3G Sucks.

salmo

Active Member
Joined
Nov 14, 2005
Messages
46
Reaction score
0
I've had 3G for going on 2 months now and in my view it's major waste of money. The coverage is bad, most places around Cape Town I can only get a GPRS signal. On the odd occasion that I can get 3G the speed is nowhere near 384K, it's closer to a 56k dial up.

3G sucks.
 
3g in Cape Town is not great. However I noticed if I force my phone to use UMTS band instead of Auto it tends to use 3G much more than GPRS.. Its odd that way. However I think doing that is bad because because it lowers your cell phonecall coverage quit a bit.
 
It's become standard practice for most to use 3G-only and GPRS-only profiles and not let the system decide when to switch.

In Cape town northern subs, I often work with 1 to 2 bars at full speed on a 3G-only profile.
 
Salmo, are you using an external antenna? It's a must. And the 3G only profile of course.
 
Maybe you can be more specific about the area you are in ?
I have worked in a few locations around Cape Town with great success, and imo the 3G network has become a lot more consistant over the last couple of months with far less problems, it would appear the major teething problems are sorted out,
...so the network does have a bit of teeth now:D

Follow biometrics suggestion, and if I may add, try an optimise your positioning for best results.
For instance , at my work, my GSM signal and in places my 3G signal is flacky(the GSM signal has always has been very dodge), but sticking my 3G box with it's external antena in just the right sweet spot provides excellent 2 bar performance.
 
salmo said:
3G sucks.
It started out well for me, but lately it is rather pathetic (Pretoria East) ...

It's falling back to GPRS most of the time, and there seems to be a problem with the name server resolution.
 
There is nothing wrong with 3G but simply the plonkers who tried to implement it here in S.A.

They hype something do death that they simply are too incompetent to deliver while other overseas cellphone companies with clued up technical people have no problem with 3G.
 
tibby.dude said:
There is nothing wrong with 3G but simply the plonkers who tried to implement it here in S.A.

They hype something do death that they simply are too incompetent to deliver while other overseas cellphone companies with clued up technical people have no problem with 3G.
So you can't win - the own crowd has the coverage (Vodacom), and the other has the techies (MTN) ... C-Cell does not count, they piggy-back on the Vodacom network?
 
tibby.dude said:
There is nothing wrong with 3G but simply the plonkers who tried to implement it here in S.A.

They hype something do death that they simply are too incompetent to deliver while other overseas cellphone companies with clued up technical people have no problem with 3G.

As an obvious expert on International 3G implementations, please enlighten us to the following.

When did which country implement 3G? (We all know SA is always behind in everything)
What are their pricing structures? (We all know we're being ripped here)
What is their service availability? (SA networks must be the worst around, it's a fact)
What is their coverage statistics? (Being a large country with a small population, it's a fact we've got crap coverage)

I've been long searching for this information and am glad we finally found someone who can comment on this. Reading the UK and other international 3G forums, I had the (obviously wrong) impression that they also suffered from early adoption problems.

Awaiting the info with anticipation.
 
nextstep said:
It started out well for me, but lately it is rather pathetic (Pretoria East) ...

It's falling back to GPRS most of the time, and there seems to be a problem with the name server resolution.

The Pretoria area still seems to be problematic from a connection point of view.

Not sure about the name server issue. Are you getting DNS timeouts?
 
Hi IC, Neo and others

V3G can possibly confirm my facts, but I have heard that Vodacom’s 3G performance is of the best (most likely the best) out of all the providers in the Vodafone group. They are also early adopters which is never easy.

Regards,

RPM
 
That's like saying the food at the KFC on Rivonia Road is less greasy than the other branches.
 
vodacom3g said:
It's become standard practice for most to use 3G-only and GPRS-only profiles and not let the system decide when to switch.

How can I set this, I can't see any option to choose whether to stay with 3G only or choose the best option in the control panel? I do recall seeing it somwhere though.
 
Changed profile but 3g still sucks.

I figured out how to change the profile to 3G only but it's even worse, now I have no signal at all.

3G still sucks!
 
Neo said:
When did which country implement 3G?

A company like DoCoMo in Japan with it's total 69 million 3G users.

In fact Vodofone ( well that is no surprise now is it ) lost some major marketshare in Japan because they could not deliver their ****ty Nokia 3G handsets to the market in time.

n January, Vodafone Japan said it would miss its annual sales target because of delays in rolling out new 3G handsets. Meanwhile, its two rivals are set to release new 3G phones this spring, while Vodafone's next 3G release isn't likely before the summer. Unimpressed shoppers complain that Vodafone's current 3G handsets -- especially those made by foreign manufacturers such as Nokia Corp. (NOK ) and Motorola Inc. (MOT ) -- don't look cool, and lack the functions of rivals' models. By contrast, the latest DoCoMo phones, all from Japanese vendors, can be used to pay for groceries at convenience stores, while KDDI Corp. customers have downloaded 2 million songs to their handsets in recent months. Vodafone falls short largely because it has tried to introduce a uniform suite of handsets and services worldwide rather than customizing them for Japan. "People here don't want what people in Glasgow want," says Gerhard Fasol, chief executive of Eurotechnology Japan, a Tokyo consultancy.

http://www.businessweek.com/@@4Gh1@oUQ2AftDAAA/magazine/content/05_08/b3921065.htm

Oh see that bit in bold fellow 3G experts ... to me that is a rather successfull rollout .... I rest my case :).
 
Last edited:
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X