[Opinion] Don't apologise - empathise

OrbitalDawn

Ulysses Everett McGill
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
47,678
Reaction score
9,368
Location
Aboard the Nostalgia For Infinity
If you read only one race-thing this week...

Justice Malala seems to get it better than most.

Apartheid was racism on an industrial scale. Its key architects took the opinions of your dumb, garden-variety racist, like Penny Sparrow, and turned them into a ruthless, systematic machine of disenfranchisement, impoverishment, torture and murder over decades.

In light of the racial tweets last week, what should South African whites do?

Here's a start: Don't denigrate black pain. Don't even try to pretend you understand the level of anger and pain that white racism and apartheid have done to blacks. If you have to listen, empathise and move on. Those who complain are not whining.

They are not just in pain, they want you to acknowledge the sheer horror of what happened here by speaking and acting with thoughtfulness and care.

Many whites ask: What do they want us to do? Actually, nothing. Not an apology, not a project of reparation. Just don't denigrate the pain, or try to make the "good old days" seem better than they were. They were worse than you can imagine.

For my children, for black people who have suffered in the past and continue to feel the brunt of apartheid's effects today, here's something to think about: the Penny Sparrows of the world are numerous. They are distracting. They are tiring. They are, crucially, irrelevant. We will never go back to what they hanker for: the days of apartheid. We have won.

This country faces real problems that a Penny Sparrow cannot even come close to comprehending. This is our real and urgent challenge.

We have 500,000 children passing matric this year into an economy with 35% unemployment. I want to talk, to fight and to do something about that. There is massive inequality. I want to help find a solution to that. There is poverty on a grand scale. There is corruption. There is no water in large swathes of the country.

Just a year ago a child fell into a pit latrine at school in Limpopo. Children are taught under trees. These are the real, urgent, problems that we face.

Racism? There is nothing I can do about Penny Sparrow. She was a racist throughout her life. Being blessed with a Nelson Mandela didn't change her. She will not change now. By all means she must be outed. Yet don't lose focus, particularly if you are a political leader. You are here to make poor people's lives materially better today than they were yesterday. Deal with the Sparrows but don't lose your focus.

There is an expression used by ANC activists - siyaqhuba. It means we go on, despite the noise. When I hear and meet the Sparrows of this world, all I say is this - "siyaqhuba", despite what they say. We are keeping on, building a better country every day, word by word and deed by deed, despite the failings of many of our leaders.
 
the Politics of this is to detract you from the REAL problems... thus short minded things like racist is being thrust into the spotlight... to what benefit? discord... political gain.

**im all against racism, however all this happening now before elections?
 

A-fckin'-men.

This guy gets it.
The inhumane shlt has gone down, there's nothing we can do about it. Acknowledge, empathize and move onto the major issues at hand...right now. (As he says, don't ever downplay what happened. There was some seriously fcked up stuff that went down.)

Arguing about idiotic racist remarks, though, is not going to put food in that starving child's belly. Don't get sucked into the government's race-driven emotional BS campaign. (They have nothing else...certainly not any kind of good track record in helping the people help themselves.) See it for what it is and work together to "fix" this country. Once everyone is "sorted" and shlt works, then by all means, go after those racists and do what you gotta to do.
The no.1 problem (pun intended) is the poster child for corruption. That punk, his cronies and everything he stands for has got to go.
 
I believe that we have won, as a country and if the other side of the coin is that sparrow chick and her ilk, then yes, they have lost.
Nobody's lost. The sparrow chick and her ilk helped people across all races to bring things to the table, take it out in the open and unite again against racism. Sure there will always be bigots and the law needs to "provide" for them accordingly.
 
Brilliant article.

When I see black people from the older generation, those who look in their 50's and older, I always get a twinge of sorrow and empathy. The hardships that apartheid put these people through is something I can never hope to comprehend and hope I never find out what that word "apartheid" really feels like.
 
the Politics of this is to detract you from the REAL problems... thus short minded things like racist is being thrust into the spotlight... to what benefit? discord... political gain.

**im all against racism, however all this happening now before elections?

Do you not realise that Malala is talking about people like you? This is not a "political gain" tool but an issue that people feel strongly about. What, should we ignore Sparrow because elections are around the corner?
 
There is one thing I want to nit pick on though. One can only empathize with someone when you truly know what they are going through, when you have been through a similar experience yourself. You can however show sympathy to someone in pain/distress without the experiences yourself.
 
Apartheid was racism on an industrial scale. Its key architects took the opinions of your dumb, garden-variety racist, like Penny Sparrow, and turned them into a ruthless, systematic machine of disenfranchisement, impoverishment, torture and murder over decades.
Umkhonto we Sizwe and the glorious ANC death camps.

Many whites, however, cannot begin to comprehend the anger and pain that racism and apartheid inflicted and continue to inflict on black people.
Its been more than 20 years now. Move on FFS.
 
Last edited:
Do you not realise that Malala is talking about people like you? This is not a "political gain" tool but an issue that people feel strongly about. What, should we ignore Sparrow because elections are around the corner?

Its been more than 20 years now. Move on FFS.

Aaai, jirre....some just and will never get it....

Those two deserve one another. It seems racist remarks and "get over it" statements are more important than actually focusing on getting rid of the no.1 problem at hand. :erm:
 
Nobody's lost. The sparrow chick and her ilk helped people across all races to bring things to the table, take it out in the open and unite again against racism. Sure there will always be bigots and the law needs to "provide" for them accordingly.

She lost her job I think? :whistle: :twisted:
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X