PC vs PlayStation 4 vs Xbox One cost comparison

I think right now a console is better value for gaming than a gaming PC
 
I used to be a die hard PC gamer - consoles were a joke - but I wanted to scream every time there was a new release and I had to upgrade my GPU to play on full detail or my CPU or RAM to meet minimum requirements. I then bought a PS3 just for the knowledge that whatever is released for the platform will play and look as the developers intended.

Truth be told I still crave the keyboard and mouse action of my pc and often switch it on for a bit of Counter Strike, but for the new titles I'm lost to that platform.

The PS3 fills a gap, but I still struggle to enjoy the controls - If I could play PS3 (FPS) titles with a keyboard and mouse - it would be the best for me.
 
As long as you choose your components for a PC wisely there is no real need to majorly upgrade within 5 years. Still rocking my I7 920 and 5850 from 5 years ago. Basically has cost me R200 a month. I do have a ps3 but I mainly use that when friends come over and we play indi local multiplayer games etc...
 
I think right now a console is better value for gaming than a gaming PC

HAHA

Not a chance.

PS4/Xbone have a very limited catalog at the moment and are still way overpriced and mostly remakes. (Ill include WiiU in this even though its cheaper and has more games)
PS3 /XB360 are cheaper now and their games are cheaper but only has value if you have kept a PS+ or XBL sub... also not a lot of new games for these consoles

You can build a gaming PC for the price of a PS4 + steam = the best value for money
 
HAHA

Not a chance.

PS4/Xbone have a very limited catalog at the moment and are still way overpriced and mostly remakes. (Ill include WiiU in this even though its cheaper and has more games)
PS3 /XB360 are cheaper now and their games are cheaper but only has value if you have kept a PS+ or XBL sub... also not a lot of new games for these consoles

You can build a gaming PC for the price of a PS4 + steam = the best value for money

/thread
 
HAHA

Not a chance.

PS4/Xbone have a very limited catalog at the moment and are still way overpriced and mostly remakes. (Ill include WiiU in this even though its cheaper and has more games)
PS3 /XB360 are cheaper now and their games are cheaper but only has value if you have kept a PS+ or XBL sub... also not a lot of new games for these consoles

You can build a gaming PC for the price of a PS4 + steam = the best value for money

Not sue you can build a PC for under 6000 that will be able to match the PS4 in terms of graphics , near impossible if you factor in the cost of an OS
 
Not sue you can build a PC for under 6000 that will be able to match the PS4 in terms of graphics , near impossible if you factor in the cost of an OS

There are a few threads here on how it can be done. I'm on my phone now so it's had to link. You can actually do 4k gaming for the price of a ps4.
My rig is 2 years old and still kicks a ps4 in the glory hole.
 
I used to be a die hard PC gamer - consoles were a joke - but I wanted to scream every time there was a new release and I had to upgrade my GPU to play on full detail or my CPU or RAM to meet minimum requirements. I then bought a PS3 just for the knowledge that whatever is released for the platform will play and look as the developers intended.

Truth be told I still crave the keyboard and mouse action of my pc and often switch it on for a bit of Counter Strike, but for the new titles I'm lost to that platform.

The PS3 fills a gap, but I still struggle to enjoy the controls - If I could play PS3 (FPS) titles with a keyboard and mouse - it would be the best for me.

Dude your doing it wrong!
My PC is 9yrs old with only 2 upgrades ... changed gpu, previous one died on me and put in an
SSD - still playing BF4 and i meet min req for hardline and i still have room for a yr or 2 more.

That said i got a Xbox one and i just cant get myself to pay 900 for a std edition game it pains me
when i think that the same game on pc is only about 400.

PC is still the best and with steam .... nothing better!
 
Last edited:
Not sue you can build a PC for under 6000 that will be able to match the PS4 in terms of graphics , near impossible if you factor in the cost of an OS

It's not hard to match 720p @ 30fps...
 
The article stinks. Comparing the cost of brand new and pre-order games is not a fair reflection of the cost of purchasing games on each platform. PC absolutely annihilates consoles when it comes to game prices. Another issue is the cost of the PC. A gaming PC is also a PC, so you should account for the amount that you would otherwise have spent on a non-gaming system.

I would never buy a desktop PC with less than a midrange processor, 27" monitor, adequate RAM etc, and I bought an SSD, nice mouse and mechanical keyboard for primarily non-gaming purposes. For me, the hardware cost of PC gaming was only around R4k - R3k for a graphics card (R4k new card minus R1k for outgoing card that I sold) and another grand for a gaming headset.

I've saved crazy money since switching from PS3 to PC a few years ago. If PC gaming costs you more than console gaming it can only be because you bought an insane rig (which isn't a bad thing - good for you) or because you're clueless or unconcerned about game prices.

I used to be a die hard PC gamer - consoles were a joke - but I wanted to scream every time there was a new release and I had to upgrade my GPU to play on full detail or my CPU or RAM to meet minimum requirements. I then bought a PS3 just for the knowledge that whatever is released for the platform will play and look as the developers intended.

Truth be told I still crave the keyboard and mouse action of my pc and often switch it on for a bit of Counter Strike, but for the new titles I'm lost to that platform.

The PS3 fills a gap, but I still struggle to enjoy the controls - If I could play PS3 (FPS) titles with a keyboard and mouse - it would be the best for me.

The only way you could have an issue with your hardware frequently is if you bought absolutely crap stuff. You don't have to spend that much for a PC to be good for 4-5 years. My last PC lasted 4.5 years, and my current one will last around the same.

That said, you might want to consider making the Xbox One your current gen console of choice. It lets you stream the XB1 games to a Windows PC.

I think right now a console is better value for gaming than a gaming PC

As I said above, not even close.
 
I bought my PC in 2011 and it's still going strong today. The only upgrades I've made is the graphics card last year (which in hindsight was not actually required until this year) and putting in an SSD. It's still kicking the crap out of most games on max settings, or at least high.

The main value of a PC isn't focused exclusively in it being the best gaming platform. If you were looking at gaming as the sole factor, then PCs and consoles both have pros and cons, and it's ultimately up to choice as to which to go for.

The thing that makes the PC better value in my opinion is that it does so much more than a console. I can work, manage my e-mails, surf the net, download and stream movies (Roku 3 + Plex Media Server ftw!), run the file structure how I please, pirate anything I want (even though, other than a few movies, everything I have is original now...hurray for steady income!) etc etc. The console is considerably more limited in it's capabilities, and where it has the same capabilities it is limited in how you can do it.

Therefore the reason I choose PC over console is that PC provides a much better overall value. The console is too restricted, and only actually competes with the PC small number of things.
 
Sure a pc is more versatile, but if it is all about gaming, there is not one of you playing the latest releases on a nine year old pc (PS3 was launched in 2006). If the ps4 has the longevity of the ps3 (which is still getting new releases), your current rig will without doubt be swapped or at least upgraded long before the console reaches the end of its life.
 
Sure a pc is more versatile, but if it is all about gaming, there is not one of you playing the latest releases on a nine year old pc (PS3 was launched in 2006). If the ps4 has the longevity of the ps3 (which is still getting new releases), your current rig will without doubt be swapped or at least upgraded long before the console reaches the end of its life.

The tradeoff is that your eyes don't have to bleed from the crap graphics, low resolution and low framerate.
 
Sure a pc is more versatile, but if it is all about gaming, there is not one of you playing the latest releases on a nine year old pc (PS3 was launched in 2006). If the ps4 has the longevity of the ps3 (which is still getting new releases), your current rig will without doubt be swapped or at least upgraded long before the console reaches the end of its life.

True...but...the amount of money you save on games allows you a little leeway for some upgrades, so...there's that. :)
 
The tradeoff is that your eyes don't have to bleed from the crap graphics, low resolution and low framerate.

Exactly, I don't see why being able to claim that you're gaming on an antique would be a positive.

True...but...the amount of money you save on games allows you a little leeway for some upgrades, so...there's that. :)

9 years of not paying R800 a game is going to give you plenty leeway for upgrades.
 
I used to be a die hard PC gamer - consoles were a joke - but I wanted to scream every time there was a new release and I had to upgrade my GPU to play on full detail or my CPU or RAM to meet minimum requirements. I then bought a PS3 just for the knowledge that whatever is released for the platform will play and look as the developers intended.

You do realise that the console game 'settings' are lower than what ca be achieved with a high-end gpu. Instead of trying to play everything on ultra with you pc maybe you should turn down you settings to match those of the consoles. A average pc will easily beat a console if you play at the same settings.

Examples,
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w4z4igRnlLQ
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8q4Cb7u8W1w
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X