nVidia 8600GT a lemon?

doobiwan

Executive Member
Joined
Jul 28, 2005
Messages
5,975
Reaction score
3
Location
Sydney, Australia
Oh dear.

I wondered why I hadn't seen any 7600GT vs 8600GT reviews yet.

http://www.legionhardware.com/document.php?id=637&p=5

Just consider the 8600GT is $50 more expensive.

Not at all, the 8600 GT is a joke in my opinion and does not deserve to be part of the x600 GT series. If anything, what we have see here today should have been performance delivered by the 8500 GT, not the 8600 GT. The results really spoke for themselves, as the GeForce 8600 GT was 12% slower in Far Cry, 17% slower in F.E.A.R, 7% slower in X3: Reunion and 19.5% slower in Company of Heroes. The only two games that the 8600 GT came out on top in was Prey (15.5%) and Supreme Commander (27.5%), making a two out of six effort very poor indeed.

Making matters worse is the glaring fact that the new GeForce 8600 GT currently costs $170 US where as the 7600 GT can easily be had for $110 US. This means for the extra $60 US you only get Direct X10 support, which is pretty much useless at this point in time. In fact, it will be a while before quality DX10 games out weigh DX9 games, so what is the point of the 8600 GT? As far as we can see there is no point, it’s a dud! There is little to no reason for anyone to invest $170 US into a mid-range DX10 graphics card now. Especially given by the time quality DX10 games are out, mid-range supporting graphics cards will be much faster and even cheaper!
 
Well the 8800 cards are pro. 8800GTS 320mb in particular... great performance at a decent price, especially if you're picking up one of the XFX's.
 
I don't think it is worth it, personally. Rather wait a while for the cards to be manufactured a bit better and the speed to rise and prices to drop and then consider buying a mid-range 8xxxGT/GS card.
 
and to think I nearly decided to wait for this card :o

I waited month after month after my PC packed up at the end of last year. But when the 8800GTS 340mb came out I went for it and went well over my budget.

Ahhh thank god for that :cool:

*pats himself on the back*
 
I suggest you flog it now, WKJ and get the 8800GTS at least

Thats what im trying to do coz watch, in about 2 months itl be worth 3/4 less then you paid for it :(
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X