Tongaat Mall Building Collapse and Inquiry

Heads are gonna roll. Which contractor / construction company is responsible for the building of the roof?

Hope the rest come out alive! :(

If they had insurance, the forensics will be all over this regardless. Protocol requires they determine the cause of the loss. It will come out the wash. With fatalities and injuries come the local authorities looking to see if their was negligence involved.
 
I heard that the owner has been pushing to get the mall up and at least partially ready for the december rush, as he owns the spar and obviously does not want to miss the huge december sales. Cant blame him for wanting to recover some of the investment, but surely he understands that should the building collapse due to shoddy workmanship, he or his family may be inside. Hopefully this will be a wakeup call and he will make sure the building is up to par.
 
Construction should have stopped: eThekwini

Construction at a shopping mall in Tongaat, north of Durban, where a roof collapsed on Tuesday killing at least one person and injuring 29 others, should not have been taking place, eThekwini deputy mayor Nomvuzo Shabalala said.

"We took them [the contractors] to court a month ago. We thought they had stopped," she told reporters on the scene.

The reason the municipality took the contractors to court was because "they hadn't followed processes".

Netcare 911 spokesman Chris Botha said a concrete slab the size of a soccer field collapsed at the mall.

He said 50 people were feared trapped under the rubble.

Lieutenant Mandy Govender said one person died and 26 people were injured when the roof collapsed on Tuesday.

"Almost the entire area of the construction site in the mall is down," she said.

"We are still combing the area with sniffer dogs searching for survivors. All the workers are not accounted for at this stage. Emergency services are on the scene as we speak."

Botha said earlier that roads surrounding the construction site had been closed.

A Sapa reporter on the scene said hundreds of onlookers were standing at the edge of the cordoned off construction site.

Trains passing the mall had to slow right down as people were cleared from the railway line that borders the mall.

Fiona Moonean, whose house is located directly across the railway from the collapsed level of the mall said she was washing dishes at the time of the incident.

She said that a few days earlier, workers had started removing the scaffolding supporting the level.


"Just after 4.30pm it was a thunderous sound. Before the bang, I heard too much scaffolding fall. That's when I picked my eyes up [and looked through her window at the mall]. The whole concrete slab crashed down with the pillars. The smoke and dust was too thick. I heard them screaming out for help in Zulu."

She called the emergency services and a woman took down her details.

"She had to calm me down because I was so freaked out. For me, the most traumatic is the sound of the guys' voices. That is the part that plays in my head," she said.

- Sapa
 
Never knew tongaat had any shopping malls, which one are we talking about here if you could pin it on google maps?

At the end of the day someone still made a profit! Yeah I know it's sick but it's probably true!
 
Never knew tongaat had any shopping malls, which one are we talking about here if you could pin it on google maps?

At the end of the day someone still made a profit! Yeah I know it's sick but it's probably true!

The mall was due to open next year April, I believe. It's right at the beginning of Tongaat.
 
The mall was due to open next year April, I believe. It's right at the beginning of Tongaat.

Wtf is the beginning of tongaat, maidstone side, westbrook side or verlulam side?
 
Workers sift through rubble

Rescue workers were sifting through the rubble at the shopping mall in Tongaat, north of Durban, on Tuesday night after one person died and 29 were injured -- two of them critically -- when a concrete slab collapsed.

It was initially reported that 50 more people were feared trapped, but the site foreman told rescue workers they may have already left for home, as the slab caved in while they were knocking off.

Sniffer dogs were combing the scene for survivors late on Tuesday night.

Spotlights were lighting the area, which was described by Netcare 911 spokesman Chris Botha as being around the size of a soccer field.

Paramedic Neil Powell told the French news agency Agence France-Presse (AFP) that most of the injured had broken bones and crush injuries.

"Some are in severe condition, others are mild," he was quoted as saying.

Heat-seeking equipment had detected three "hot spots" where other survivors could be located, AFP reported.

Fibre-optic cables were being fed into the area to determine if anyone else was alive.

KwaZulu-Natal premier Senzo Mchunu expressed his shock at the accident.

"We express our condolences to the family of the person who died in this horrific accident," he said in a statement.

"We also wish those who were injured prompt recovery."

He said he was liaising with health MEC Sbongiseni Dhlomo to ensure the injured received quality healthcare at public health facilities.

"Importantly, I am confident that all the relevant departments such as the department of labour and eThekwini municipality will help speed up an investigation into the causes of this accident," Mchunu said.

Earlier, eThekwini deputy mayor Nomvuzo Shabalala said construction at the mall should not have been taking place.

"We took them [the contractors] to court a month ago. We thought they had stopped," she said.

It had approached the court because the contractors had not "followed processes".

Fiona Moonean said she was washing dishes when the slab collapsed, directly over the railway line from her home.

A few days earlier, workers had started removing the scaffolding supporting the level, she said.

"Just after 4.30pm it was a thunderous sound. Before the bang, I heard too much scaffolding fall. That's when I picked my eyes up [and looked through her window at the mall].

"The whole concrete slab crashed down with the pillars. The smoke and dust was too thick. I heard them screaming out for help in Zulu."

She called the emergency services and a woman took down her details.

"She had to calm me down because I was so freaked out. For me, the most traumatic is the sound of the guys' voices. That is the part that plays in my head," she said.

Lieutenant Mandy Govender said earlier on Tuesday evening that almost the entire area of the construction site in the mall was down.

"We are still combing the area with sniffer dogs searching for survivors. All the workers are not accounted for at this stage. Emergency services are on the scene as we speak."


Source : Sapa /aw/js/cls
Date : 19 Nov 2013 22:40
 
This is terrible, not that the workers are bad enough but could you imagine a collapse at peak times.
Hope all the others are safe.
 
So also a lack of enforcement from the Metro side.

They did what was required of them. They can't be expected to police the area every single day. This isn't the fault of the municipality - seems they identified problems and did what they could to stop it, and were under the impression after the court proceedings that construction would halt. The contractors were breaking the law - the municipality can't be held accountable for that...
 
Rescue efforts continue at KZN Mall

Efforts to find any survivors in the wreckage of a collapsed mall in Tongaat, north of Durban, continued on Wednesday.

Sniffer dogs were repeatedly sent during the night over the football pitch sized portion that had collapsed on Tuesday afternoon.

Members of the police's search and rescue units conducted an audio test early on Wednesday morning, tapping and knocking at numerous places in the wreckage in the hope of hearing a reaction from trapped workers.

The test did not elicit any response.

When the disaster unfolded on Tuesday night initial reports were that as many as 50 people had been entrapped. Netcare 911 spokesman Chris Botha said that one person, a woman, had died and 29 people had been taken to hospital.

It was still unclear how many workers had been on the construction site and how many were unaccounted for. A train passing by in the early hours of the morning had commuters leaning out of windows and doors to see what was happening.

Many were using their cell phones to film or photograph the devastation.

"The Indians [who are] building this must be killed," was one of the shouts that could heard from the train as it passed.

Construction worker Skhumbuzo Ngcobo said that all he saw was dust when the slab collapsed.

"Next thing all of us were down on the floor with the scaffolding and everything. I hurt my hand, my back," he said from a hospital bed on Tuesday night.

He was three floors up on scaffolding setting up bricks for a bricklayer to use when a slab caved in. He heard one of his friends calling and he helped to pull him from the rubble onto the railway line.

They were not sure what else would collapse.

"The only thing I could see was concrete rubble and they were taking people from under the concrete. Most of them, I thought they were dead, because that place was finished," he said.

Ngcobo worked for a sub-contractor. He had been told that four people from his company, which he did not want to name, were still missing.

Asked what he thought had caused the accident, the 24-year old said construction on the mall had been going too fast to allow the concrete to set.

"That job, they doing it [too fast] and rushing it. They wanted to do a quick job [to] finish that thing. That's the thing I think went wrong."

He said that within two or three days of concrete being cast, scaffolding was being removed.

"I don't think that concrete was hard enough. They were building more walls on top of the slab, the top slab."

Earlier, eThekwini deputy mayor Nomvuzo Shabalala said construction at the mall should not have been taking place.

"We took them [the contractors] to court a month ago. We thought they had stopped," she said.

The municipality had approached the court because the contractors had not "followed processes".

Ethekwini Democratic Alliance councillor Brian Jaganathan said plans for the mall's construction started in 2010, when several people were forced to move from their homes to make way for the development.

"I found out that in 2010 no plans had been passed. In 2012 they started building and during the last month they were working at a high pace."

He questioned why the building had been allowed to continue despite the court order.

Lubabalo Ntanze, whose legs were injured, said he was laying bricks when the scaffolding underneath him gave way.

"I though I was going to be dying when that wall came down," he said, also from hospital.

Fiona Moonean said she was washing dishes when the slab collapsed, directly over the railway line from her home.

A few days earlier, workers had started removing the scaffolding supporting the level, she said.

"Just after 4.30pm it was a thunderous sound. Before the bang, I heard too much scaffolding fall. That's when I picked my eyes up [and looked through her window at the mall].

"The whole concrete slab crashed down with the pillars. The smoke and dust was too thick. I heard them screaming out for help in Zulu."


Source : Sapa /js/kn/aa
Date : 20 Nov 2013 06:25
 
Apparently the company is notorious for shoddy workmanship and corruption, but the city insisted on using them. The ANC used their majority in the council to extend their dealing with the company, too. :rolleyes:
 
So many articles and I have yet to read the actual name of the contractor or the developer :wtf:
 
https://twitter.com/barrybateman

TongaatMall apparently the construction company was Gralio Construction, also referred to as Gralio Precast, owned by Jay Singh.

Gralio was the subject of an investigation last year because eThekwini low-cost houses it built were falling apart.

Gralio owner Singh has been criminally convicted of bribing an eThekwini official in 2009 to overlook poor workmanship.

Gralio has been awarded government low-cost housing contrast worth tens of millions of rand.

this July 2012 report states Gralio/Singh continued to receive tenders because he’s an ANC benefactor http://t.co/ZOZ17cmTcA
 
It was still unclear how many workers had been on the construction site and how many were unaccounted for. A train passing by in the early hours of the morning had commuters leaning out of windows and doors to see what was happening.

Many were using their cell phones to film or photograph the devastation.

"The Indians [who are] building this must be killed," was one of the shouts that could heard from the train as it passed.

Great journalism. Throw in one remark to spice it up with some race hate....
 
Chickens. Home. Roost.

And it's big, ugly chickens too. Discovery and court process should be very interesting.
 
Labour department to handle mall site

The labour department has taken control of a collapsed mall construction site in Tongaat, north of Durban, KwaZulu-Natal health MEC Sibongiseni Dhlomo said on Wednesday.

He said heavy machinery would be brought in to remove rubble from the site following the collapse on Tuesday afternoon.

Emergency workers would remain on standby at the scene once the labour department's efforts started at the site.

Netcare 911 spokesman Chris Botha said the search and rescue operation had been called off so that the labour department could move some of the rubble with heavy machinery.

He said one woman was confirmed dead on the scene and 29 were hospitalised with various injuries.

Police spokeswoman Lieutenant Mandy Govender said three people were unaccounted for, but it was possible that more people were trapped in the debris.

Labour department spokesman Page Boikanyo said in a statement a delegation led by acting director-general Sam Morotoba would visit the scene on Wednesday.

The department's deputy director-general of inspection and enforcement services, Thobile Lamati, and Compensation Fund commissioner Shadrack Mkhonto would also visit the scene.

Earlier, eThekwini deputy mayor Nomvuzo Shabalala said construction at the mall should not have been taking place.

"We took them [the contractors] to court a month ago. We thought they had stopped," she said.

The municipality had approached the court because the contractors had not "followed processes".

African National Congress KwaZulu-Natal spokesman Senzo Mkhize said construction companies flouting building regulations should be blacklisted.

"The ANC is appalled that this tragedy happened barely a month after the eThekwini municipality had ordered the construction to stop," he said.

"Had the company complied, surely this disaster could have been averted."

He extended the party's condolences to the family of the woman who was killed and wished the injured a speedy recovery.

Mkhize also commended the emergency workers for their efforts.

Police cordoned off the site on Wednesday morning and small groups of people watched the operations from a distance.


Source : Sapa /js/mjs/jk/ar
Date : 20 Nov 2013 09:45
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X