Forum Software

mikeyb

Senior Member
Joined
May 22, 2008
Messages
797
Reaction score
30
Location
The middle-of-no-where
Can anyone recommend any forum software. I've downloaded and played around with phpBB, I though it was very good but I like to know what other good ones are there to compare it to. :)

P.S. Anybody know which software MyBroadband's forum is written in?
 
No I would have to say and recommend myBB 1.4 to you! Just released yesterday! Its the best!
 
I'd suggest SMF (simple machines forum) as it has LOADS of themes and extensions available for free. I haven't used the others too extensively though... :D
 
http://www.simplemachines.org/ is very customisable and is free.

Personally though, I think that IP.Board is one of the best forums, http://www.invisionpower.com/ but if I can remember, it isn't free.

I'd suggest SMF (simple machines forum) as it has LOADS of themes and extensions available for free. I haven't used the others too extensively though... :D

If you're looking for a simple little forum script, vanilla is pretty good.

http://getvanilla.com
'
I just downloaded and played around with all of them - and they are all good :D:D I just have to play inky-pinky-ponky to pick the best :o:D
 
Isn't VBuletin and phpBB just about the same thing. I thought VB was just a commercial implementation of it?
 
The latest incarnation of PhpBB is very different from vBulletin. And don't listen to people, it's quite good :D

What forum software depends on what you're going to do with it and how much traffic you expect. Some forum software is more scalable (phpbb) while others have more enterprise level features (IPB, vBulletin) and generally come at a price.

Any of them will do in a pinch though unless you're looking at something the scale of Gaia (which runs a customized version of PhpBB). SomethingAwful runs a customized version of vBulletin which they've eliminated almost all the customary bloat from.
 
So was it the same codebase at some time then? If so, when did it split off?

The thing with these kind of applications, is the performance is down to two things:

1. Your codebase. If your code is lean and cacheable, you can do wonders with it.

But to a much bigger extent:

2. Your SQL queries and DB configuration. If you don't do stupid **** like select count(*) to find out how many posts or whatever, and you configure your database server properly and design/optimise your database properly, again, you can squeeze a lot of performance out of a single server.

To compare the above, I've worked on two MySQL database servers in the last week that are at either extremes. One was a single proc box with a two disc SATA RAID-1 and 2GB memeory, doing in excess of 2500 queries per second. The second was a Dell R800, eight cores, 8GB memory, SCSI RAID-10, struggling to get over 250 queries per second after I did a fair bit of configuration and general table optimisation. The difference is down to the kind of queries ran on either. The first box have properly designed databases, with proper data segmentation, the second started as something small with only a few tables that they just kept adding on to with no thought for how well it would scale. They basically have to re-write their application to make it work better.
 
I'm not aware of it having had the same codebase but I suppose it's entirely possible. I've worked with both and some of the ways vBulletin and phpBB do things are vaguely similar.

Like I say though, most of the time your average user isn't going to notice a significant difference between forum software unless they're reaching large traffic. That said, looking over the list of changes SA have made to the vBulletin code, it looks like quite a lot of it was bloated/inefficient even for their relatively small {compared to Gaia at least) community so I imagine that had a fair amount to do with it.

Stuff like:

- Cleaned up templates while praying for death; reduced number of templates from
1397 to less than 250

phpBB3 appears to use 98 Templates and 62 tables compared to vBulletin's 1397 and 200 odd respectively. vBulletin also doesn't do the whole MVC thing :D

Anyway, random rambling over - any forum software will probably do in a pinch, just keep scalability, upgrade and conversion issues in mind in case you ever need to change.
 
Resurrection, I suppose it is almost Easter,

What would you guys recommend for setting up a small forum these days in terms of free platforms.

Mostly a Q & A forums for a Niche industry


Thanks
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X