Scientists have misled the public - Tim Noakes

rpm

Admin
Staff member
Joined
Jul 22, 2003
Messages
66,806
Reaction score
5,057
Location
Johannesburg
Professor Tim Noakes said his eyes were opened the day his own health failed.

"It is the day I saw the truth," said Noakes, speaking at the University of KwaZulu-Natal on the topic, "Reversing the greatest blunder in the history of medicine. Can South Africa lead the way?"

On Thursday, Noakes told a gathering at the Graduate School of Business auditorium at the Westville campus that scientists had misled the public by telling them to eat a high carbohydrate diet. His health had also suffered as a result.

“We have failed our people, because we haven’t recognised insulin resistance is the real problem.

“The reasons scientists made a drastic error is because we thought heart diseases were caused by high cholesterol and they are not. Cholesterol is caused by insulin resistance,” said Noakes.

Noakes, who promotes the Banting Diet - a low-carbohydrate high-fat lifestyle - said the diet required three things.

“We say, eat real food, limit the carbohydrates and learn how to cook.”

He said a high carbohydrate diet led to diseases like diabetes.

“Your cats are diabetic and obese because you are feeding them carbohydrates and they are carnivores. There is an outbreak at the moment of diabetes in cats.

“Research shows these are the most insulin resistant animals and if you treat insulin resistant animals with carbohydrates, they will get fat and die. The reason your cat and I am diabetic is because we both eat too much carbohydrates.”

Noakes said he made the decision to start banting on December 12 2010.

“That is the day I decided I am never eating another carbohydrate in my life again…

“Today we are dying from diseases our predecessors were not dying from. The reason is nutrition. They had incredibly good nutrition until they were introduced to the industrial diet.”

'Obesity is all about hunger'

He said uncontrolled hunger led to obesity.

“The key to obesity is when you don’t understand hunger, you can’t get rid of your hunger. Obesity is all about hunger.”

He encouraged parents to buy the correct foods for their children.

“It is the addictive foods that have high sugar that cause obesity. If you want to prevent obesity and diabetes, you need to get rid of your hunger.

“We need to address the environment that allows for these products to be sold to your children. We need to wean them off the high sugar drinks.”

He explained insulin was a fat-building hormone.

“If you look in the mirror and see a roll on your tummy, that is the insulin roll. Insulin promotes fat storage.”

He said if your diet does not remove your hunger, then you would never lose weight.

News24 - http://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/Scientists-have-misled-the-public-Tim-Noakes-20150813
 
One of the best article titles ever. Scientists. This article could be about how flat the earth is. Stupid News24. As usual.
 
Tinfoil hats are cheap today... cheaper than yesterday...
 
insulin created my haemorrhoid...I see it now
 
“It is the addictive foods that have high sugar that cause obesity. If you want to prevent obesity and diabetes, you need to get rid of your hunger.

Yup, let's stop eating...
Let's all become members of the Church of Scientology...
 
Noakes said he made the decision to start banting on December 12 2010.

“That is the day I decided I am never eating another carbohydrate in my life again…
Not even one teensy weensy carbohydrate? What is he eating?
 
  • Like
Reactions: B-1
So Prof Noakes... have you got any data, research, studies, papers, links(:)) etc to back up this up? Or should I just take your 'fat cat' observation as gospel?
 
I don't have an issue with Noakes and his dietary plan, many people love him, like many people love Dr. Oz and Dr. Phil. Then again, I do have an issue with them riding the people – the money train. Treating individuals as equal when it comes down to our health (our unique biology).

Noakes is on a roll.

http://www.iol.co.za/lifestyle/i-ve-had-another-complaint-noakes-1.1899828#.Vc2k0Yiqqko

“Why do we have academic institutions? If we knew everything, we wouldn’t need them. My view is that if you aren’t challenging (conventional) thinking, you are the one who is controversial, and should be sacked. So I should be the only one employed,” an upbeat Noakes began.

He revealed that he had been told on Thursday morning that a complaint of disgraceful conduct had been laid against him with the Health Professions Council of South Africa, over a remark he had made to a dietician with whom he had disagreed.

On Thursday, however, the council could not confirm that it was investigating the complaint.

Noakes is already facing charges of unprofessional misconduct for encouraging a high-fat, low-carbohydrate diet on Twitter.

“The reason the Banting eating plan works is because it is biologically based. It is the only diet which is biologically based. There’s a host of science proving that it is beneficial in many ways … If you understand the biology you will understand that when you take in carbohydrates, your body is not really designed for it.”

Read the article.
 
I don't have an issue with Noakes and his dietary plan, many people love him, like many people love Dr. Oz and Dr. Phil. Then again, I do have an issue with them riding the people – the money train. Treating individuals as equal when it comes down to our health (our unique biology).

Noakes is on a roll.

http://www.iol.co.za/lifestyle/i-ve-had-another-complaint-noakes-1.1899828#.Vc2k0Yiqqko



Read the article.


After reading the article all I want to know is what should I feed my cat then?
 
It is the only diet which is biologically based.
I thought it was a lifestyle™, not a diet :p

“We need to address the environment that allows for these products to be sold to your children. We need to wean them off the high sugar drinks.”
This is such a novel concept, I wish all diets discouraged the use of fizzy drinks. :rolleyes:
 
This is such a novel concept, I wish all diets discouraged the use of fizzy drinks. :rolleyes:

You incorrectly assume it's just the fizzy drinks. the so called healthy juices, energy drinks, vitamin waters, etc, are all saturated with added sugar in one form or another.
 
When did scientists tell people that eating a high carb diet was good for them? :confused:

Sugar/Carbs won the battle in the 60's against fats.

People had always eaten fat, always. Since then sugar and carbs became good and fats a no no.

Just look at obesity now compared to then, even in low income areas.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X