Need a replacement for TradeShield / iShield

InTheCube

Expert Member
Joined
Aug 8, 2008
Messages
4,581
Reaction score
87
Location
InTheCube.co.za
Hi.

At my company, we are currently using TradeShield / iShield as our gateway to the internet. It is also our DHCP server, content filter, and internt usage monitor. However, I find that the software really sucks. I doesn't doesn't meet our needs, and I would like to replace it.

What I require in a replacement software package are the following features:
- an HTTP proxy, for caching of HTTP traffic, to reduce bandwidth costs, and improve speeds for commonly accessed sites.
- a DHCP server which allows fixing of IP addresses to specific MAC addresses
- assigning of friendly names to MAC addresses (e.g. : SalesPrinter, CCTV-PC, PastelServer) which will be used throughout the software.
- a monitoring tool, to monitor bandwidth usage by MAC address, or by "account" - which can have multiple MAC addresses linked to it.
- the ability to set usage limits per MAC address, or account.
- a website/content filter, to filter out porn sites, warez/crack sites, etc.
- firewall

The main idea of the software is to be able control internet usage on our local network, as well as act as our Gateway/Firewall to the internet. Tradeshield/iShield really sucks at this.

For e.g. once TradeShield "sees" a new device on the network, it will pick up its name, and that name will remain forever linked to the MAC address of the Device. So for e.g. if I install a new PC, but don't change the default computer name assigned to it by Windows, and then connect this machine to the network, TradeShield will pick up the default name, .e.g. Acer-User322304, and remember it forever. Now in the usage reports, I have several machines called Acer-2390..., or other weird names that make no sense, and I can't change this. So it's very difficult to figure out who the culprits are, without maintaining my own list of MAC address to User mappings.

Please help!
 
I believe what I am looking for is called a "Network Security Appliance" - this is a dedicated hardware device.

However, I am also interested in Software Solutions. Currently, TradeShield runs on a Linux box, and I am hoping to find a software solution that will also run on Linux.

Please help..
 
I believe what I am looking for is called a "Network Security Appliance" - this is a dedicated hardware device.

However, I am also interested in Software Solutions. Currently, TradeShield runs on a Linux box, and I am hoping to find a software solution that will also run on Linux.

Please help..

Smoothwall, Ipcop, Clarkconnect, PFSense - Linux firewalls - well Pfsense is BSD based I think.

Try those.

J
 
I've heard of something called a CyberRoam device which you may want to look into. Otherwise one of the firewalls mentioned by jsheed could do the trick.

If you want to get a little more advanced, there's always Microsoft ISA Server.
 
What I require in a replacement software package are the following features:
- an HTTP proxy, for caching of HTTP traffic, to reduce bandwidth costs, and improve speeds for commonly accessed sites.
- a DHCP server which allows fixing of IP addresses to specific MAC addresses
- assigning of friendly names to MAC addresses (e.g. : SalesPrinter, CCTV-PC, PastelServer) which will be used throughout the software.
- a monitoring tool, to monitor bandwidth usage by MAC address, or by "account" - which can have multiple MAC addresses linked to it.
- the ability to set usage limits per MAC address, or account.
- a website/content filter, to filter out porn sites, warez/crack sites, etc.
- firewall

Smoothwall :

HTTP Proxy : YES
DHCP Server : YES
Assigning friendly names to MAC/IP's : Not sure - although if it is Windows PC's Windows'll do that automatically (assign a friendly name to the IP so you can still do a ping pastel-pc from any other windows PC). I never had the need for this functionality, maybe others can help with this one?
Monitoring Tool : YES (SARG)
Cap Limits : NO (You can, however, use the bandview mod to see bandwidth consumed per IP)
Content Filter : YES (Dansguardian or URL Filter)

More MOD's can be found here : http://community.smoothwall.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=26&t=23845
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X