Me too - there was a new rapid evolution in gaming, from a mechanics perspective, graphics perspective, story perspective, etc. all the time, back then. Right now, I find that it is a lot more "settled", so one hardly ever gets the "Wow, I've never even seen anything like this before" effect.
I still remember when I saw a Commodore when my Atari was all I knew, when I saw PC Sierra adventure games, when I first saw CGA, then EGA, then VGA. When I first saw Castle Adventure, Rogue, Mach3, then Wolfenstein 3D, Doom, Quake, Decent, Baldurs Gate, Might and Magic, Warcraft, Diablo, etc. Each one was mind blowing - it's a little hard to get that same system shock (see what I did) going from a 2018 game to a 2019 game.