The Rugby thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Caught the highlights of the Bulls / Lions Currie Cup match. While the way it ended was bizarre, my takeaway from it was the ref constantly dipping into his pocket to reach for his yellow card. Were they all justified or was the ref just being power hungry?
Didn't see the game but in general I think we've got way too many yellow cards happening. I actually think we've got way too much VAR going on in rugby - we're looking for reasons to stop the game, get people sent off and my personal view is, I'd rather a wrong decision (yes even if it's against my team) but a more flowing game than what's going on now.
What I'd do - in touch for a try, sure, check that.
Grounding - nope, ref, you make the call.
Forward pass - nope, ref, you make the call.
High tackles - nope, ref, you make the call as you see it. This slowing it down to see if a shoulder possibly touched a head, dunno, again seems like we look for a reason to send someone off.
Or let the refs do their job, no going back 5 phases to spot a small knock on, give each captain 2 challenges for everything. I mean what % of tries are awarded immediately, and what % are first checked to see if anything happened first?

For contact sports, going down a man, football, NFL, basketball, league, nowhere else is it as common as in rugby. Maybe ice hockey. Football a red card is not common, league the tackles seem way more hardcore than rugby, they seem far more tolerant to potential high tackles, yet I hardly see folk being sent off. Sure then people will simply give away penalties but all these other sports have found ways to overcome this, sure we can too.
Anyway, that's my mini rant.
 
Didn't see the game but in general I think we've got way too many yellow cards happening. I actually think we've got way too much VAR going on in rugby - we're looking for reasons to stop the game, get people sent off and my personal view is, I'd rather a wrong decision (yes even if it's against my team) but a more flowing game than what's going on now.
What I'd do - in touch for a try, sure, check that.
Grounding - nope, ref, you make the call.
Forward pass - nope, ref, you make the call.
High tackles - nope, ref, you make the call as you see it. This slowing it down to see if a shoulder possibly touched a head, dunno, again seems like we look for a reason to send someone off.
Or let the refs do their job, no going back 5 phases to spot a small knock on, give each captain 2 challenges for everything. I mean what % of tries are awarded immediately, and what % are first checked to see if anything happened first?

For contact sports, going down a man, football, NFL, basketball, league, nowhere else is it as common as in rugby. Maybe ice hockey. Football a red card is not common, league the tackles seem way more hardcore than rugby, they seem far more tolerant to potential high tackles, yet I hardly see folk being sent off. Sure then people will simply give away penalties but all these other sports have found ways to overcome this, sure we can too.
Anyway, that's my mini rant.
... Or perhaps go with a system similar to cricket where a captain is allowed a predefined number of challenges per game and then the ref just calls everything else.
 
Yeah The Sharks one is concerning me a lot. :oops:

I hope the Womans 7s do some magic but they are against a strong Aussie 7s side....
With the Sharks it depends what team pitches up. Nothing less than a top notch 80 minute performance will do. We seldom get that from the Sharks.

The Women's 7's side are going to get hidings of note! Great experience for them though. Let's see how they go... they super green in 7's... (green and gold)...
 
Woman 7s look like they have no idea what is going on... o_O
 
Embarrassing performance. They are not even keen to tackle or chase down Australia line breaks...
 
Embarrassing performance. They are not even keen to tackle or chase down Australia line breaks...
Dude, the Aussie women are in a class of their own. Hiding to be expected... you can't tackle what you can't catch...
 
The cultural episodes that precede every game played in Australia are tedious AF but today's was quite entertaining....:laugh:
 
... Or perhaps go with a system similar to cricket where a captain is allowed a predefined number of challenges per game and then the ref just calls everything else.
Agreed:

Or let the refs do their job, no going back 5 phases to spot a small knock on, give each captain 2 challenges for everything. I mean what % of tries are awarded immediately, and what % are first checked to see if anything happened first?
 
Mens 7s starting brilliantly wow.

Good job Blitzbokke.

You are so bad. :mad:
 
Now that's embarrassing....

After USA shut down our winning streak we went downhill fast and now each 7s team we play against is difficult.

How can they suddenly be so bad?
 
After USA shut down our winning streak we went downhill fast and now each 7s team we play against is difficult.

How can they suddenly be so bad?
Injuries to key personnel. Also Neil Powell is taking over as defense coach at the Sharks. His head is no longer in the 7's game. Very disappointing....
 
@Sepeng @vatie

They tried the captain's challenge in NZ and Aus. It failed dismally and was widely unpopular. WR decided to discard that trial as a failure.
 
Lol the Blitzbokke looks so bad I'm embarrassed man. Wtf
 
So we went from being the best to the worst in 1 weekend.

Wow
 
In the Bulls / Osprey's game, in the 77th Min the Ospreys scored a try. the Bulls no 9 took the ball over the line and appeared to ground it in the in goal area - anyone knows why the ref gave the try instead?
 
In the Bulls / Osprey's game, in the 77th Min the Ospreys scored a try. the Bulls no 9 took the ball over the line and appeared to ground it in the in goal area - anyone knows why the ref gave the try instead?

I was looking at that and wondering myself.

We kept on looking whether Ospreys was offside which he clearly was. There is no way he could have seen the ball over the line from an on side position.

Secondly exactly as you mention the Bulls 9 had his hands on the ball the whole time which at the very least would have made it a carried back 5m scrum instead they said no it's a try.
 
Blitzbokke lost against Scotland in the 9th place semi final.

I think we have reached rock bottom again. Wow
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X