DSTV with HDMI

Dolby

Honorary Master
Joined
Jan 31, 2005
Messages
39,185
Reaction score
6,158
I'm not sure if this is the correct place to ask this, but here goes anyway :

When will DSTV decoders have HDMI ports? I'm not talking specifically about PVR or DualView decoders as I wouldn't pay extra for those features, but stand alone DSTV decoders with the HDMI port?

The reason I ask is because hear often about the new DTSV HD which is coming next year (or so) ... but there's no decoder with these ports as yet. I've always understood it that the hardware ports appear on items sooner than one can use the technology - so surely it should be very soon? :/ Even if they don't broadcast hi def while we have these port, it would awesome to use for convience of one cable.

I'm looking forward to the day where I can take ONE cable from source to amp and ONE cable from amp to monitor. At maximum I'd only have 4 or 5 cables into my amp and it would look so much better behind there ;) Come 3 years I may have DVD HD ... DSTV HD ... DVD HD HDD ... all displayed on my LCD in HD ... whoohoo!
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure if this is the correct place to ask this, but here goes anyway :

When will DSTV decoders have HDMI ports? I'm not talking specifically about PVR or DualView decoders as I wouldn't pay extra for those features, but stand alone DSTV decoders with the HDMI port?

The reason I ask is because hear often about the new DTSV HD which is coming next year (or so) ...

http://mybroadband.co.za/news/Telecoms/1039.html
High Definition Television will be standard for the 2010 World Cup, but South Africans may not be lucky enough to experience it.

DSTV have said in a recent news article (cant remember where) not to expect HDTV soon. (altho its on trial - go figure)
If you want a satellite decoder with HDMI output, then you can go buy an after-market one. DSTV --DOES-- work on any Irdeto compliant CI hardware. (They are usually PCMCIA type looking cards that you plug your smartcard in to... all CI compliant decoders can use these cards)

(looks like this http://www.madelectronics.com.au/in..._id=39&zenid=cfc753f92cccbb2867304fe50421b022 )
 
Last edited:
ha!! They don't even have component out! maybe HDMI 5 years from now.
 
When will DSTV decoders have HDMI ports?
You're most likely not going to see the new DSTV decoders with HDMI & component output till the end of 2008 or sometime in 2009. That said, DSTV did promise season pass functionality for the current PVR by June 2006 so ... :p

I'm not talking specifically about PVR or DualView decoders as I wouldn't pay extra for those features, but stand alone DSTV decoders with the HDMI port?
It'll be quite some time before DSTV launch a single view (non PVR) decoder with HDMI/component output or HDTV support, those features will be reserved for their premium decoders (i.e. the next PVR).

Dual view functionality has been thrown out the window, the current dual view decoders have already been discontinued and it's inclusion in the current PVR is blamed for many of the major issues with enhancing the PVR's software. To achieve dual/multi view functionality on DSTV's next PVR, you'll require extra decoders (possibly scaled down versions) for each extra viewing environment (i.e. one per zone/room).

The reason I ask is because hear often about the new DTSV HD which is coming next year (or so) ... but there's no decoder with these ports as yet.

I've always understood it that the hardware ports appear on items sooner than one can use the technology - so surely it should be very soon? :/ Even if they don't broadcast hi def while we have these port, it would awesome to use for convience of one cable.
Correct, there would be little point in DSTV using up valuable transponder space to broadcast a HDTV signal that nobody can receive. Due to the fact that DSTV (as well as all new entrants) will be broadcasting their HDTV signal in MPEG4 format, none of the existing decoders will be able to make use of the signal as the decoders only support MPEG2. This limitation extends to many 3rd party decoders as well, including the likes of Dreambox, Topfield, Manhatten, etc. Until recently MPEG4 has been limited to proprietary decoders (e.g. Sky HD box, DirecTV's H20) but this is starting to change, Topfield's TF7700HSCI and Dreambox's still unreleased DM-8000 will provide MPEG4 support.

Something else worth noting is that DSTV have stated that their primary focus on HDTV will be for the broadcasting of sports events. This is rather unfortunate but given that this requires DSTV to upgrade to HD-capable outside broadcast equipment, we may just get lucky and see those existing HDTV produced shows like Lost, Prison Break, Scrubs, etc on our screens a little sooner.

I'm looking forward to the day where I can take ONE cable from source to amp and ONE cable from amp to monitor. At maximum I'd only have 4 or 5 cables into my amp and it would look so much better behind there ;) Come 3 years I may have DVD HD ... DSTV HD ... DVD HD HDD ... all displayed on my LCD in HD ... whoohoo!
Many of the newer amps, those around the R5000 mark and up, will upscale your input source (no matter whether it's composite, s-video or component) and output it via either the component or hdmi connector thus requiring only one cable to your monitor.

The only problem with the above is that most amps that have hdmi and/or component connectors don't have scart connectors. Assuming you have a DSTV decoder with the higher quality RGB scart connector (e.g. single view 720i, dual view or PVR decoder), you're left connecting your DSTV decoder to your amp via a scart -> s-video connector. This is at least better quality than that offered by the current single view decoders which only offer composite connectors.

To make full use of the DSTV decoders RGB scart connector, you could get a scart -> component converter (e.g. Kramer FC-4, Atlona AT-SCART-COMP) but bear in mind that these devices may result in lip-sync issues as they will add a minor delay to the video feed but not the audio feed (it may however be an unnoticeable delay).

Another option for achieving the scart -> component conversion is to get a UK TiVo. Unlike the US TiVo which feature composite and s-video connectors, the UK TiVo has scart connectors for both input and output. By means of a simple software hack the UK TiVo is able to convert the inputted RGB signal and output a component signal. Given that the TiVo is handling the audio as well, there shouldn't be any lip-sync issues :D

If you want a satellite decoder with HDMI output, then you can go buy an after-market one. DSTV --DOES-- work on any Irdeto compliant CI hardware.
Although this is an option, there are a couple of problems going this route. Firstly the cost of decoders with component output tends to be a bit high, added to that the cost of an Irdeto CAM and it starts getting expensive. Next issue is that most of the current decoders won't be able to output the MPEG4 HDTV broadcasts when they eventually do arrive. Then there is the ever present issue of not being able to display the DSTV EPG (TV guide) as it's in a proprietary format. I'm not aware of any 3rd party satellite decoders that are able to display the DSTV EPG without having it downloaded from the web, converted into the relevant format and then uploaded to the decoder. Although the above issues are relevant, this is still one of the better options as far as getting high quality picture output.

If you're happy to spend the amount of money required to go the above route, you may also want to consider the option of setting up a dedicated HTPC with a DVB-S card (see the "HDTV Tv Cards" thread for more on this option).
 
Last edited:
I've been following the thread and meaning to jump in but just haven't had the time to respond to all the inaccuracies established in the early parts of the discussion. arf9999 as well as a couple of others did make some very valid and very needed corrections ;)
OK, so a simple yes or no (you can post a detailed reply in the actual thread):

720p is better than 1080i?
 
OK, so a simple yes or no (you can post a detailed reply in the actual thread):

720p is better than 1080i?
Different horses for different courses, 720p is better for fast moving action while 1080i is better for highly detailed scenery. That's from the broadcast and content production perspective, the "When is SA getting High Def?" thread goes into this a with a little more complexity.

As far as TV selection based on resolution is concerned, think of it this way:
- 720p input on a 720p TV is native
- 1080i/p input on a 720p screen gets downscaled
- 720p input on a 1080p TV gets upscaled
- 1080i/p on a 1080p screen is native
 
Different horses for different courses, 720p is better for fast moving action while 1080i is better for highly detailed scenery. That's from the broadcast and content production perspective, the "When is SA getting High Def?" thread goes into this a with a little more complexity.

As far as TV selection based on resolution is concerned, think of it this way:
- 720p input on a 720p TV is native
- 1080i/p input on a 720p screen gets downscaled
- 720p input on a 1080p TV gets upscaled
- 1080i/p on a 1080p screen is native

That part is very relevant to the thread I linked, thanks.

Sorry for the temporary hijack.
 
Although this is an option, there are a couple of problems going this route. Firstly the cost of decoders with component output tends to be a bit high, added to that the cost of an Irdeto CAM and it starts getting expensive. Next issue is that most of the current decoders won't be able to output the MPEG4 HDTV broadcasts when they eventually do arrive.

None of the current SD decoders will work Mpeg4 ... the bitrates for a NEC EMMA processor that DSTV use in their decoder is rather crap. (it s the same for the cheap PPC ones too)

Most of the HD decoders have upgradable CODECS for the video/audio. I have just implemented WMV/WMA on a AMD Geode based HD decoder while waiting, DVB-S2 isnt finalised and every tom-dick-n-harry as a different interpretation on how the DVB stream should look :D

I do agree that costs and the EPG issues, but thats the options in SA!
 
You're most likely not going to see the new DSTV decoders with HDMI & component output till the end of 2008 or sometime in 2009. That said, DSTV did promise season pass functionality for the current PVR by June 2006 so ......<snip>

Aaah another excellent detailed post from TivoZA... I do like your knowledge on the subject. :)

OT/
I have not been following the DSTV forums lately but any idea when the much promised feature software upgrade is due out for the PVR - was scheduled for end September /October this year :rolleyes:

*/keeping fingers crossed
 
Until Joe Public gets educated enough to demand certain quality of boradcast , I am afraid that the No-Choice and UEC (puke) will just produce slop and tell you that its magic.

Have a look at the broadcast resolutions being sent atm. Channels running on 384 hor pixels. Sports on 576 and MM1 on 576 and the rest a mis-match not meeting DVB specs.

Doldbly Digital 5.1 transmits 2 rear speakers as mono !!!! vak

AVR
 
I have not been following the DSTV forums lately but any idea when the much promised feature software upgrade is due out for the PVR - was scheduled for end September /October this year :rolleyes:
Given the fact that it hasn't yet been released to the field trialists (i.e. beta testers), it's unlikely to be released to the general public before November :rolleyes: If it's not released in November, don't expect a release until February as updates are frozen during December to prevent unforeseen hiccups causing issues and January tends to be a rather quite month as people are generally on leave.
 
Given the fact that it hasn't yet been released to the field trialists (i.e. beta testers), it's unlikely to be released to the general public before November :rolleyes: If it's not released in November, don't expect a release until February as updates are frozen during December to prevent unforeseen hiccups causing issues and January tends to be a rather quite month as people are generally on leave.

:( Bad news.. since the field trialists will most probably find bugs that need to be sorted out so I do not see us getting it before March 08...

Oh well!
 
Hi I'm a really green noob. I want to buy a solution to record DSTV to my PC. I can’t for the life of me get myself to sit in front of the TV and be dictated to about what and when I watch anything. I think this is the most archaic form of entertainment. I would rather record stuff for a month and then choose what I watch. :-} To do this I want to record to my PC.

I have a question TIVOZA. I would really like a definitive answer about DVB-S2, DVB-S, and CAM and HDMI. Is it at all possible to use a DVB-S2 Card (say a Twinhan or the like), with CAM (Diablo, Irdeto, Dragon???), with a legal smart card from NEW 1100 decoder, to receive HD. (If I cant at least SD?)

Firstly would a DVB-S2 card (HD???) work or should I rather get a DVB-S (SD???) one? What “make” card should I consider?

Secondly I would like to know which CAM would definitely work with DSTV.

Thirdly is there anf PC cards with HDMI input to record the HD from DSTV?

My real question then is:
Could anyone please tell me which card, cam combination with a new decoder's smartcard would work. Money isn't really a problem so I don't mind buying the best if it really is the best and works very well.

Thanks
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X