To all those non-feral druids out there:
Wondering how spec a druid to be a boomkin. My druid is currently feral but I am wanting to try something different. What are advantages/disadvantages? Any other recommended specs?
If you want some perspective from someone not splashing around in the kiddie pool... I have[had] a 70 feral druid that raided all the way through to SSC/TK, before i moved to EU due to latency issues. Maintanked KZ, Gruul and offtanked/dps'ed Lurker, Hydross, Morogrim, Loot Reaver and some other stuff (world bosses/dragons).
I was also the druid class lead for the guild I was on, and had to deal with a couple balance druids.
These are my personal observations.
(1)Balance dps is subpar. Even relatively well geared balance druids raiding with us simply could not match the other caster dps.
(2)Balance dps has massive aggro issues. They can't push dps without pulling aggro, even with Subtelty maxed.
(3)However, they offer some nice buffs. If specced right, improved feral faerie fire can help melee dps tons, and helps with tank threat too. The moonkin aura is a great buff for casters.
(4)A well played moonkin is an asset despite slightly subpar dps because they bring some great utility to the raid in the forms of innervates and battlerezes and tranquility, which are easier for them to pull of in combat as caster dps as opposed to being a healer or tank.
(5)They make certain specific encounters much easier, for eg tanking Kiggler the Crazed in Gruul's Lair (theyre immune to his polymorph) or tanking/kiting adds on certain other boss fights.
(6)if their individual skill and situational awareness is superlative, Cyclone can be a great PVE tool ideal for saving a clothy that's been aggroed by a loose mob. On it's own it's not an effective form of cc, however, but it can buy just enough time for a heal on the clothy and for an offtank to peel the mob off.
(7)Unlike other caster dps, they can switch to a pretty respectable raidhealing role if another healer becomes necessary.
(8)FoN is bad. It breaks sheeps. Can be useful on boss fights but good timing is necessary. Most often they just get onehit by an aoe.
(9)They excel as cc outdoors when root can be used. They were great, for eg, in AQ20. Also their Hibernate can be extremely useful sometimes, such as the dragonhawks in TK. Make sure you set up a focus cc macro for such situations, and people will soon come to love you.
(10)Overall it is useful to bring one along on a 10man or 25man raid to buff the caster pack, but there is really little to no point on bringing more than one.
In short, it's a great raid spec but hard to justify spots over locks and mages, and even elemental shamans.
For PVP, Balance is more suited to BG's. In arenas their lack of burst potential and interrupts holds them back as a pvp caster. They dont have a very good representation in any of the 3 brackets, at least at high-rating play.
Any other recommended specs?
Resto really is flavour of the month. Specced appropriately you can enjoy being a strong raidhealer and also do exceedingly well in the 2v2 and 3v3 arenas. It's a great spec for someone who wants to support his guild when they need a healer, and who also enjoys competitive pvp. Being resto and hitting the arenas means you'll be able to gear up on season3 epics relatively quickly, which means when your guild needs a healer to fill a spot, you can slide in without a respec or feeling too gimped gearwise.