Neighbours angry about slaughter

Djtay

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 18, 2009
Messages
462
Reaction score
0
http://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/Neighbours-angry-about-slaughter-20100927

Port Elizabeth - Residents of Bluewater Bay, an upmarket suburb in PE, are furious after a beast was slaughtered in a garden as part of a cultural ritual over the weekend.

Maureen Gardiner of Claude Crescent said she and other neighbours were traumatised by the incident.

"The animal was tied to a pole on Friday night and on Saturday was dragged down the road on a rope before it was later slaughtered in an open garden in front of everyone.

"The screaming of that animal is still haunting me. Our own pets were so traumatised that they don't even bark anymore.

"It is really not fair towards animal lovers like ourselves," said Gardiner.

"All of us here have our own culture and we should respect one another. We are no longer in the dark ages."

Permission

Gardiner, who lives across the road from these neighbours, reported the incident to police.

Officials then showed her a letter from the municipality in which these residents were given permission to perform the ritual on their property.

Municipal spokesperson Kupido Baron said on Sunday that the metro supported the right of residents to perform cultural practices, especially if they were responsible and informed the municipality about their intentions in advance.

But DA councillor Terry Herbst was irate because he felt residents had not been informed in time about the matter.

According to the letter of permission, a municipal official issued the notice on September 21 in which residents were informed that a cultural slaughter and ceremony would be held on September 24 and 25.

Professor Hennie van As, legal expert at the Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University, said he believed notice three days ahead of an event was sufficient.
 
If the dude asked for permission and sent a warning around you really have no right to complain. It is their property.

Would have been nice to have tranquilised or stunned the thing first though. Surely that wouldn't impact on the symbolism of the ceremony?
 
Would have been nice to have tranquilised or stunned the thing first though. Surely that wouldn't impact on the symbolism of the ceremony?

Unfortunately (to those offended by the ritual), when the cow or goat does not cry, its a big issue and the ceremony will not continue.
 
Last edited:
All of us here have our own culture and we should respect one another.

My fellow white people seem to greatly lack the ability to comprehend the irony of their words, along with the fact that 'respect' in these cases almost always invokes a 'do what is appropriate according to white culture' standard.

Anyone is welcome to do a similar ritual in my street. Hopefully it could finally stop my neighbour's dogs from barking almost non-stop.
 
No in a neighbourhood with lots of houses close together its not sanitary to slaughter an animal like that. This is something that should be done in a veld far away from dwellings.
 
Unfortunately (to those offended by the ritual), when the cow or goat does not cry, its a big issue and the ceremony will not continue.

oh... poor creature.

Do you know why it has to cry? I am now morbidly fascinated.
 
Because otherwise the great juju in the sky does not accept the sacrifice.

Probably to let the gods know that it was indeed sacrificed :D

The gods are either cruel or blind and therefore need to hear it because they can't see it.

Seriously though killing the animal while it is aware like that is not something I agree with. If you're going to kill it kill it quickly and humanely. To draw out suffering and make it cry out... disturbing. Unless they are violating some sort of animal cruelty law (I ain't no lawyer) I don't see why they shouldn't be allowed to do it though. It strikes me as unusually cruel but realistically they sought permission and sent out warnings.
 
I just have to roll my eyes...

Some d00s pulls up to the PnP on Friday and gets out of his black 325i in nothing but a loincloth, feathers in his hair and Nike's :rolleyes:

Personally I think that its unacceptable. Public nudity and animal slaughter. If you want to carry on like that you should drop the beamer, the nike's and the upmarket suburb and do it in the bush: with a donkey, barefoot by a mudhut.
 
From the article it doesn't look like they actually went to every neighbour and asked if it would be "ok". They seem to have gotten the permission from the local council only, and did not consider their neighbours at all. Getting permission from the council is all good and dandy, but that should be the last step after you got approval from your neighbours. Maybe if all the neighbours were informed, they could have made plans to be away from home if it offended them.

Respecting peoples cultures is a two way street, but it looks to me, like the neighbours didn't know about the ritual taking place before hand.
 
I just have to roll my eyes...

Some d00s pulls up to the PnP on Friday and gets out of his black 325i in nothing but a loincloth, feathers in his hair and Nike's :rolleyes:

Personally I think that its unacceptable. Public nudity and animal slaughter. If you want to carry on like that you should drop the beamer, the nike's and the upmarket suburb and do it in the bush: with a donkey, barefoot by a mudhut.

It's his money that bought the beemer and the house in the surburbs...If you don't like it YOU can move. It was Heritage day FFS.
 
It's his money that bought the beemer and the house in the surburbs...If you don't like it YOU can move. It was Heritage day FFS.

LOL. Hows a beamer and a house in the suburbs part of his heritage? It was Heritage day FFS!
 
oh... poor creature.

Do you know why it has to cry? I am now morbidly fascinated.

Seeing that this happened in PE, I can assume it was a Xhosa cultural ritual. It is believed in Xhosa tradition that the crying of the cattle or goat shows the acceptance of the offer by the spiritual world. If it does not cry, it is regarded as a sign of rejection of the ritual by the spiritual world and everything will be stopped.

The slaughter of a cattle often means the ceremony is a big deal that involves the clan. A goat is normally slaughtered in ceremony where an individual is affected e.g. During initiation
 
Last edited:
Our own pets were so traumatised that they don't even bark anymore.

Will The Dog Whisperer be able to help these animals? Will the neighbors who have found peace at night block his attempts? Does anyone care if the meat tasted good? Find out on the next episode.
 
Seeing that this happened in PE, I can assume it was a Xhosa cultural ritual. It is believed in Xhosa tradition that the crying of the cattle or goat shows the acceptance of the offer by the spiritual world. If it does not cry, it is regarded as a sign of rejection of the ritual by the spiritual world and everything will be stopped.

The slaughter of a cattle often means the ceremony is a big deal that involves the clan. A goat is normally slaughtered in ceremony where an individual is affected e.g. During initiation

Interesting. Thanks for the information. I didn't know that.
 
Will The Dog Whisperer be able to help these animals? Will the neighbours who have found peace at night block his attempts? Does anyone care if the meat tasted good? Find out on the next episode.

OMG! This turned out to be a great Monday for lolz :D
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X