you killed the steak .....some weird italian try ....but yeah like everyone said dont do funny things
best for me is abit of bbq basting and mushroom sauce or no sauce
Food is a personal thing. Maybe that's the way he likes it, and so be it. I can never understand why people insist that how someone else makes something is the wrong way, if that's how they like it done.
The low, slow method is well worth it but the best thing to do is to sear the steak first on a high heat. This induces the maillard reaction in the meat while it's in the oven. The oven method then helps to break down the protein bonds and fat within the meat so it is super tender. This is why roasts are (usually) so tender.
If you use this method, then you must cut the initial sear off of the steak after it has rested once it comes out of the oven, otherwise it dries out completely. You then sear the steak as suggested before, not forgetting to season the meat.
There is also a myth that putting salt on steaks beforehand will draw out the moisture and make it dry. While the principle is sound, the process is a very, very slow one in red meats as the myocin proteins are strong enough to hold the juices in.
So by all means, season the meat with salt before it goes in the oven. Three hours is not enough time to draw any moisture out. In fact it is believed now that seasoning red meat an hour before cooking is beneficial, due to the salt actually inducing more of a brining reaction which draws flavours into meat, and not out of them...
Interesting read here and in related articles, on salting and other thoughts on steak prep - http://www.seriouseats.com/2011/03/the-food-lab-more-tips-for-perfect-steaks.html