Pietersen makes all-time England XI

O

Ou grote

Honorary Master
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
15,472
Soon Trott will be in there.

http://www.cricinfo.com/england/content/current/story/422490.html
Pietersen makes all-time England XI

Kevin Pietersen is the only player from almost the past two decades to make it into the all-time England XI chosen by Cricinfo, with Ian Botham the next most-recent star to make the cut.

Pietersen's selection, by a panel of renowned cricket writers, journalists and commentators, confirms the impact he has had on the game since he made his Test debut in 2005, but there are no places for anyone else who contributed to England's Ashes victories in 2005 and 2009.

The opening positions are taken by Jack Hobbs and Len Hutton, two of the true legends of the game, and they are followed by Walter Hammond at No. 3 and Ken Barrington at No. 4. Pietersen, who is still in the early part of his career but is already recognised as a match-changing batsman, only just made it to final XI, beating off strong competition from Denis Compton, who captured the hearts and the minds of English fans in the post-war years.

Andrew Flintoff and Tony Greig both made it to the shortlist for allrounders, but Botham won that contest hands down. "A proven century-maker, unlike Andrew Flintoff, and capable of bowling either fast like Harold Larwood, or outswing like Fred Trueman," Scyld Berry, the editor of Wisden Cricketers' Almanack, wrote about Botham. "Hammond at first slip and Botham at second would make a formidable cordon beside Alan Knott."

Knott was the unanimous choice as the wicketkeeper. Sydney Barnes and Harold Larwood won the premier fast bowler's positions by an overwhelming majority, but it was a closer contest for Fred Trueman who had stiff competition from Frank Tyson. Bob Willis was the only modern fast bowler who came close to selection.

The sole spinner's position went to Derek Underwood, who beat Jim Laker by a single vote.

Last month Cricinfo produced a definitive all-time great Australia team, which didn't include any members of the current Australian line-up. Over the coming year, the website will turn its eye to all of the top Test-playing nations and round off the deliberations with an all-time World XI.

Cricinfo also asked readers to select their all-time XIs and the only two differences were that David Gower was voted into the middle order ahead of Barrington and Laker took the spin position from Underwood.

For more details click here.

The nominees

Openers
Jack Hobbs, Len Hutton, Herbert Sutcliffe, Mike Brearley, Geoff Boycott, Graham Gooch, Mike Atherton, Michael Vaughan

Middle order
Wally Hammond, Ken Barrington, Kevin Pietersen, Colin Cowdrey, Peter May, David Gower, Stanley Jackson, Frank Woolley, Ted Dexter, Denis Compton

Allrounders
Ian Botham, Tony Greig, Andrew Flintoff

Wicketkeepers
Alan Knott, Bob Taylor, Les Ames, Jack Russell, Alec Stewart

Fast bowlers
Sydney Barnes, Harold Larwood, Fred Trueman, Bob Willis, Alec Bedser, Frank Tyson, John Snow, Darren Gough, Brian Statham

Spinners
Hedley Verity, Wilfred Rhodes, Jim Laker, Derek Underwood
Click to expand...
 
Creag

Creag

The Boar's Rock
Joined
May 19, 2009
Messages
43,527
KP ain't my favourite player by any stretch of the imagination but here's the thing; he's done a remarkable job of making No. 4 his own in the England side. And the determination to make a success elsewhere despite SA ignoring him.

Our bad!

I still don't like him! :cool:
 
S

sybawoods

Expert Member
Joined
Aug 4, 2003
Messages
1,230
McT said:
KP ain't my favourite player by any stretch of the imagination but here's the thing; he's done a remarkable job of making No. 4 his own in the England side. And the determination to make a success elsewhere despite SA ignoring him.

Our bad!

I still don't like him! :cool:
Click to expand...

Don't want to minimise KP's achievements in the last few years, but it is well know that in SA, (according to stats at least, and cricket is a game of stats), KP couldn't even be regarded as an everage player at the time that he left. In the season before he left for Eng he had a batting ave of 7.66 in 50 over games, and 10.75 in the 4 day game: http://online.freeware.info.pl/games.html That doesn't really make anyone sit up and take notice. On the bowling front, which was his reason for inclusion in the provincial side at the time, he had averages of 59 and 37.5 respectively - also less than average.

To blame "quotas" (as oppsed to merit) as a reason for his non-selection into the SA'n side is KP-mania stirred by the British, and some local, press. The mere fact that there were plenty of white kids breaking into the SA'n side at the time, and since his departure, is testimony to the fact that he just wasn't good enough back then. Oh yeah, and the small matter of us being the number 1 ranked team in the world at the moment. Unfortunately for KP you have to be really good to make it into our side :)
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top