Dirtiest player?

OrbitalDawn

Ulysses Everett McGill
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
47,635
Reaction score
9,302
Location
Aboard the Nostalgia For Infinity
What are some nominations? I think possibly Jarrad Hoeata from some of the matches I've watched recently. On the local end probably someone like Deon Fourie. He's almost always in a fight, and tries to sneak punches in.

I think the Heineken Cup probably has a lot more foul play, but I don't really watch it so can't mention any players.
 
Richard Loe might squeeze in on that list
He played 49 Tests between 1987 and 1995, as part of a front row that included Sean Fitzpatrick. His test record consisted of 37 wins, 2 draws, and 10 losses. In addition, he played 29 non-test matches for the All Blacks, 3 as captain.

[edit]Anecdotes

Peter Fitzsimmons tells an amusing anecdote about Loe being 'sorted out' by a player in an Australian State side shortly after Loe broke Paul Carozza's nose after he had scored a try. Loe was immediately 'king-hit' and sought a rest by lying on the ground purportedly injured. After what apparently seemed like a lengthy delay, during which the offending player, Tomasi Tamanivalu, was pleading for an early shower, the first words Loe spoke were directed to the referee, "Don't send him off!".

In another story, a New Zealand man who had been faxing letters to the All Blacks hotel criticizing the team and in particular Loe after a loss got the shock of his life when his phone rang and there was Loe on the other end of the time. "You got a problem", he said. "No, no problem!", replied the man![citation needed]

Throughout his career he received numerous bans for striking, eye gouging and other foul play.
 
Playing outside the laws will have to be McCaw - but that isn't dirty - dirty to me is fighting and sneaking punches - based off of his two return games Etzebeth fits that mould.
 
Sebastien Chabal (very dirty cave man :p)
Hika Reid
Gert Smal
Uli Schmidt
Schalk Burger
James Dalton
Bakkies Botha
Danny Grewcock

Merv Hughes if he had to play rugby
 
Has to be one of the best laughs I have had in a while :D
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X