Carte Blanche Interview/Fair Lady Interview

Peapod

Expert Member
Joined
Sep 11, 2003
Messages
1,358
Reaction score
6
Hello All
Been quietly slogging away in the background and have some news
Carte Blanche are interviewing me (yes i am going to be on TV) for a completely unrelated issue than broadband, but guess what, its an in - the researcher I am speaking to is interested in what we are doing and fighting for so WOW at last, a door opens.
Secondly, I am being interviewed by Fair Lady/Wendy Knowler for a broadband/adsl in depth analysis so again, some excellent exposure.
Will need some input on lots of issues remembering that we have to keep the language simple and "man/woman in the street" our technical issues.
Watch this space


And there you thought I had faded away.......didn'tcha?
 
Well glad that you did not leave us after all :).

In the case of Fair Lady readership I would punt the benefits of broadband for education and esp kids and how this could be of benefit to all folks if only it was cheaper.

I would not concentrate so much on the P2P or playing games and watching TV aspect of broadband as it is rather useless to most people but something more concrete and beneficial like wikipedia and that MWEB school site for example.
 
I'd suggest, to be sneakily tactical about it - to try link Telkom's control and profiteering, to 'racism' - given that their current attitude and prices DIRECTLY block the poorest folks from participation in the global Net - which translates in local context, to 'poor black people'.

As I think of it, perhaps 'economic racism' is a term to consider using? Or 'economic Apartheid'. (thus linking Telkom's attitude and direct effect on the market - to an instantly understandable, valid and usefully emotive image in the minds of 'average joe public'.)

Telkom as it is, IS clearly practising a form of supremacist economic elitism - locking out the majority from cheap easy access to the Net - and thus depriving them of 'information' 'education' and 'knowledge'..

Just a thought - not sure if it's useful or not.. but it might be good to begin to try paint Telkom in a way that communicates easily - what its doing and its effects on SA - without having to quote figures, which'll make most people switch off.
 
LoneGunman said:
which translates in local context, to 'poor black people'.

- locking out the majority from cheap easy access to the Net - and thus depriving them of 'information' 'education' and 'knowledge'..

Not to break balls or anything, but running with LG's train of thought, you can't say that they(Telkom) is locking out the majority from cheap internet. You have to first consider the fact that the majority can't afford to get means by which to connect to the internet, even if they could get it... consumerism on a whole in this country is messed up as far as Rich vs. Poor...

Well, just my 2cents.

GoodLuck PeaPod!!

-Sticking it to Telskum since 2000
-Shintorojin
 
Peapod said:
..
Secondly, I am being interviewed by Fair Lady/Wendy Knowler for a broadband/adsl in depth analysis so again, some excellent exposure.

Great, Wendy here is question you must ask Peopod.
When does the secret agreement between Thabo Mbeki and SBC communications come to an end? The previous head of Icasa said that this
document is extremely important, but since it's secret he could not get his
hands on it. It will explain exactly how Jay Naidoo
and Mr.Mbeki went about to selling South-Africa down the river.
And unspeakable R30bil was wasted in rolling out telephone lines to
underserviced areas. After Telkom installed these lines, they promptly went
ahead to disconnect all the lines! :mad:
 
following on from LG and the Khaas & in simple terms

how many broadband/dsl lines are there in soweto and khayelitsha combined?
 
this is exciting news, peapod, and well done for cracking an interview!
/me is looking forward to more info :)
 
Peapod said:
Hello All...................And there you thought I had faded away.......didn'tcha?

Sweat peas never fades away, after the blooms, new seeds develop to become the pretty self again and again, Maybe seasonal but all the same.

Maybe make a point of the fact that Telkom only cater for the middle and upper classes and keep the masses uninformed and unserviced. Why make 16 Billion profit with hard work and huge infrastructure if the same can be got of a few sods that are prepared to pay for it because they want or have to have it.

Also Telkom never adhered to their mandate to bring cheap and affordable comm's services to the masses. Now they still have all the liberty's but the same mandate is given to the SNO and they have to adhere to it? or else!

Where is the GVT logic. They should penalise TELKOM and give the sat3 cable to SNO and TELKOM can rent the bandwidth.
 
My email to Wendy - she will edit.

I think I got my point accross.......no doubt will elaborate before this goes to print in the Fair Lady

My comments;

Broadband in South Africa is a joke. Every time I see the Telkom “go where no South African has gone before” advert, my blood boils and my stomach churns. The truth is that 90% of South Africans cannot afford entry level broadband. Which is a non statistic really because in order to get Telkom ADSL, one has to have access to basic copper telephony in the first place. And we all know that South Africa is the only country on the planet where fixed line services are decreasing, not increasing. In fact, since 2000, over 2 million landlines have been disconnected and penetration has slowed to under 4%. Telkom will tell you the reason for this is lack of demand and bad debt. I can tell you that this lack of fixed line growth is because 80% of South Africans cannot afford basic telephony. Our call charges are the most expensive in the world for international, national and local calls. Our rates are just over 3 times higher than the next highest country which is Belgium. Thabo Mbeki called us to put our shoulders to the wheel to create an information nation. What a noble call to arms. The sad truth is that Telkom have throttled our country by denying us even the most basic form (and laughably the oldest too) of electronic communication. A telephone! Telkom made R18.6 million profit PER DAY in 2005. Yet few schools have the discounted internet access and telephony they were promised. Disadvantaged areas that would benefit so hugely from access to information and basic communication remain isolated. Small businesses, the entrepreneurial spirit that Madiba engendered and encouraged is stifled and held back. Not many small firms can afford the R3000 a month that basic telephony and interconnectivity costs them. Telkom baffle us as a nation with statistics and glitz. The sad truth is that we are being robbed. ADSL lines are charged on a multi tier system. We pay for the phone line, then we pay for the ADSL line, which is in fact the same line, and we pay even more if we ask for a faster service, but it’s still the same line! Then we pay an ISP for a connection service, then we pay for extra bandwidth. We pay triple to quadruple what any other third world nation pays for broadband, and we have the slowest and most unstable service. 2Mb ADSL is now standard from Manilla to Rio de Janiero. We are the only country in the world that pays for an ADSL line. The situation stinks. Add to this, Telkom have positioned themselves to dominate and monopolise infrastructure…does it really matter how many other licensed operators there are? They will all have to use Telkom’s infrastructure at a premium – Telkom in effect have price fixed the market. They have to be held accountable for the quantifiable detriment they put our nation under. They have to be held accountable for the throttlehold they have on our economy. They have to be held accountable for our children, all our children, held back from free information over profiteering and greed.
Stats and facts – thanks to Gregg at Hellkom http://www.hellkom.co.za
Financial and General Facts

Profit after tax:
2000: R1,540 billion
2001: R1,690 billion
2002: R1,280 billion
2003: R1,735 billion
2004: R4,592 billion (Equates to R12.58m profit per day)
2005: R6,807 billion (Equates to R18.6 million profit per day)

Telkom CEO's salary in 2004: R11.1 million which equates to:
R1,267/hour or
R30,410/day or
R213,461/week or
R925,000/month
Sizwe Nxasana's R11.1 million could keep 183 people employed for 1 year at R5,000 a month.

Employee expenses in 2003/4 include retrenchment costs of R302 million, R244 million, R373 million, R132 million and R303 million in the years ended March 31, 2004, 2003, 2002, 2001 and 2000, respectively.

Telkom Directors were paid R60 million in 2003, one American receiving over R15 million, another almost R11 million, and others between 4 and 8 million. Making that much money isn't a bad thing - when not a monopoly.

Telkom is a founding member of Proudly South African, even though:

- They were managed until end 2004 by Americans from SBC who dictated pricing
- They are contributing to our rampant unemployment by firing 10% of their staff every year - in fact they have almost HALVED their workforce since '99!
- They are the most expensive Telecoms provider in the world [Telecoms Report]
- Over 80% of the population cannot afford their basic telephone service.

Almost 90% of business users have been locked into 3-5 year contracts to stifle the second operator in acquiring customers at startup.

In 1999, there were 61237 Telkom employees, by September 2003 this had been reduced to about 33800 - simply adding to the country's almost 40% unemployment rate and going against Government's promise to curb unemployment.

Exchanges, equipment and lines have been paid for many times over the decades but we are still faced with ridiculously high voice and data charges. Costs for international bandwidth and interconnection are dropping almost monthly.

Vodacom contributed 22% of Telkom's group revenue and 33% in operating profit in 2002/3. Telkom has a 50% stake in Vodacom.

Telkom's shareholders consist of Government 39.3%, Thintana 30% (60% owned by SBC), and retail and institutional investors like Ucingo 30,7% (Sep 30 2003). SBC also has an 8% indirect share in Vodacom via Telkom's 50% share.
[ NOTE: Thintana has sold their shares and ran back overseas with around R9 billion of our money ]

Government and businesses accounted for around 71% of Telkom's earnings in 2003.

XtraTime offers hundreds of 'free' minutes, except that these don't apply to Internet calls, cellular calls, special numbers, operator assisted calls, international mobile numbers or calls terminated on the SNO's network.

Telephony and Voice Call Facts

Growth in prepaid customers slowed to 4% "due to a clean up of all inactive customers."
- Which in corporate speak means disconnecting poor people who can't afford the high prices.

Landlines disconnected due to non-payment/inability to pay: over 2 million

S.A. is the most expensive country for local call rates [R22/hour] (Telecoms Report).
S.A. is the most expensive country for national call rates [R59.40/hour] (Telecoms Report).
S.A. is the most expensive country for international calls, being just under 3 times more expensive than 2nd place (Telecoms Report).

Local call costs rose by 12.5% in 2003, 24% in 2002, 16% in 2001 and 10.5% in 2000.

Cellphone calls are routed between towers via Telkom lines, not through the air from tower to tower, which is a factor adding to the high cost of cellphones.

Data and Internet Connectivity

An Internet Service Providers Association of South Africa (ISPA) report given to the Independent Communications Authority of SA last year shows that Telkom telephone call charges are gradually consuming the overall cost of connecting to the Internet.

The report shows that Telkom's call charges rose from being 59% of the average consumer's combined telephone and ISP bill in 1993, to 85% of the bill by 2003.

According to Internet World Stats, SA's Internet growth increased by 29.2% last year as opposed to Africa's growth of 123.6% and Europe's growth of over 100%

ADSL customers surged 661% in 2004 despite ridiculous limitations and limits placed on the service. As an example, one ISP in the UK - Wanadoo - at one stage received over 25,000 orders per week - this is due to the affordable prices.

Around 50% of a South African ISP's charges are Telkom-related.

Telkom has access to 20% of the SAT-3 AND safe cable even though it only purchased 13% (Total of 27.3Gbps).

ADSL prices for residential users:
192Kbps: R270/mo ADSL line rental + R92 phone line rental = R362 without ISP (i.e. no connectivity)
384Kbps: R359/mo ADSL line rental + R92 phone line rental = R451 without ISP (i.e. no connectivity)
512Kbps: R477/mo ADSL line rental + R92 phone line rental = R569 without ISP (i.e. no connectivity)
1Mbps: R680/mo ADSL line rental + R92 phone line rental = R772 without ISP (i.e. no connectivity)

ADSL prices for business users:

512Kbps: R477/mo ADSL line rental + R122 phone line rental = R599 without ISP (i.e. no connectivity)
1Mbps: R680/mo ADSL line rental + R92 phone line rental = R772 without ISP (i.e. no connectivity)
(Business are barred from getting a 192 or 384k line.)

- In the UK you get 24Mbps uncapped for R100 less than the 192Kbps with no ISP..........
- British Telecom's slowest available ADSL speed is 2Mbps.

Local AND international download AND upload usage is counted towards your cap, whether it be e-mail, FTP, chatting - anything going in or out of your connection.

Schools, Universities, NGO's, charities and the like don't receive discount from Telkom for Internet access. U.S. Universities have up to Gigabit internet connections and free access for students.

NOTE: Our Communications Minister Ivy announced last year that schools will be receiving a 50% discount on internet access. This should be happening this year - but with current prices as high as they are 50% off isn't enough for an educational institution, it should be free, and the public should get 50% off. Thus far nothing much has happened.
 
Well done Peapod...and so glad that Wendy is working on this - she's brilliant!
 
Bloody hell, that is one well prepared fact sheet!!.... yes Telkom these are facts not built up lies or half truths that u manage to hide in.... go guys!!!
 
With regard to the stats - the hourly rate is wrong, unless he works a 24 hour day.

I think it would have a bigger impact to say that its closer to 3777 per hour, assuming an 8 hour working day :p
 
Peapod said:
I think I got my point accross.......no doubt will elaborate before this goes to print in the Fair Lady

hi Peapod,
do you have any idea when this article will be published?
 
I sincerely hope that in all these wonderful 'Interviews' The subject will come up regarding 'CHEAPER RATES' for 'THE INTERNET' Where Thousands of people like myself who are disabled under privilaged i.e.(poor) and pensioners, who are less fortunate and incapable in earning salaries. Should people like ourselves have the privilage to access these Services at lower rates?...Or is it because of our disposition that we cannot afford such high rates and therefore go without it, along with everthing else?
After all the Internet and telecommunication should not fall in the catergory of luxuries but a 'Gateway to a Wealth of information and Education. and give those who cannot afford such privilages a chance to be able to Experience and have some exciting fulfilment in the lives they lead... After all what is there left to look forward to?...I don't only speak for myself as I'm a little fortunate than others, Only Just...(Thanks to My Family) but for those who Don't have families and cannot speak out for themselves...The battle has been half way won 'Open Source Information" now what we need is a similiar cheap service to use those resources"What's the point here? (Open Source) only for those who can afford to access the Internet? Come On think of those who cannot help themselves... Give them a Chance to see, communicate and experience 'the rest of the World'... we live in...
 
Last edited:
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X