Caster Semenya killed them!

[Bona Botse]

there's a poll at sport24 asking whether you think caster is male or female. the third option took the words right out of my mind: "This vote disgusts me"

 

[LancelotSA]

there's a poll at sport24 asking whether you think caster is male or female. the third option took the words right out of my mind: "This vote disgusts me"

Yip! The media, and apparently the Australians, tend to forget that this is a human being we are dealing with. And she is only 18. Keep things like this behind closed doors.

 

[Ou grote]

Girl... You'll be a woman soon... (In about 2 weeks hopefully)

What a boyjie!
They should test those Williams sisters as well.

 

[Devill]

did the aussies start this?

Yes.

The 26 year old record is held Jarmila Kratochvílová, who looks like a man....

Holy moly little kids hide! The chude is gonna eat ya!

Yip! The media, and apparently the Australians, tend to forget that this is a human being we are dealing with. And she is only 18. Keep things like this behind closed doors.

It might be that im just drunk but Lance QFT.

 

[APoc184]

did the aussies start this?

Yeah.
Funny coming from a nation that cannot even tell the difference between a woman and a sheep.

 

[Ou grote]

Dad: Caster's my little girl
2009-08-20 11:54Email | Print

All major newspapers' front pages pictured a triumphant Semenya who powered to a 1:55.45 win - the world's best this year - shortly after the athletics governing body announced that the runner's gender was to be verified.

"She is my little girl. I raised her and I have never doubted her gender. She is a woman and I can repeat that a million times," father Jacob Semenya told the popular tabloid Sowetan which dubbed the champion "Our Golden Girl".

"For the first time South Africans have someone to be proud of and detractors are already shouting wolf. It is unfair. I wish they would leave my daughter alone."

Semenya's 80-year-old grandmother Maphuthi Sekgala told The Times that the first year sports science student had long been teased about her boyish looks and for being the only girl in her local soccer team.

"(The controversy) doesn't bother me that much because I know she's a woman - I raised her myself," she said in her rural village in northern Limpopo province.

"She called me after (the heats) and told me that they think she's a man. What can I do when they call her a man, when she's really not a man? It is God who made her look that way."

Semenya's former high school head told the Afrikaans broadsheet Beeld the top runner had played with boys, enjoyed soccer and wore long trousers to school.

"I first realised that she was a girl in Grade 11," he said, explaining how Semenya had moved to stand with a girls team after he had divided the boys and girls for short running race.

Semenya was a total unknown a few weeks ago - with Beeld describing her birthplace as remote and rural, with the teenager living with her grandmother while at high school and growing up without electricity or running water.

The runner's coach Michael Seme laughed off the allegations, saying the athlete fielded constant questions about whether she was a boy from younger athletes when training.

"Then she has to explain that she can't help the fact that her voice is so gruff and that she really is a girl. The remarkable thing is that Caster remains completely calm and never loses her dignity when she is questioned about her gender," Seme told the newspaper.

Semenya had been "crudely humiliated" a few times and the closest Seme said he had seen her to anger was earlier this year when some people wanted her barred from using the ladies restroom.

"Then Caster said: 'Do you want me to pull down my pants that you can see. Those same people came to her later and said they were extremely sorry."

 

[LCBXX]

My sports reporter buddy commented in Divine style: Walks like a man, Talks like a man....

Well I've looked and looked again at the pictures of her and I must say, if it is discovered that she is/was a actually man, I won't be surprised.

If she is a woman, I'd have to say that she needs to femine-up a but. I've seen a couple of really butch lesbian types, but there was always something that hinted that it was a woman with manly traits or whatever.

The 26 year old record is held Jarmila Kratochvílová, who looks like a man....

Damn...what an ugly man-woman-bear-pig-thing. Hasselhoff krulle!

 

[Ou grote]

Well I've looked and looked again at the pictures of her and I must say, if it is discovered that she is/was a actually man, I won't be surprised.

If she is a woman, I'd have to say that she needs to femine-up a but. I've seen a couple of really butch lesbian types, but there was always something that hinted that it was a woman with manly traits or whatever.

Probably won't be in this years SI swimwear calendar.

 

[LCBXX]

Probably won't be in this years SI swimwear calendar.

Or Rolling Stone/FHM/GQ/etc.

 

[LCBXX]

Semenya had been "crudely humiliated" a few times and the closest Seme said he had seen her to anger was earlier this year when some people wanted her barred from using the ladies restroom.

"Then Caster said: 'Do you want me to pull down my pants that you can see. Those same people came to her later and said they were extremely sorry."

To be brutally honest, I would be terrified to see what she was hiding under that green pant.

Rather do DNA or whatever tests they do to determine this. Please. If those tests say she's a chick, it's cool. Just do SHOW me she's one.

 

[chiskmumellow]

If she is a woman, I'd have to say that she needs to femine-up a but.

Why does she need to feminine-up a bit?

 

[LCBXX]

Why does she need to feminine-up a bit?

Because, as it stands, a lot of people, on face value, initially perceive her as being a man and not a woman.

Sure, if you are a woman who wants to be perceived as man (like if you are a lesbian and dress/carry/act/talk as a man would), then booyah.

As it stands she wants people to believe and see her as a woman, which is, generally, not happening and is being disputed by an athletics board.

 

[BinaryJack]

Because, as it stands, a lot of people, on face value, initially perceive her as being a man and not a woman.

Sure, if you are a woman who wants to be perceived as man (like if you are a lesbian and dress/carry/act/talk as a man would), then booyah.

As it stands she wants people to believe and see her as a woman, which is, generally, not happening and is being disputed by an athletics board.

...errr...
The way she looks or her being a woman has got nothing to do with the current situation actually.
This is a matter of sex and not gender.
There are so many pics already posted on this forum of other manly women that are even more butch looking.
So i dont think she has to change the way she looks.

 

[LCBXX]

...errr...
The way she looks or her being a woman has got nothing to do with the current situation actually.
This is a matter of sex and not gender.
There are so many pics already posted on this forum of other manly women that are even more butch looking.
So i dont think she has to change the way she looks.

That's fine. You have your opinion, I respect yours. I can however understand where the whole question of what her sex is comes from, regardless of who brought it up.

 

[BinaryJack]

That's fine. You have your opinion, I respect yours. I can however understand where the whole question of what her sex is comes from, regardless of who brought it up.

But her looks never played a role in the questioning of the record.
It was her track time in Mauritius that started it all.

 

[LCBXX]

But her looks never played a role in the questioning of the record.
It was her track time in Mauritius that started it all.

From the little I've read about all gender verification tests, nearly all the suspected athletes also "looked" suspicious. Dora[Hermann] Ratjen, for example.

 

[chiskmumellow]

But her looks never played a role in the questioning of the record.
It was her track time in Mauritius that started it all.

To be fair, if she looked like Jenny Meadows and ran that time in Mauritius, gender testing wouldn't be considered.

 

[Jewelbox]

Did you hear her speak? Sounds just like a man! Maybe she is a lesbian? What about Martina Navratilova?

 

[OzzieCapie]

Yeah.
Funny coming from a nation that cannot even tell the difference between a woman and a sheep.

Thats a classic...although do remember that the Aussies make the same joke about the Kiwis.

As for Caster...let's wait and see...there is IAAF protocol that needs to be followed and if ASA had pre-empted this by following said protocol, it would have been better managed.

Why did they wait until now and still have head in sand btw, when they could have stubbed it out a year ago when doubts first surfaced.

cheers

 

[RetroBok]

The Clue is in the name Caster Semenya. Sheesh please say I wasn't the first to notice?