Xarog
Honorary Master
- Joined
- Feb 13, 2006
- Messages
- 19,039
Where have you considered the possibility that they are false? It's precisely because you don't consider that a possibility and present your opinion as based in "fact" that I'm criticising your posts. You, for whatever reason, have ruled out this possibility without reasonable justification. And frankly because you are not capable of doing independent verification of the American assertions, your choosing to believe in their veracity can be nothing but taking their assertions to be true at face value.Exactly, if i took American statements at face value i wouldn't consider the possibility of them being false.
http://www.dictionary.com/browse/face-value?s=t
I don't know who can have advanced knowledge of what lies inside every building in the middle of a civil war.I dont find this to be an acceptable excuse, you should know what you're bombing otherwise its just indiscriminate bombing.
So sounds very much like there were militants in multiple buildings. I can't think of a single armed force in the world that would disengage in a combat situation just because the people that are shooting at them and they are shooting at just ran into another building...Grantza said:A U.S. military official told CNN that U.S. forces were not operating in the area of the hospital, and their closest strike had been 20 kilometers (12.4 miles) to the north.
Marco, with Doctors Without Borders, told CNN that two barrel bombs hit buildings near the hospital. The injured were rushed to the hospital and relatives hurried there. A third barrel bomb landed at the facility's gate, causing many of the casualties, he said.
And as an aside, I wonder what the date of that US strike 20 kilometers away was.
While you have a point, that doesn't have any bearing on whether or not whoever pulled the trigger could know they were bombing a hospital.And when Syrian government officials react like this to the bombing of an MSF hospital
http://www.al-monitor.com/pulse/sit...016/02/syria-conflict-russia-msf-france.html#
It becomes abundantly clear that providing their location will only make things worse for them.