Has the City of Cape Town's R263 million Hospital Bend project made any difference to traffic congestion on the way home?
This is the announcement the city made on April 22, 2010:
"After seven years of planning and two years of complex construction work, Capetonians can now look forward to using the newly completed Hospital Bend Interchange, which is expected to greatly ease traffic flow to and from the city.
"Today is a very special day for the City of Cape Town and our citizens. I am sure that in a few weeks time when the commuting public get used to the new formation of Hospital Bend they would have forgotten the challenges and difficulties we all had to negotiate the old lane formation," said Councillor Elizabeth Thompson, Mayoral Committee Member for Transport, Roads and Major Projects, who officially opened the new interchange on 22 April 2010.
Capetonians have already had a taste of how this new interchange will work, after the De Waal Drive bridge, pre-selection lanes and Anzio Road bridge opened for traffic over the past two weeks. It is expected to take a while for traffic patterns to stabilise as motorists become used to the new situation and decide on new regular routes.
This project, which was completed on time and within its budget of R263 million (excluding VAT), has become one of the City of Cape Town's flagship transport infrastructure projects."
So now it is a few weeks later, how do things look? Are we happy with the results?
Well, to be honest, incoming traffic flow from Settlers Way does seem better. The added lane under the bridge before hospital bend has reduced the congestion at the Liesbeek parkway feed onto Settlers Way. Hooray. Thank you.
But going home? Not so great. Every single day since the opening, traffic is backed up from the start of De Waal Drive and Eastern Boulevard right through to Hospital Bend. From 4 o' clock until well past 6 o'clock. EVERY SINGLE DAY.
Going home is no fun anymore. Clearly this is a capitalist plot. Coming in to work is easier, going home is really a pain.
So why is there still congestion outbound every day? It's because, despite spending R263m on fancy bridges and pre-selection lanes, the Hospital Bend is still a bottleneck, as it always was. (Admittedly a bottleneck with R263m pre-selection lanes which must count for something.)
Traffic backs up for kilometres before the bend and then after (or around) the bend, the traffic flows freely once more. And why is there still a bottleneck? Because traffic using 5 lanes (3 from Eastern Boulevard and 2 from De Waal Drive) is forced into 4 lanes on Hospital Bend and then opens back up to 5 or 6 lanes (3 on Settlers Way and 2/3 on M3).
Even a rocket scientist can understand that 5 lanes of traffic squeezed into 4 will cause congestion. (We have all seen that anytime a vehicle breaks down and blocks a lane, congestion occurs on a multilane highway in peak traffic.)
So, I would like the City to answer:
? How can the City undertake a multimillion Rand project without addressing the most fundamental problem of homeward bound congestion, pre-selection lanes notwithstanding?
? How is it that the entire 'pre-selection' very costly infrastructure (R263m) has not made the slightest difference to the congestion problems we have always had? In fact it seems to have gotten worse.
? So why did we spend R263m just so we can pre-select which lane to get stuck in?
Somebody should get fired. We could have spent R263m on housing and services for the less fortunate citizens we have among us.
If you ask me, the bridges were built to show what fantastic world-class engineers and builders we have, capable of tackling the most complex projects. We have world-class bridges with world-class pre-selection lanes and world-class congestion as a result.
Well done Cape Town, kudos for you.