Hezbollah ain't no pushovers

@neio:

Your source, on the other hand, is completely unbiased and totally objective:

HNN.us said:
Lebanon: How We Got Here
Yoav Gelber

Mr. Gelber is a professor of history at the University of Haifa. He is currently at UNC Chapel Hill.
 
At your suggestion. I have highlighted some events you may have missed.
wikipedia said:
Precursor to the violence

As of June 8, 2006, a senior Palestinian security official close to the Hamas government, Jamal Abu Samhadana, was killed in an Israeli air strike, sparking angry demonstrations in Rafah, southern Gaza Strip. For many months, the Israelis have regularly shelled open areas such as fields and orchards in an effort to prevent Palestinian militants using them to fire their missiles into nearby Israeli territory.

On June 9, 2006, eight civilians on a beach near Beit Lahiya - seven of whom belonged to the same family and three of whom were children - were killed and dozens of others wounded in an explosion on the beach of Beit Lahya in northern Gaza Strip. The Palestinians held Israel responsible for the incident, but Israel denied any involvement. Four other people were also killed in separate Israeli air strikes in northern Gaza Strip, Palestinians said.

The military wing of the Palestinian militant group Hamas said it will no longer respect a self-imposed truce that had held since February 2005.[7]. In a statement on its website, the Izzedine al-Qassam Brigade said Israeli "massacres" had spurred the decision. Hamas said it fired rockets at Israel for the first time since its truce 16 months ago, in response to the deaths. [8]. Israel, which has been shelling open areas of northern Gaza to prevent rocket attacks, promised to investigate the deaths. "If innocent civilians have been killed by an Israeli shell, that is totally unacceptable," said government spokesman Mark Regev. "If people have to pay a price with their careers because of negligence or some other factor, that will be done ..."

Jordan spoke of the killings as a crime which would further increase tensions, while Turkey said they were a severe blow to efforts to bring peace. Five Israeli human rights organisations demanded an urgent to end the killing of Palestinian civilians by Israeli security forces. A joint statement put out by the organisations says that since October 2000 at least 1,647 Palestinians - nearly half the number killed by Israeli troops - had been taking no part in fighting at the time of their deaths. The groups said 704 under-18s had been killed by Israeli troops and blamed "illegal expansion of Israel's open-fire regulations, double messages regarding the use of force... and failure to conduct independent investigations".

An Israeli army spokesman said chief of staff Dan Halutz had ordered an immediate stop to all artillery shelling of Gaza while an investigation was carried out into the incident. Speaking before the Hamas statement, Mr Abbas condemned the Israeli strikes in Gaza. "What the Israeli occupation forces are doing in the Gaza Strip constitutes a war of extermination and bloody massacres against our people," he said. UN Secretary General Kofi Annan said he was "deeply disturbed" by the killings and called for a full investigation. The foreign ministers of Russia and the UK also condemned the strike [9].

On June 11, 2006, eleven Palestinians including nine civilians were killed in an Israeli missile attack on a vehicle carrying militants on their way to fire rockets [10].

On June 26, 2006, several Palestinian militias claimed responsibility for the attack of a Israeli military post, killing two soldiers and kidnapping the Corporal Gilad Shalit [11]. The kidnappers called for Israel to release hundreds of imprisoned Palestinians under the age of 18. Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert denied any negotiations and alternatively, in response to the two killed soldiers and the one kidnapped, called for a military operation in Gaza to extract the kidnapped soldier.

Please note again, that I am not defending anyone. I think that the situation in that part of the world is the result of a long, complicated and ugly history. Everyone involved has contributed to the current situation.

I am merely disputing your cut and dried version of events.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lebanon#2006_conflict_with_Israel
 
Last edited:
Please take a look at the map to see how far the shelling on the beach was from the Lebanese border.
Hizbollah attacked first, the events in Gaza, whilst bad, did not take place anywhere close to Lebanon.

http://home.mchsi.com/~jason911/Temp/israel.jpg

PS, the little yellow explosion icons are actually the reach of the missiles being fired on Israel as we speak.

Southern Lebanon will obviously look much worse.
 
Last edited:
Sunnic said:
agressor? dont forget who stole who's land and who started the killing first, as you say for every action there is a reaction!

"it [hizbollah] was founded in 1982 with the declared aim to fight the Israeli occupation of Southern Lebanon" If im not wrong Israel withdrew from Southern Lebanon more then 5 years ago, why are they still around and what rights do they have attacking Israel on israeli soil or kidnapping soldiers from the Israeli side of the border.

And just in case you are in this debate without any actual knowledge of the situation, I think this little extract from WIkipedia puts thingsinto perspective nicely
Wikipedia said:
Operation Peace of the Galilee (מבצע שלום הגליל, Mivtsa Shalom HaGalil in Hebrew), began June 6, 1982, when the Israel Defense Forces invaded southern Lebanon. The Government of Israel gave a green light for the invasion as a response to the assassination attempt against Israel's ambassador to the United Kingdom, Shlomo Argov by Fatah - Revolutionary Council and to artillery attacks launched by the Palestine Liberation Organization against populated areas in northern Israel. See also Operation Litani.

After attacking PLO, Syrian and Muslim Lebanese forces, Israel occupied southern Lebanon. Surrounded in West Beirut and subject to heavy bombardment, the PLO and the Syrian forces negotiated passage from Lebanon with the aid of international peacekeepers.

Hizbollah exist purely to propagate fear and terrorism. They are murderers without a cause other then the maniacal destruction of an entire country which has existed and defended itself quite spectacularly for more then 50 years. The last thing Isarel wants is to be back in Lebanon but with thousands of rockets falling on more then a third of the country what choice do they have.
 
Last edited:
chiskop said:
On June 11, 2006, eleven Palestinians including nine civilians were killed in an Israeli missile attack on a vehicle carrying militants on their way to fire rockets

I cant understand how this can cited as an example of the wrong doings of Israel. Israel targeted militants with rockets. Unfortuanately nine civilians died, that is tragic but not surprising considering the documented use by organisations such as hamas and hizbollah of civillians and children as shields or decoys. Even as we speak hizbollah are using peoples living rooms as launch pads for rockets. If israel take out the launch pads they probably kill Lebanese civilians if they dont more rockets land on Israeli civilians.
 
It was you - Nah, it was you! Real mature ways to settle arguments - My bombs be bigger than yours - All your bases be mine. Pity about the thousands dead: men, woman and children. Casualities of war - Bah, who gives a damn! Take that!

The world should take a wakeup pill.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X