Morgoth:
What you fail or just dont want to understand is that initiation has some greatly positive effects if implemented correctly but only if it is done at tertiary education level. I was at hostel back when it was still allowed to initiate first years, and one thing I saw is is that because of the initiation hostel had no racial problems whatsoever.
It's a multi-racial hostel, all first years were treated equally, everyone suffered equally but rarely too much, and if anyone suffered its because he asked for it. That alone created a comeradery amoungst the first years and we never did anything against each other because of anything as trivial as race.
Granted the final initiation was harsh but in retrospect it was just a type of controlled gauntlet, bad but not as bad as advertised and you get over it quickly, hell I got over it the very same night. That alone gave the first years who decided to brave it, myself included, a amount of self respect.
Of course we were never forced to do anything exessive, if something like that was ever required there were allways more than enough volunteers.
And lastly the initiation traditions of the hostel also acted as a buffer against the chaos that normally happens when a youth lives outside his parent's house for the first time, that alone proves its usefullness. Hell before I stayed at the hostel I was a snot nosed brat from a small town, if not for the structure and character building enviroment I would have never become so comfortable with city life so easely in such a safe manner.
No my friend, if you dont like initiation u were obviously subjected to either a bad initiation or you have the guts of a worm