Test your Computer Security

PeterCH

Honorary Master
Joined
Aug 8, 2005
Messages
18,371
Reaction score
3
Location
Cape Town
TestMyPCSecurity hosts a number of utilites which can be used to test
your Firewall and Host Intrusion Prevention System (HIPS).

http://www.testmypcsecurity.com/

A great one to start off with is the Comodo Firewall Test Suite,
which includes 34 exploits, including a Rootkit installation:
For both WinXP and Vista:
http://www.testmypcsecurity.com/securitytests/firewall_test_suite.html

Both Comodo and Avast report that the downloaded zip for all tests contains the win32 virus.
 
Both Comodo and Avast report that the downloaded zip for all tests contains the win32 virus.

The files are actually hosted on comodo.com,
I think one of the tests ?falsely reports a virus, the others are fine.

TrojanSimulator is reported as a virus. The others are not, that is not the dozen or so I ran, definately not this one:
http://www.testmypcsecurity.com/securitytests/firewall_test_suite.html

that is:
http://eu1.download.comodo.com/securitytests/CLT.zip

Here's the rundown:
http://www.virustotal.com/analisis/360f53944e01a5ff444bd6b9a1dac6be
 
Last edited:
Here's Comodo's Press Release about the site:
http://www.comodo.com/news/press_releases/09_04_08.html

"TESTMYPCSECURITY.COM" REPRESENTS A NEW MODEL IN DESKTOP SECURITY - BETTER SECURITY THROUGH A COMMUNITY BASED AND INDEPENDENT TESTING SITE
Testmypcsecurity.com has become a respected "Virtual Security Community Watch Group" that is reflective of a diverse set of testers who better represent real world environments

Jersey City, NJ (April 09, 2008) - Comodo, a leading security company, announced today that the recent launch of Testmypcsecurity.com has ignited a new model in security that is, in effect, acting as a "Virtual Security Community Watch Group", helping community members with issues and questions about computer security. Importantly this site, which will house one of the largest collections of computer security tests, provides an independent presentation of test results from a diverse set of community testers. Its credibility is driven by the fact that all information is gathered and created by the users, for the users and does not promote any specific commercial interest whatsoever. Comodo provides the infrastructure for the site but in no way affects the information represented.

Testmypcsecurity.com was launched as a new website to address an emerging concern in the security industry - the lack of an independent testing resource that gathers all of the tests and testers needed to objectively assess the effectiveness of PC security solutions. Existing testing sites provide a limited number of tests with information that is often dated and reflective a very limited set of testers. The appeal of Testmypcsecurity.com is that it provides a broad array of computer security tests, including firewall leak and Host Intrusion Prevention System (HIPS) tests that all community members can use for testing purposes. The tests were created as a safe way for users of all abilities to determine the effectiveness of their security software at preventing viruses from damaging a computer system. This approach permits a broader set of testers that can post their results for all community members to see and is likely to be more representative of the "real world". Further, results are posted almost immediately and are more current than many other testing sites that delay posting results for weeks or even months at a time. The site been highly successful at attracting a wide variety of testers and the site actively encourages site visitors to join the community as testers.

Testmypcsecurity.com was designed to be both a testing and education resource for users and includes:

* Detailed and technical explanations about firewall leak tests and HIPS testing,
* Downloads of individual and batch security individual tests,
* Information on other people's test results and comments, and
* The ability to become part of the Test My PC Security testing community.

"Testmypcsecurity.com creates a new type of community - a virtual community of like minded people concerned with creating better desktop security for all." said Melih Abdulhayoglu, CEO and Chief Security Architect of Comodo. "The power of a community to test security software and help other community members stay safe represents the new way forward in online security. This type of community can only operate effectively if the environment is independent of commercial interests. That's what we created with Testmypcsecurity.com and it's why the site has exceeded our expectations in terms of impact and influence within the security industry."

For more information, please visit: www.testmypcsecurity.com
About Comodo

The Comodo companies provide the infrastructure that is essential in enabling e-merchants, other Internet-connected companies, software companies, and individual consumers to interact and conduct business via the Internet safely and securely. The Comodo companies offer PKI SSL, Code Signing, Content Verification and E-Mail Certificates; award winning PC security software; vulnerability scanning services for PCI Compliance; secure e-mail and fax services.

Continual innovation, a core competence in PKI, and a commitment to reversing the growth of Internet-crime distinguish the Comodo companies as vital players in the Internet's ongoing development. Comodo secures and authenticates online transactions and communications for over 200,000 business customers and 3,000,000 users of our desktop security products.

For additional information on Comodo - Creating Trust Online™ visit http://www.comodo.com

For more information, reporters and analysts may contact:
Judy Shapiro
Comodo
+1 (201) 963-9471
Email: [email protected]
 
I think these things (no offence) are just another scheme to get you to buy useless software.

Except the HIPS/Firewall which seems to do best at these tests is offered completely FREE of charge. But I do get you. The site is paid for by Comodo,
makers of Comodo Firewall Pro and other products. CFP actually happens to be totally free without any spam or ads.

http://www.testmypcsecurity.com/view_results_xp.html
 
Comodo Firewall Pro (includes a HIPS) is free, so you only need a good AV package (AVAST) and Comodo FP to protect your system.
Comodo also has an AV solution but it's not as good as the others. Their Firewall is top rated along with Outpost and Online Armor.
 
I scored 10/340 o.0

/me shoots avast

LOL, I got double your score!

Seriously though, it makes you think - perhaps its time to get rid of SAV and sygate?? I was hoping to at least get 50% :(

Just downloaded the Full_tests and it looks like it could come in handy. Thanks PeterCH :)
 
Last edited:
I scored 200/340 no active av running

added another firewall rule and got 210/340

I run Comodo and BitDefender AV 2008 on my main home WinTel machine.
It scores 340/340. Actually the AV does not pick up any of the malware action attempts,
only the CPF.

The main thing is to have a HIPS running. That tells you if a program wants to shut down your AV scanner or Firewall.

This is one of the other Firewall testers, this time from Atelier.
Here the HIPS and the AV both picked up the attempt and reacted, well
BD just deleted the file while CPF is asking for a response - Allow, Block
or treat application as (eg Web browser).
http://mybroadband.co.za/photos/showphoto.php?photo=9996
 
I run Comodo and BitDefender AV 2008 on my main home WinTel machine.
It scores 340/340. Actually the AV does not pick up any of the malware action attempts,
only the CPF.

The main thing is to have a HIPS running. That tells you if a program wants to shut down your AV scanner or Firewall.

This is one of the other Firewall testers, this time from Atelier.
Here the HIPS and the AV both picked up the attempt and reacted, well
BD just deleted the file while CPF is asking for a response - Allow, Block
or treat application as (eg Web browser).
http://mybroadband.co.za/photos/showphoto.php?photo=9996

Funny, I run Bit Defender and got 40
 
Funny, I run Bit Defender and got 40

Bitdefender doesn't stop these tests. It did stop one of the other tests,
see post.
Comodo Firewall Pro recognised all of the attempts in this test and if you
click Block each time you'd have passed the test 100%.
 
The grand daddy of online security tests is Shields Up on http://www.grc.com/default.htm

Is is still good?

If your ISP uses a NAS server the ShieldsUP test may show that you're stealthed while you're not. The difference between that and the tests here is that these are leak tests as well as tests which attempt to use rootkits or
other tricks to connect to the internet from inside your system to the outside internet. So, if you do run a trojan horse program by mistake (and the AV misses it) then your FireWall should alert you that it's attempting to connect to the web - even via way of your browser. A less smart FW may allow the connection because the trojan may hijack your browser to connect - a more clued up FireWall/HIPS program will warn you eg
"PamelaAndersonSexyPicturesAlbum.exe is attempting to modify the memory of Firefox.exe"
and you have the option to block and disable the naughty program. These tests mimic trojan horses and other malware which may fool your ordinary firewall to connect to the web by hijacking approved processes eg IE, OE, FF, WindowsUpdate etc.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X