Forceps not removed in operation. What recourse?

Carneades

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 3, 2010
Messages
310
Reaction score
0
An acquaintance was diagnosed with intestinal cancer around Christmas 2012. She was operated on in the beginning of 2013 and once she had healed began a rigorous and long course of chemotherapy which she completed in November. She was given a break for the holiday season and is due to start radiation therapy now. Yesterday she went in to have the preparation work done for this therapy. At some stage of the day she was told not to leave the center where this was being done as there was a problem and the doctor needed to see her urgently.
After waiting for said doctor to clear his/her dairy for the day she was informed that the X-rays from earlier had shown that there were a pair of forceps or scissors that had been left in her bowel area when they operated necessitating an operation to remove them before any radiation can take place.
When being admitted to a Private as opposed to a State hospital the admission forms have a waiver absolving the institution and its employees from all and any claims of omission, negligence and malpractice. Our Consumer Protection Act appears to allow this and in a recent case our Supreme Court upheld the validity of this section of the admission form if the patient or their representative signs without crossing the section out. The pressures on those being admitted to hospital for any reason should not include having to have the legal nous to look for these clauses in the “contract”.
I am pissed that people are expected and do sign away their rights. I am pissed that the staff working in the operating theater cannot do their jobs and account for all the equipment used in the performance of their jobs. I am pissed at a woman who has been through so much should have the additional burden of having to face an operation that should have been unneeded!
Now I ask what recourse do these people have. The surgeon who performed the operation has stated that he will do the operation to remove without charge as will the anesthetist, the hospital on the other hand will admit no fault and will be charging for all services provided to repair the incompetence or whatever of their staff. Any ideas will be most welcome.
 
regardless of other recourse which you should have a look at your trusty attorneys to deal with the simple fact is that the HPCSA can receive a complaint concerning the medical staff - while I abhor opportunistic ambulance chasing damages litigation is the surest quality control mechanism there is.

The doctors involved in performing the original surgery frankly have an ethical duty to ensure that (on the facts as presented) the patient is out of harms way - do no harm being a credo of medicine regardless of whether the Hippocratic oath is taken or not - and the hospital private or public has a relationship with the medical staff to serve as their facility.

I would address the fact with the surgeon that if as a result of the hospitals attitude a patient is left worse off after surgery than before a complaint with the HPCSA should naturally follow. The hospital admin might not give a **** about the patient but they certainly will give a **** about the medical doctors who operate in the hospital.
 
That's bull****. The hospital should at the very least cover all her charges or make the surgeon responsible carry the charges.

Can she not sue them for pain and suffering, or does the clause absolve them from pain and suffering caused by their negligence as well?
 
For a start, she should inform the surgeon that she expects him to carry all the additional costs, including theatre and other hospital costs. She should not be out of pocket in any way because of the surgeon's negligence. Do it politely but firmly, and in writing. Set a reply-by date. After that, send a claim and copy his insurer and the clinic CEO. Again set a reply-by date.

All this of course with the aid of a good attorney.

Yes, her normal Aquilian action can also include a portion for pain & suffering.

Remember, though she might have signed away her common law rights, she can still ask and come to a private agreement with the surgeon. Nothing but obduracy stops him from agreeing, which is why it's worth starting the process politely.
 
Last edited:
I heard a lawyer speaking about that clause on 702 once and he said that no one can get you to sign away your rights, just as someone cannot employ workers for R1 an hour, even if the workers agree to it. She should probably go speak to a lawyer and report them to the medical counsel in the least.
 
Important - she should refuse to sign any docs accepting financial responsibility for the corrective op. Insist that the surgeon accept liability for the theatre and hospital fees, and that he or his proxy sign.
 
Having it removed this week coming. Will have to stay in hospital for three days at their personal cost at this stage of the affair. She was having problems with her back and legs which it is thought are as a result of the "mistake"!
 
Get a second opinion urgently so they can witness Xray and advise of complications that could arise. There might have been a swab or something that could cause infections etc.
I would be very careful with the way forward just to ensure liability down the road.
 
Hospital and doc/surgeon better hope they have insurance..all complications as a result of it and extra will be settled. I think in this case they usually go for the hospital as it's part of the general staff as they need to ensure that all eq is accounted. Surgeon for negligence of leaving equipment in for duration.. Ie it was not left purposely.

Lawyer up
 
Last edited:
a pair of forceps at the beginning of the bowel area for a year? and she had no problems? something isn't adding up here for sure. this is a foreign object which most definitely shouldn't be there and she has no symptoms. sorry i don't buy this one.
 
Should be surgical stainless steel which would render it safe from any magnetism due to it's non magnetic propeties! Radiation is another issue thou!

Stainless steel, even surgical, is still magnetic.
The fridge magnet sticks to my surgical scissors like a limpet.
 
If all else fails just mention to the hospital and doctor that they will be featured in an article in the local newspaper. Worked for my aunt who was experiencing multiple strokes and needed a referral for specialist help.
 
I would contact the medical council and ask them how to go forward. Request that they do not interfere as yet, but advise you on how/what....
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X