PS3 Exclusives are Graphical Beasts!

I am Penguin said:
See text added. ;)
Click to expand...

So you're saying that the developers are wrong?

I am Penguin said:
NG2 is a multiplat then go see the picts above.
Click to expand...

I'm not into these comparison things at all. But if you get off because a game looks better on your console, than on another, then good for you.

What I don't get is, why do you all say that multi platform comparisons are crap, but when a PS3 game finally looks better than a 360 game, then it's ok to compare?
 
I am Penguin said:
Sure I agree fully, but funny on PS's everyone wants the best GPU and Graphics but with consoles they are claiming that the WII/PS2 graphics is fine even in todays age. :confused:

I like to look at the fine details and master pieces (ART) produced by the devs? Else NFS could have plastic Tommy cars for all I care then otherwise. :(
Click to expand...

I agree with you there, I wouldn't mind playing games on the Wii with it's old GFX, but I would much rather look at the PS3's graphics. It does draw you in more, and sometimes I do stop and go OMG.

And yes, the NG2 GFX looks better on the PS3 than on the Xbox 360, judging by those pics.
 
I am Penguin said:
YEP! Demo just released on Japan Playstation store.
Click to expand...

Heheeh, might as well throw away that comparison then

NG2 on the 360 was released how many years ago?

Obviously (I've stated this to Solidus as well) the PS3 version will be better
 
I am Penguin said:
The developers do what they can but we all know one group/programmer is not as innovative as another. The PS3 is prove of that. The main reason the Xbox multiplats always looked better tham the PS3 was because the Xbox was/is the lead/base platform to develop on for the game. Now that the Devs get to grips with the advanced PS3 tech we see the results as each new ly released game try the dethrone the previous "leader"
Click to expand...

Got any other multiplat examples apart from NG2 (as I stated above)?

I am Penguin said:
Why? You mean the Xbox360 GPU have improved by now? What happened to the "PS3" is the underdog concerning Graphics capability? So you agree then it was a massive underestimation by the PS3 usual bashers. :D
Click to expand...

No, the NG devs have had more time to work on the PS3 version, thus it will be better... you could fairly compare it if Sigma 2 was released on the PS3 the same time NG2 was on the 360
 
Last edited:
Retro said:
Ah ok, I get it. You're happy that the PS3 reached it maximum capibility. :)
Click to expand...

Sure am, especially since Gears 2 also maxed out the 360, and that was, what, already a year ago? ;)

Retro said:
Purposely scoring PS3 games less because of 360 fanboys, that sounds very anti-PS3 to me?.
Click to expand...

Well, to you it would, wouldn't it? You're the king of conclusion-jumping!

Retro said:
Apparently it's not logical for you? I don't know how to explain myself anymore, you seem to be stuck at the multiplat thing and can't get over it? I have multiplatform games and I have exclusive games. I don't care which they are when I buy them. Honestly, I couldn't even really tell you which are exlusives and which aren't. It just doesn't matter to me, if a game is good, then it's good, doesn't matter which console it was originally made for.

Once again, no. As a gamer I chose the console which had the most good games available on it.
Click to expand...


You said:

So this is basically all the great games on each console, that you either don't get on the other, or that doesn't score as good on the other console.
Click to expand...
What this means is you're discounting games that are essentially the same from your list, which in turn means that you're discounting what is exactly the same gameplay experience on reviewer % aggregates, which makes no sense at all, which means you're spinning pseudo stats to prove a point (still don't know what that point is)
 
I am Penguin said:
Well lets see in future bud. There is many more to come sooner than you think.

Anything will now do as excuse for Xbox fanbois, makes me laugh really. Funny things they suddenly come up with. Strange that so many are so QUITE now!
Click to expand...

lol @ the 360 fanboi excuse

Think of it as the 360 getting NG2 v1.0, the PS3 is getting NG2 v2.0

Which would you buy? If i didn't already have NG2, I'd buy the ps3 version, since its had more dev time
 
Oculate said:
lol @ the 360 fanboi excuse

Think of it as the 360 getting NG2 v1.0, the PS3 is getting NG2 v2.0

Which would you buy? If i didn't already have NG2, I'd buy the ps3 version, since its had more dev time
Click to expand...

Why people still insist on these comparisons is beyond me, honestly.
 
Kerrrang! said:
Sure am, especially since Gears 2 also maxed out the 360, and that was, what, already a year ago? ;)
Click to expand...

Links please? I'm sure you won't just be making a statement like that unless you had proof?

Well, to you it would, wouldn't it? You're the king of conclusion-jumping!
Click to expand...

No, please explain it to me, seriously. You're saying most sites score PS3 games less because of 360 fanboys? Really, if that doesn't sound anti-PS3, I don't know what does.

What this means is you're discounting games that are essentially the same from your list, which in turn means that you're discounting what is exactly the same gameplay experience on reviewer % aggregates, which makes no sense at all, which means you're spinning pseudo stats to prove a point (still don't know what that point is)
Click to expand...

*sigh* I wanted to know which console had the most games scoring more than 90%. I took out the duplicates in the same category on both, just to get a shorter list. I could leave the duplicates in if you want and show the list again. Percentage wise it's still going to be EXACTLY the same though, since all those would be on both sides, so I'm still not sure how I'm spinning the stats?

If you can give me another way of seeing which console has the most games above a certain percentage, I'll gladly try it?
 
Retro said:
Links please? I'm sure you won't just be making a statement like that unless you had proof?



No, please explain it to me, seriously. You're saying most sites score PS3 games less because of 360 fanboys? Really, if that doesn't sound anti-PS3, I don't know what does.


*sigh* I wanted to know which console had the most games scoring more than 90%. I took out the duplicates in the same category on both, just to get a shorter list. I could leave the duplicates in if you want and show the list again. Percentage wise it's still going to be EXACTLY the same though, since all those would be on both sides, so I'm still not sure how I'm spinning the stats?

If you can give me another way of seeing which console has the most games above a certain percentage, I'll gladly try it?
Click to expand...

Already posted those links couple of pages back...And yes, i trust an actual analyst's view more than Retro's.:eek:

I don't see the point in googling again for the Gears 2 link - you don't care about exclusives...
 
I am Penguin said:
Not quiet. Just read my lips "THE Devs are only NOW getting to grips with the power of the cell structure" Thus the PS3 games/graphics are improving and the Xbox? Well they reduce resolution to get some extra vuma! Nice win win situation not. Yeah I am starting to love my PS3, never doubted its capability ever, seems to me I was vindicated.
Click to expand...

So it's possible for PS3 devs to do more on the PS3 now, than what they could a year ago (same happens on PS1, PS2, Xbox, Saturn, Dreamcast etc.), but it's not for the Xbox devs?
 
Kerrrang! said:
Already posted those links couple of pages back...And yes, i trust an actual analyst's view more than Retro's.:eek:

I don't see the point in googling again for the Gears 2 link - you don't care about exclusives...
Click to expand...

lol, great thing about forums, people making statements like that and then "don't see the point" in finding the source. ;)

Still waiting on a "non stat-spinning" way to get reviews results between different consoles. Or don't you see the point in that either? ;)
 
Retro said:
lol, great thing about forums, people making statements like that and then "don't see the point" in finding the source. ;)

Still waiting on a "non stat-spinning" way to get reviews results between different consoles. Or don't you see the point in that either? ;)
Click to expand...

Yes, i don't. You're a gamer, who doesn't care about exclusives. And you can't seem to make heads or tails why games that perform less well than others would score less.

So yes, i don't see the point, and obviously, neither do you...
 
Kerrrang! said:
Yes, i don't. You're a gamer, who doesn't care about exclusives. And you can't seem to make heads or tails why games that perform less well than others would score less.

So yes, i don't see the point, and obviously, neither do you...
Click to expand...

Once again I don't see why you're mentioning exclusives? You claimed that the Xbox reached it's maximum capability with GOW. I'm just asking where you got that info from?
 
Retro said:
Once again I don't see why you're mentioning exclusives? You claimed that the Xbox reached it's maximum capability with GOW. I'm just asking where you got that info from?
Click to expand...

I didn't claim the 360 was maxed out, it was the EA Games VP.

And i still don't know why it's so important to you?
1st of all, you don't care about exclusives.
2nd of all, if a console has utilised 100% of it's resources to make a game, is that a bad thing? As i've said earlier, if every game can look as good as UC2, you can color me impressed.
 
Kerrrang! said:
I didn't claim the 360 was maxed out, it was the EA Games VP.

And i still don't know why it's so important to you?
1st of all, you don't care about exclusives.
2nd of all, if a console has utilised 100% of it's resources to make a game, is that a bad thing? As i've said earlier, if every game can look as good as UC2, you can color me impressed.
Click to expand...

It's important to me cause if it's true, I'll probably think about buying a PS3 ;) Cause I just can't believe that. I also hate it if people make statements like that without proof, because it normally turns out they're lying.

And for $%#@ sake, will you stop with the exclusives / multiplat thing? I'm not asking because it's an exclusive, I'm asking cause I think you're talking k@k and giving you an opportunity to prove me wrong.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X