Instead of trying code everything yourself (or paying a developer to do it) rather go for an existing framework as mister suggested. The opensource revolution is happening - the days of doing everything yourself are long done.
I'd suggest using the blogging way of doing things - the old way being boring "Homepage, FAQ, Contact Us, etc, etc".
www.wordpress.com is a blogging framework. The advantage of using such a framework is that users can easily find info on your site, since you tag each post. One day, you might write something interesting that you read in Revelations, which you can then tag a "revalations, endtimes". The next day you'll write something about a new Christian book dealing with marriage, and tag it "books, marriage, relationships". The nice thing about this is that people can find this info months later by clicking on the "popular tags" system that comes with wordpress.
Check out this site for example:
http://achristian.wordpress.com/
Then there's also a whole bunch of free Christian related templates: A quick search in google bought back a ton of results:
http://www.magictemplate.com/files/free-christian-wordpress-themes.php
http://www.ozzu.com/designs/wordpress_themes/keyword/christian/
...and there's more. Search google for free Christian wordpress templates.
The nice thing about choosing a blogging system (as opposed to the "normal" website system) is that it gets you in the habit to update you website and create content. CONTENT IS KING! It is the golden rule of the web and I've seen far too many people with "normal/brochure websites" that promise to update their sites, but because it is such a hassle, they never update once the site is a month old.
With wordpress, you can easily write entries to your website by using a firefox plugin called scibefire. Click a button, start typing, hit sumbit - viola - your site is updated.
But yea, if you really want to go the old fashioned way and do most of this yourself, check out
www.yola.com (the old synthasite). You can do the website layout using their system, download the html and css and then integrate that with your website (it worked this way last time I checked anyway)
Hope this helps. Good luck with the whole process - it's pretty fun actually.