Petition against Eskom

I don't know how true this is, I got it from the comments section on Times Live.

HamburgerDave said:

"Did you know that E-on a German power company offered to build the most modern green coal power station in the world in SA, the condition would be that they run it. The state turned them down. The technology would be ground breaking and all this would not cost SA a cent to build. But Eskom does not want any competition. "

This is nonsense.... it's not even remotely true. Also, a coal station for SA costs in the region of R150 billion.... now who would give away that amound of money? Seriously.....
 
guys, i think we all know what happened in chernobly, and there were russians!

no offense to us, but im sure were less qualified then them
 
guys, i think we all know what happened in chernobly, and there were russians!

no offense to us, but im sure were less qualified then them

Most modern reactors will not blow up the same way as chernobyl did, they usually slow down when they get hotter unlike the chernobyl type also they dont use flammable material as control rods.
 
This is nonsense.... it's not even remotely true. Also, a coal station for SA costs in the region of R150 billion.... now who would give away that amound of money? Seriously.....

Of course you're basing this on fact? Do you understand the potential profits such an enterprise would bring for any investor?
 
The problem with current alternate energy sources is that they're horrifically expensive and extremely inneficient. You can generate power from wind & solar sources, but you pay astronomically high premiums to do so. The technology will mature, and it will become a viable alternative to fossil fuel stations, but that's not going to happen soon, and in the interim they're too expensive for a developing nation to invest in without severely damaging growth & development. Nuclear power really is the way to go right now if you want clean, cost effective energy, but the initial investment in terms of cost and time for building the station makes them less than ideal for us right now.

I've noticed nobody seems to mention hydro-electric power though? I would have thought that would have to be the wet dream in terms of clean power generation and infrastructure footprint. I understand we don't have all that many rivers suitable for HEP stations, but surely there's scope for more than we have already.
 
The problem with current alternate energy sources is that they're horrifically expensive and extremely inneficient. You can generate power from wind & solar sources, but you pay astronomically high premiums to do so. The technology will mature, and it will become a viable alternative to fossil fuel stations, but that's not going to happen soon, and in the interim they're too expensive for a developing nation to invest in without severely damaging growth & development. Nuclear power really is the way to go right now if you want clean, cost effective energy, but the initial investment in terms of cost and time for building the station makes them less than ideal for us right now.

I've noticed nobody seems to mention hydro-electric power though? I would have thought that would have to be the wet dream in terms of clean power generation and infrastructure footprint. I understand we don't have all that many rivers suitable for HEP stations, but surely there's scope for more than we have already.

Not really, there's very few rivers in our country that can be used for hydro electric stations. The best we can go for is pumped storage stations to help deal with peaking. There's a pipedream of building a hydroelectric station on the Congo river that would be able to supply 20-30 GW (I think that's about 1/3 of Africa's current demand) reliably, but the political climate in the region is still way too unstable for that to become a reality.
 
Problem is hydro electric power stations affect the ecosystem and environment of that river
 
I agree, nothing else than a bunch of signatures on a document that goes nowhere...
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X