THE TOP GEAR TWIN TEST: HONDA E VS FIAT 500
We know they both look great, but can Fiat’s new electric 500 outdrive a Top Gear electric car favourite, the Honda e?
It’s also a shame that Fiat has only included three drive modes. You’ll want to avoid Sherpa – that switches off everything you don’t need and limits power – which means in everyday driving you’re left with Normal mode, which allows the car to completely coast and only deploys regenerative braking with the first stage of pedal travel, or Range mode, which switches to full one-pedal driving and max regen. With most customers likely to have come from a combustion-engined car, it might have been wise to feature a compromise between the two, or to let the driver adjust the regen with wheel-mounted paddles. Fiat has put additional volume and skip controls behind the wheel instead. Perhaps that’s a hint at buyer priorities...
Beware Fiat 500 prejudice, though. As alluded to earlier on, the all-electric 500 is leaps and bounds better than its combustion-engined counterpart and will make a fantastic polar bear-friendly city car for many. In fact, with that real world 150-mile range it could even serve as an only car if you rarely frequent Britain’s motorway network. The same can’t be said for the Honda, but it wins this test thanks to superior quality and more satisfying driving manners. It’s also the one you want to be in, the one you want to be seen in and the one you really want to own. It’s the ideal second car.
Honda e Advance – 8/10
£29,160 otr/£29,710 as tested
e-motor, 36kWh battery, RWD, 152bhp, 232lb ft
0-62mph in 8.0secs, 100mph
137 miles claimed range/100 miles as tested
1555kg
Fiat 500 Icon – 7/10
£27,995 otr/£30,132 as tested
e-motor, 42kWh battery, FWD, 117bhp, 162lb ft
0-62mph in 9.0secs, 93mph
199 miles claimed range/150 miles as tested
1465kg
www.topgear.com






