Shootout : 3 Bluray players (incl PS3!)

  • Thread starter Thread starter kingrob
  • Start date Start date
K

kingrob

Guest
http://www.soundandvisionmag.com/hd-dvd-bluray/1927/shootout-3-blu-ray-disc-players.html

''Getting back to our trio of Blu-ray Disc players, my personal favorite was the PlayStation 3. This machine's picture and sound quality were nothing short of stunning, and its HDMI 1.3 connection and built-in Dolby TrueHD decoding give it a layer of future-proofing that the other players currently lack. I also appreciated its multichannel Super Audio CD playback and 60-GB hard disk for storing compressed music files. And even though I don't have much use for the PS3's gaming capabilities, I definitely got a kick out of Resistance: Fall of Man. The PS3's $600 price — several hundred less than the others — also goes a long way toward making it the Blu-ray Disc player of choice.

The PS3 also proved to be a fine player for multichannel SACDs. On "Breathe" from Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon, the sound quality approached that of my Denon DVD/SACD player — silky-smooth yet detailed, with fluid, low-reaching bass.

Did I mention that the PS3 also plays games? I'm no authority there, so I invited Isaac George, an 11-year-old family friend and PlayStation enthusiast, to come check things out. Isaac wasn't that impressed with Genji: Days of the Blade — playing it, he said, wasn't all that different than doing the same thing on PS2. But he instantly warmed to NBA 07, commenting enthusiastically on its complexity, depth, and lifelike 1080p graphics. His favorite game, however, turned out to be Resistance: Fall of Man, an ultraviolent shooter (sorry, Isaac's mom) involving foul-looking creatures called Chimera. After playing the game for a few hours, it became my favorite, too. Who needs movies when you can slaughter Chimera?

BOTTOM LINE With its crisp 1080p Blu-ray Disc playback, flexible, wide-ranging audio options, and mounds of other network and gaming features, the Sony PlayStation 3 is nothing short of awesome. From my perspective, the only reason someone would buy a standalone Blu-ray player instead of a PS3 is a complete aversion to videogames — either that, or the desire for a more traditional A/V form factor (that also includes upconversion of standard-def DVDs). That said, Sony's PS3 game console is one of the most exciting, well-executed home theater products I've laid my hands on in a long time. Good luck finding one!''

*I know ToxicBunny would love to read this... :)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
What is the pricing like now days? Last time I checked Bluray players were over $1000
 
Or you can plug any USB mass-storage device into one of the PS3's four front-panel USB slots and achieve the same end.

I didn't know that! Can you do that with a XBox?
 
Like the guy said in his review, the only reason why you would not go for the PS3 as your HD-DVD player, is purely 'cosmetics'.

I would buy the PS3, cos I get a gaming console for free & it's cheaper than the other HD-DVD players...it's really a 'no-brainer'.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
a kick out of Resistance: Fall of Man. The PS3's $600 price — several hundred less than the others — also goes a long way toward making it the Blu-ray Disc player of choice.

is the ps3 not several hundred dolla more ?

its cheaper to buy a ps3 for blu ray than to actually buy a blue ray drive haha
 
As a Blu-Ray player, the ps3 is almost a no-brainer.. i won't deny that for a second... Its just supposed to be miles better than anything else on the market, and right now... its marginally better in some cases than the xbox... and marginally worse...

And of course theres no guarantee that Blu-Ray will become the next standard of choice.... so yeah...

Me, I like mine xboxen... it hath given me great plsr.. oh and fudzy, yeah you can plug usb thingymajigs into the xbox... i have my 120gb musicfarm plugged in and it are werking beautifully.....

*sticks tongue out at kingrob*..least i won't have to wait until march or april next year at the earliest to get my games console...
 
*sticks tongue out at kingrob*..least i won't have to wait until march or april next year at the earliest to get my games console...

T-Bunny, I'm so glad you finally admit that the PS3 is light-years ahead of the ol' x-boxsie!

I'm a die-hard Sony fan - I will play games on the PS2 while I'm waiting for the PS3... 3 months of pain, but years of pleasure. :)

No wench sticks her tongue out at the king! :mad:

/king orders knights to saddle up and find the wench
 
Last edited by a moderator:
scotty777.... ummm it can, i do it with my own xbox360... but anywho....

wench???? WHO you calling a wench... false king... *runs away*
 
Oh and kingrob.. i do not admit the PS3 is lightyear ahead.. i just reckon its a diff approach... might end up being better.. but sony are struggling atm..
 
First of all to enjoy HD you'll need an HDCP capable HD display, a proper HD LCD TV/monitor retails for R45.000 in SA ATM, 46 Inch 1920by1080 Toshiba.

Secondly who is to say who the winner will be BD or HD-DVD?

Thirdly, 1st Gen BluDisk/HD-DVD players will be buggy, will have software,
picture quality and other issues. They will also be super pricey, which
is ok if you have money to burn but not-OK if you have money to burn
and want quality at the same time.

Finally the current limited generation of HD material on BD/HD-DVD disks
is made up of crummy Holywood blockbuster cr@p. No reason to to spend
R50.000 to watch stubble on Tom Cruise's face.

As a console the PS3 is a great solution, the BD drive is a bonus, but people should buy a dedicated BD player once those become affordable/BD establishes itself as the quality will beat an integrated solution anyhow.
PS2 DVD playback quality sucks compared to stand alone DVD players, for instance.
 
hahahahaha!!!! dumb ass, it can't

I do it with mine...

[RANT]
Do you have a xbox360?
Just for interest sake how old are you? If your < 18 i could understand the mindless garble you post as just pure immaturity, if not I think you should consider getting help.

Sorry i dont mean to attack, but its just im getting rather sick of the **** you post, and im sure im not the only one.
[/RANT]
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X