Prasa's chief engineer not registered

  • Thread starter Thread starter arr0w
  • Start date Start date
A

arr0w

Guest
Johannesburg – The chief engineer of Prasa, the Passenger Rail Agency of South Africa, is not officially registered with the profession’s statutory body, Netwerk24 reported on Wednesday.

In 2006, the Engineering Council of South Africa (Ecsa) rejected Dr Daniel Mtimkulu’s application to register with it.

Mtimkulu, who is head of engineering services at Prasa, was introduced at a press conference on Monday as the designer of the Afro 4000 locomotives that have been reported as unsuitable for South African infrastructure.

According to Rapport, he bought the locomotives, worth R600 million, despite warnings that their height was too great.
They were built in Spain and began to ship in December 2014.

At Monday’s press conference, Prasa CEO Lucky Montana, flanked by Mtimkulu, dismissed Rapport’s article and said there was nothing wrong with the locomotives.

Mtimkulu claimed to have studied engineering science at the University of the Witwatersrand before going on to study in Germany and get his doctorate.

Wits’ registration office could find no record of Mtimkulu having been a student.

According to the Engineering Profession Act and Ecsa regulations, an engineer working for a government entity has to be registered. Ecsa told Beeld that Mtimkulu was not registered with it.

In 2006 he applied to register, but his application was rejected because he did not hand in training and project reports. These were needed as proof that he had received training from a registered engineer.

Ecsa told Beeld that at the time of his application, Mtimkulu only had a BTech qualification and a national diploma.

Only those with a BSC degree in engineering and more than 3 years’ experience may apply to register as a professional engineer. Someone with a BTech qualification and more than 3 years’ experience may register as a professional engineering technologist.

Prasa spokesperson Moffet Mofokeng said Mtimkulu had a genuine PhD.

By Tuesday evening, Mofokeng had not responded to repeated queries about Mtimkulu’s Ecsa registration. He said Mtimkulu had been chairing a meeting since 14:00 that day.

In an sms sent around 18:00, Mtimkulu asked Beeld to call him later. His phone was then switched off.

http://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/Prasas-chief-engineer-not-registered-20150708
 
Which German university did he study at?

If he got his PhD from the Max Planck institute I would be willing to forgive him for slacking with his earlier studies here in South Africa.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
"Experience and “a brain” were more important than obtaining “a piece of paper”." ~ Hlaudi Motsoeneng
 
It's really so sad. Perhaps, instead of being another "Chippy Shaik" he might be a another"Gordon Sibiya" but the precedents are stacked against him.
 
The story is, in essence, FALSE.

He is registered with ECSA as a Technologist, just not as an engineer so to say he is NOT registered with ECSA is untrue.
 
The story is, in essence, FALSE.

He is registered with ECSA as a Technologist, just not as an engineer so to say he is NOT registered with ECSA is untrue.
You sure it's the right guy?
 
On the ECSA website there is only one Daniel Mtimkulu - registered as a Professional Civil Engineering Technologist in 2009. I wonder whether its the same person.
 
The story is, in essence, FALSE.

He is registered with ECSA as a Technologist, just not as an engineer so to say he is NOT registered with ECSA is untrue.

Yes let's FOCUS on THAT. Not the fact that he lied and should be sent to jail.
 
Why, why, why do candidates lie?

The flourish of the "gravy train" perhaps??

And why was he appointed in the first place?? Maybe just to do the BEE thing. Black in charge and all is cool....until all ends in the usual crap......always.

Just another Billion here or there. Wasted. Feeling sorry for them = NO. Apartheid's fault no doubt?

Stupid connected thieves become very wealthy thieves under the Zuma administration...

I hate, hate, hate where this Beautiful country is heading. I was once very proud of my Country of birth. In true African majority style...heading for the begging bowl. Money always wasted. Until nothing is left.

Why does It ALWAYS HAVE TO END THIS WAY IN AFRICA???

I know the reasons but to put them on a Public forum will offend sensitive little thieves that are in the majority now...little words like "I did not struggle to be poor"...comes to mind :mad:

What a absolute abortion of humanity.....

End of the day....David Bullard was correct in his final post...

Here somewhere.
 
Why, why, why do candidates lie?

The flourish of the "gravy train" perhaps??

And why was he appointed in the first place?? Maybe just to do the BEE thing. Black in charge and all is cool....until all ends in the usual crap......always.

Just another Billion here or there. Wasted. Feeling sorry for them = NO. Apartheid's fault no doubt?

Stupid connected thieves become very wealthy thieves under the Zuma administration...

I hate, hate, hate where this Beautiful country is heading. I was once very proud of my Country of birth. In true African majority style...heading for the begging bowl. Money always wasted. Until nothing is left.

Why does It ALWAYS HAVE TO END THIS WAY IN AFRICA???

I know the reasons but to put them on a Public forum will offend sensitive little thieves that are in the majority now...little words like "I did not struggle to be poor"...comes to mind :mad:

What a absolute abortion of humanity.....

End of the day....David Bullard was correct in his final post...

Here somewhere.


i have always said it is difficult to go against a culture.I mean with all the resources in the world Africa still cant get it together.What more do they need.
These people in charge never created anything so dont have a clue on how to run it

Back to point of article,is he willing to go public that the height of trains are no problems and if any problems,he shall take responsibilty.Also stop talking and prove your qualiications.I would not feel threatened if somebody asked to see my degree
 
Feeling better now?

Not really. But at least I got it out.
You guys living in nice places and areas do not understand the way the ANC supporter base thinks and behaves.

I am amongst the fodder. That's all.

And I shall not talk about this again. Consider the subject closed.

My little first hand experiences here with fodder seem to not worry or concern you.

So be it. Nothing more to say.
 
same old same old, from earlier . . .

JOHANNESBURG - The South African ambassador to Japan is the latest government official accused of faking her qualifications.

According to a report in the Financial Mail, Mohau Pheko has been presenting herself as Dr Pheko, when in fact she does not hold a PHD.
 
..yada yada

But there are some goodies out there. They should be national treasures. "Born in a shack, studied to candlelight and succeeded." Really succeeded. Not ANC/BEE succeeded but can cut it outside the umbrella of the ANC and BEE. These are the people in whom SA's future lies.

Sadly they are rare and painted as coconuts. Poor buggers. And Africa gets pissed when Europe and the US takes them and embraces them :confused:

I salute you Gordon Sibiya. A beer one day. Perhaps?
 
On the ECSA website there is only one Daniel Mtimkulu - registered as a Professional Civil Engineering Technologist in 2009. I wonder whether its the same person.

Not him, different Daniel.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X