While I think each company will have their own researchers, nutritionists and vets doing tests and what not to come up with a good product, I prefer to stick with one recommended by my vet.
We originally moved Fayth from a supermarket brand, on to Vets Choice a couple years ago and at the time did a few calculations, to compare the price between the products. Interestingly enough, per feeding, Vets Choice worked out to about R0.50 cheaper than that brand we normally bought at the supermarket. Even though it looks like you're paying more, you're feeding your dog less, so it balances out.
While I don't want to influence your choice, have a look at the products you're comparing and work out how much it costs per helping. You may be surprised at the results.
Edit: Fayth is now on Hills J/D for her arthritis.
We originally moved Fayth from a supermarket brand, on to Vets Choice a couple years ago and at the time did a few calculations, to compare the price between the products. Interestingly enough, per feeding, Vets Choice worked out to about R0.50 cheaper than that brand we normally bought at the supermarket. Even though it looks like you're paying more, you're feeding your dog less, so it balances out.
While I don't want to influence your choice, have a look at the products you're comparing and work out how much it costs per helping. You may be surprised at the results.
Edit: Fayth is now on Hills J/D for her arthritis.