we have asked to do this, but we did say that if schools don't complete all the tasks, they can spill over into the third term," Whittle said.

Professor Mary Metcalfe, the head of education at Wits University, said that if it was true that the department had given so little warning for the SATs, then the department "show so little understanding of the context and environment that teachers work in".

Council of South African Students chairperson Wesley Kgang, on hearing about the SAT dates, said the department was "totally mad".
 
To avoid the backlog at the end of the year they'd rather have pupils sit for an exam they are not prepared for???
What a very strange decision.
 
To avoid the backlog at the end of the year they'd rather have pupils sit for an exam they are not prepared for???
What a very strange decision.

Just another example of these Education Department idiots diving into something headfirst without considering the consequences.

They have been making decisions like this since '94, with utter disregard for what is actually happening in the classrooms. It is ONLY thanks to an excellent network of very good teachers that the Education system hasn't collapsed into total disarray since the ANC took over!
 
Some chap was on 702 and he said that it wasn't an exam but an assessment task.

Of course that could be edakashun department speak for pop exam.
 
Grade 9 CTA's hmm! you need half a braincell to pass those.

Might be.. but don't you think that the teachers being worried is a concern for the pupils too?
If the teachers weren't worried... then neither would the public/parents/students
The incompetence of the ANC/Education department must come to an end
 
Might be.. but don't you think that the teachers being worried is a concern for the pupils too?
If the teachers weren't worried... then neither would the public/parents/students
The incompetence of the ANC/Education department must come to an end

Very definitely...having spent time reading through previous OBE papers, a great deal is set on specific work that is meant to be taught to the kids from booklets provided by the government.

An A student would probably sail through them with his eyes shut, but an average student is going to have a problem particularly as much of it is booklet specific, rather than general knowledge.

Just a prime example of ANC Education Rubbish!
 
Perfect example of the media blowing sht out of preportion :(

I'm no fan of the education department (they're a serious bunch of chops as far as I'm concerned) but seriously ... these are not "exams" as we understand that term. More like what the old ballies amongst us would understand a "project" to be. Students cannot actually study and prepare for CTA's. They are given things to read through, some research to carry out based on the info in the CTA and then they complete tasks in class individually as well as in groups... plus it's all teacher led.

Teachers, parents and media making a big hulabaloo over this have had their heads up their @rses for the last 6 months (and the teachers for the last 4-odd years that CTA's have been running )
 
Hoof Hearted : So moving the CTA's forward by a few months on incredibly short notice is acceptable to you?

I must admit i think OBE is a pile of rubbish and was one of the biggest mistakes undertaken by the current Education crew.... but we have to make it work now, and doing carp like this is NOT helping.
 
@ Toxic
The nature of the CTA's makes moving them earlier a non-event. What difference does it make whether they are written at the end of June or the end of September?
It's not like the gr9's are all of a sudden going to need to learn a whole lot more in a shorter period of time and it's not like they have to write next week

I'm in no way trying to defend the ED .. as far as I'm concerned they're a bunch of fskwits who are responsible for the entire country having to contend with a substandard education system.

I just get p!ssed with media BS making a mountain out of a mole-hill.
 
Last edited:
@ Toxic
The nature of the CTA's makes moving them earlier a non-event. What difference does it make whether they are written at the end of June or the end of September?
It's not like the gr9's are all of a sudden going to need to learn a whole lot more in a shorter period of time and it's not like they have to write next week

Hoof-Hearted, it is patently obvious that your experience of a classroom is that of a student rather than a teacher!

Ther is a syllabus to be completed and very specific guidelines as to how long it has to take. CTA's have always been a pain in the butt from a teaching point of view, but it is rubbish that can be covered AFTER covering the main syllabus and possibly getting some sense into kids' heads!

Jamming it in to the middle of the year has obviously NOT been thought out at all....try standing at the sharp end of a classroom for a while before passing any more inane comments!
 
Big fuss over nothing. Even if these were exams 24 days is more than adequate time to study.
 
These Grade 9 exams are a big joke. Grade 12 should be the requirement, not Grade 9.
 
Hoof-Hearted, it is patently obvious that your experience of a classroom is that of a student rather than a teacher!

Ther is a syllabus to be completed and very specific guidelines as to how long it has to take. CTA's have always been a pain in the butt from a teaching point of view, but it is rubbish that can be covered AFTER covering the main syllabus and possibly getting some sense into kids' heads!

Jamming it in to the middle of the year has obviously NOT been thought out at all....try standing at the sharp end of a classroom for a while before passing any more inane comments!

Fazda I've been involved in teaching and training for over 20 years. I was involved in focus groups / commitees / sub-comittees / sub-focus-commitee-groups (govt loves the BS) that originally set those CTA's up (or at least conceived of them) ... eventually giving it up in disgust at the absolute waste of time and effort that the ED had made them into.

My problem is with the way this issue has been reported. Sure it's an inconvenience, sure it could have happened later in the year... but there's no way the CTA's are exams that pupils have to spend weeks preparing for or that parents need to get their nickers in a knot over. What "sense" do you need to get into gr9 kids heads before they are able to do research and what are essentially open-book comprehension tests (and I use that term loosely)

[For the record, I think the CTA's are a load of worthless BS ]
 
Last edited:
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X