Fed-up client takes on Telkom

IzZzy

Executive Member
Joined
Feb 17, 2004
Messages
5,934
Reaction score
105
Location
Sandton
Straight from http://www.iol.co.za/index.php?set_id=1&click_id=13&art_id=vn20051128121112196C555477

Monica Laganparsad
November 28 2005 at 12:33PM


"An irate customer has taken on telecommunications giant Telkom in a court battle that has exposed the widespread abuse of clip-on fraud.

Callie Geel from the Bluff, and owner of Yellowstone Kitchens, is fighting the fixed line monopoly for R2 000 worth of disputed phone calls made on his home telephone line.

Earlier this year Geel obtained a temporary order in the Durban High Court stopping Telkom from suspending his business line.

It began when Geel queried an unusually large bill and his investigation revealed that a Theuns Pretorius, who helped out a Telkom contractor, had tapped into Geel's home line. Pretorius has since gone missing.


Click Here to get R100 FREE @ African Palace Internet Casino

Because Telkom could not locate Pretorius as an existing employee, it told Geel it would suspend both his business and home line.

Geel in the initial application said the suspension of his business line would be crucial and detrimental to his business. The order was granted and Telkom was prevented from suspending the line.

Telkom has opposed the application and in its court papers Shamaladevi Singh, manager of Telkom's legal services sets out the company's standard Terms of Condition.

"If the customer has by the due date not paid any amounts due to Telkom for the service, in which case Telkom may also suspend any other service provided to the customer.

"It is, with respect, selfevident that if the alleged unauthorised use was carried out by someone other than an employee or Telkom agent, Geel was bound to pay for the calls and seek redress against the perpetrator," she said.

An analysis of the controversial bill showed that including the rental and calls, the final amount came to R3 629.17.

In total 184 calls were made, but Geel is disputing an amount of R2 595,10.

Geel has paid the balance of R564,01, which he says he owed.

Telkom's own investigation revealed that three of the disputed cellphone numbers were calls made by Helen Mass, Pretorius's former girlfriend in Volksrust.

Mass said Pretorius was never an employee of Telkom. However, in Geel's replying papers he says he hired a private investigator who discovered that Pretorius worked for Mass's step-father, Johan Nel, a contractor to Telkom.

Nel in an affidavit said he went to England and left Pretorius in charge of the business. When he returned some of his equipment was missing and so was Pretorius.

Geel, in his replying papers, said Telkom never made him aware nor provided him with a copy of their terms and con-ditions.

"My investigation has shown that widespread abuse occurs through the unlawful use of Telkom's equipment, referred to in the trade as clip-on fraud," he said.

Geel explained that Pretorius used Telkom equipment to clip on to his line.

"Telkom's investigation seems to have been a cover up for the abuse of its unsecured lines and amounts to an unlawful attempt to have a consumer pay for clip-on fraud," said Geel.

"The unacceptable nature of such conduct is further highlighted by the fact that Telkom has huge resources available to properly investigate such complaints, that it is profitable as demonstrated by the fact that its Chief Executive Officer alone last year earned an annual salary and bonus of R11-million," he said.

Telkom has the option of filing further papers before it is set down for argument."




Go Mr Geel!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Good. While I was waiting for a phone line fault to be repaired I could hear someone talking on my line for at least an hour. I reported it to Telkom immediately and I was told to raise a dispute when I get my account which I did. At least I got creditted because I had a reference number. It transpired that the Telkom guys allow their buddies to use Telkom equipment for free calls.
 
Seems fairly cut and dried: Telkom Contractor = Telkom, therefore according to Telkoms own Terms & Conditions, they're liable ... but I wonder how cut & dried it will be after the lawyers have finished with it :( .

Good luck Mr. Geel.
 
Just had another thought on this subject:

Most (if not all) overseas telcos provide a form of protection against clip-on fraud.

The telcos monitor your calling habits i.e. if you normally only made local and national calls, and suddenly they registered several calls to Abu Dhabi this would raise a red flag on their system. Even your call costs rising significantly from your norm, is enough to raise a warning flag.

They would then contact you within hours to determine if you had made these calls. If you hadn't made the calls, steps would then be taken to trace the source of the calls and you wouldn't be liable for the call costs.

So, not only do I think Telkom is liable in this case because one of their contractors made the calls, but I think they're liable because they aren't following industry best practice.
 
They in fact do monitor the call pattern, using various software systems like FMS (Fraud Management System). They just don't give a ****, 'cos somebody is generating revenue, illegal or not.
I had an "official" line for IT support purposes. They failed to disconnect when I resigned, even though they were informed in writing. Well, 6 months later I got the bill for 6 months rental on an ISDN line, plus interest. Their point of view? "You did not ensure that the line was disconnect". The problem here is that THEY own the line, so I COULDN'T disconnect. Go figure. Mobile rules.
 
Jelo said:
I had an "official" line for IT support purposes. They failed to disconnect when I resigned, even though they were informed in writing. Well, 6 months later I got the bill for 6 months rental on an ISDN line, plus interest.

I'm not sure I follow you here, Jelo. Did you work for a company that made you put your office line in YOUR name :eek: ?

If so, I must admit to regarding that as lower than ANYTHING Telkom has done.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X