Morning or evening exercise?

I find running interminably boring.
Then cycle. Else, stay fat.
Once you start doing races both running and cycling becomes very addictive.
If you want to lose weight then you can stick to aerobic exercise. If you want to build muscle you're stuffed unless you pick up some weights. Even aerobic exercise by itself will get diminishing returns without weights as well.
I got excellent results from just running and cycling. Mix in some sit-ups and push-ups if you want the "muscle image" that most noobs crave.
 
I got excellent results from just running and cycling. Mix in some sit-ups and push-ups if you want the "muscle image" that most noobs crave.

You cannot get a decent upper torso from running and cycling. You will slim down but your upper body will look puny. It's not about a muscle image, it's just about having an all round healthy appearance. Long distance runners look emaciated to me. If you have to stick with aerobic then rather mix running/cycling with swimming twice a week - you'll get an adequate balance.
 
Morning excercises are the best we are not sayign you roll otu of bed and do excercise but you should definatly excercise before you eat as this will raise your RMR (Resting metabolic Rate) for the whole day so pretty much you will loose more weight throughout the day if you excercise in the mornings ... I have taken to swimming every mornign at the gym

Personally I would not exercise on an empty stomach, I'd have toast or a sandwich an hour before I exercise. Aside from the fact that I feel really queasy after a short time exercising on an empty stomach, and have less stamina, there are no real benefits to it and you may actually lose muscle mass rather than fat.
 
No, you burn a lot more fat if you run before breakfast. If you run after you ate you might cramp or continually burp up what ever you are.
 
No, you burn a lot more fat if you run before breakfast. If you run after you ate you might cramp or continually burp up what ever you are.

You should eat at least an hour before exercising, then no cramping, burping or anything like that. It is a myth that you burn more fat running on an empty stomach and there is evidence that you may be burning muscle mass.

THE DETAILS: In an article published in this month's issue of Strength and Conditioning Journal, Schoenfeld analyzed the research that's been conducted on how our bodies function during exercise and concluded that, whether you eat or don't eat before exercise, research shows your body burns the same amount of fat. And working out on an empty stomach can actually cause muscle loss, he adds, if you do it on a regular basis. When you're hungry, your body goes into survival mode and draws protein away from muscle, where it's less crucial to survival, than from your kidneys and liver, where the body normally looks for protein. "Your body cares more about survival than looking good at the beach," he says. As a result, you lose muscle mass, which can, over time, suppress your metabolism and make it harder to lose weight.

On a more basic level, he says, exercising on an empty stomach means you don't have the energy to put in a really good workout. "One of the benefits of aerobic exercise is doing it at a higher intensity," he says. "If you're just getting out of bed, slogging through your exercises like a zombie, you won't be able to get that intensity."
http://www.rodale.com/eating-exercise?page=0,0

After reviewing years of research on the subject, a report published this year in Strength and Conditioning Journal concluded that the body burns roughly the same amount of fat regardless of whether you eat before a workout. But you’re likely to lose muscle by exercising in a depleted state, the report found, and without fuel to aid the workout, exercise intensity and overall calorie burn will be reduced.
http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/06/27/does-exercising-on-an-empty-stomach-burn-more-fat/
 
Maybe I'm a freak then cause it sure as hell worked wonders for me.

Well, unless you've actually measured your fat loss over time - both eating before exercise and not eating before exercise - you can't really tell the difference.
 
29 November 2010 I weighed 120kg and on 19 July 2011 I weighed 80kg. Thats a 1/3rd loss in 8 months. Since then it fluctuated between 79kg and 84kg. This was only from running and cycling - not been to the gym since 2008.

This is why I am a pretty strong supporter of doing it on your own - without a gym, personal trainer, dietitian or anyone else you can blame or use as excuse. Once you do it for yourself only and you only have yourself accountable for your progress - thats when you start to see results.

Initially I only wanted to loose weight, 6600km later I am hooked on running and cycling.
 
You should eat at least an hour before exercising, then no cramping, burping or anything like that. It is a myth that you burn more fat running on an empty stomach and there is evidence that you may be burning muscle mass.


http://www.rodale.com/eating-exercise?page=0,0


http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/06/27/does-exercising-on-an-empty-stomach-burn-more-fat/

If this true how does one have a meal an hour before you exercise if exercising is going to be the first thing you do when you wake up.
 
If this true how does one have a meal an hour before you exercise if exercising is going to be the first thing you do when you wake up.

If I was to exercise in the morning (I'm an evening exerciser) I would wake up, have a coffee and toast and do other things for an hour before exercising. But everyone is different, what works for me won't work for others. Rouxenator, for example, likes to exercise before breakfast. For me personally, I've tried this a few times, I feel like I want to throw up about 15 minutes into my exercise routine if I'm on an empty stomach.
So YMMV and all that...
 
What are the pros and cons of exercising in the morning vs exercising in the evening,in terms of practicality and effectiveness?


Doesn't matter. The more time there is between your last meal and exercise the better.

So if you exercise in the morning, it must be before breakfast.
If you exercise in the evening, it must be before dinner and you should skip lunch. If you eat lunch then obviously exercising in the morning is better due to the longer time interval between exercise and your last meal.

See here for resources on meal frequency and exercise/metabolism myths http://www.leangains.com/2010/10/top-ten-fasting-myths-debunked.html
 
I'm trying to run in the AM 3x a week in conjunction with my usual weight training in the afternoon. Will let you know how it goes once work actually allows me to do this for more than 2 weeks
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X