Will Roman Polanski ever be extradited?

Yes the charge could be trumped up. With celebrities involved sometimes people come up with novel ways to get cash or do someone in. The girl was probably used as a pawn or it didn't happen at all, after all these years she may even genuinely believe it has happened too.

He plea bargained - in other words he was told by the DA: "We have a strong case. We'll send you away to St Quentin and you'll be butt-raped by Bubba and Co for 20 years. Or you can plead guilty and we'll give you a slap on the wrist. Save yourself the trouble."

Obviously people are emotional and will like you, go with the testimony of a girl who was seduced, drugged and raped by this guy who since has not been convicted in Europe of anything related to this. I guess he switched off his libido for 30 years. Right?

The case wasn't clear cut.

And even if he really had sex with this girl where was her mother and why did she let this happen - and yes it's possible for a drunk guy to mistake a girl who looks 18 but is 13 for a legal girl.

It's also been 30 years and the way he was caught by the Swiss is fishy and unkosher. Thugs frequently escape to the US from Europe and they don't get extradited - I believe Europe should not let him go till the US rescinds these crazy charges or he should be tried in Europe.

Anyway google it, lots of people believe in this guy and ask yourself why they do? People hate and call Gary Glitter bad names and people still refer to MJ as a pedo even though he bribed the parents of that one kid not to press charges, why should a far better man be treated like a criminal. I disagree.

Put yourself in his shoes. If you were at a party and some girl who should not have been there said you raped her, and everyone called you a f-ng child molester, do you think you'd get a fair hearing? Judging by most responses here - I seriously doubt it, and it goes against all psychology because the guy was successfully married to numerous beautiful women and pedo's don't do that, or if they do its a facade and they rape relatives and other kids. Secondly the girl does not look like a kid (and we have testimony on that) and so he did wrong not to verify her age but he's no child molester or animal. Cases like these - if this is genuine - are very common. At the end it's her word against his. And people won't defend someone accused of this because he must obviously be guilty.

If you know my record on this forum I usually back the girl in such cases but in this case the whole thing is very fishy. Anyway a real pedo child rapist wouldn't have two governments standing in on his behalf which goes to show what people in Europe think of those charges or do you think Sarkozy would defend a child molester in public?

But look at the facts though,
-Hes never denied having sex or drugging her
- He pleaded guilty
- He fled (which does nothing to help his credibilty)
- Ive googled pictures of her when she 13, she looks 13 imo.
- Hes settled with her financially.

Also celebrities are quite good at hiring the best lawyers to discredit many accusers, weve seen it dozens of times in hollywood already. Why do you believe he is innocent though?
 
But look at the facts though,
-Hes never denied having sex or drugging her

As said he plea bargained. He did not know she was a kid either.

- He pleaded guilty

Plea bargained, I explained already. You know the judge/DA tell you one thing - this sort of thing happens commonly - people often plead guilty because they're terrified of being sentenced - it's not uncommon and not just for sex crimes - watch some C&I channel and you'll see how the lawyers and cops strong arm people.

- He fled (which does nothing to help his credibilty)

Well he did not want to go to prison. The judge should have let him off as agreed - but changed his mind. At the end the justice system was just stubborn and quite possibly some people who did not like him pulled some strings.

- Ive googled pictures of her when she 13, she looks 13 imo.

It's difficult to tell. He should have checked her driver's license - but where was her mom? Secondly people who were there said she looked and behaved older.

- Hes settled with her financially.

Which was the whole aim of the escapade. The justice system however did not take kindly to him getting away from them.

Also celebrities are quite good at hiring the best lawyers to discredit many accusers, weve seen it dozens of times in hollywood already. Why do you believe he is innocent though?

I think, and there's been much written on this, that the guy even if he had sex with her did not know she was 13, and the thing was made big by people who had other motives or at least the situation was exacerbated. Secondly as said, if he was a child predator, he wouldn't have been able to help himself while in exile. I don't believe he is a child predator, I think he didn't know she was a kid. Maybe he's eccentric, maybe poor at judgment, but get any college student drunk (male one) and see how long before he starts groping girls - even younger ones - what age do kids start having sex these days - and yes while adults should not take advantage - mess with the guy and put alcohol in the mix and you have a situation which may lead to illegal and immoral things with the girl not running away at first sign of trouble but instead leading the guy on and if he doesn't think she's a kid, well a crime will be committed.

I don't think the guy's life should be ruined by this, he spent a lot of time in exile, did a lot of good and suffered a lot - his parents were killed by the Nazis, he had to pretend to be Catholic to survive and he lost his wife. A child molester wouldn't be marrying women like Sharon Tate either - or at least he wouldn't be satisfied by them.
 
Last edited:
I support Polanski, I think the original charge was trumped up, and in those pictures that girl was definately not a child in appearance. This also sounds like a trumped up fake charge to me.

BTW even if he raped a 13 year old he is not a pedophile. Pedophiles rape children under 13 - ie children and not adolescents. I highly doubt he had sex with anyone under 18 anyhow.
Support your countryfolk eh?

Look, he drugged and raped a 13yr old. I've seen the pictures. There's no way she could be mistaken for 16 or whatever the age of consent was at the time. Noone is above the law and his only saving grace is his age and the time passed.
 
-Hes never denied having sex or drugging her
He certainly never admitted to the latter.

Also celebrities are quite good at hiring the best lawyers to discredit many accusers
If you're rich you can afford to hire good lawyers. That's a flaw in the legal system.

- He pleaded guilty
He pled guilty to a lesser charge. That is invariably offered by the state when their case is weak and accepted by the accused when they're well aware that guilty or not the nature of the accusation will have the public baying for blood, and the prosecution will be obliged to do whatever is necessary to crucify them. And in fact even after he agreed to accept the lesser charge instead of fighting them there's reason to believe the prosecutor coached the sentencing judge in an attempt ensure he received a harsh sentence.
 
Polanski breaks silence on American extradition threat

yeah right - having sex with a 13 year old makes his trail unjustified ... what a douche bag !

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/entertainment/8657602.stm

Film director Roman Polanski has broken his silence to decry the US for seeking his extradition from Switzerland on a 33-year-old child sex case.

The Oscar-winner said prosecutors wanted him to return so they could serve him "on a platter to the media".

Polanski, who is under house arrest in his Swiss chalet, spoke out against extradition in an online magazine.

"I ask only to be treated fairly like anyone else," said the 76-year-old, who left the US in 1978, before sentencing.

Polanski made his 900-word statement in an online publication run by a prominent supporter, the French philosopher Bernard-Henri Levy.

He suggested the case being prepared against him by California prosecutors was unjust.

"I can no longer remain silent because the United States continues to demand my extradition, more to serve me on a platter to the media of the world than to pronounce a judgment concerning which an agreement was reached 33 years ago," he wrote.

Polanski has been under house arrest in Switzerland since September facing a US arrest warrant over his conviction for unlawful sex with a 13-year-old girl.
 
Ah shame. For 3 decades he's been living the good life without facing trial. So unfair no other child rapist has had it so bad.....

All this support he's been receiving for the Hollywood crowd really shows what a sick bunch of hypocrites they are. One minute eating caviar in multimillion dollar mansions socializing/working with scum like Polanski and the next posing for pics wide eyed malnourished African kids.

Selfless humanitarians indeed.
 
Thanx ponder.

Dude it depends on the 13 year old girl, not all 13 year old girls play with little dolls. Yes it is disgusting but i was just wondering if he raped her or just broke that underage law.
 
Thanx ponder.

Dude it depends on the 13 year old girl, not all 13 year old girls play with little dolls. Yes it is disgusting but i was just wondering if he raped her or just broke that underage law.

Some little girls have mothers who want them to become big stars and prod them along. The reality is that much of Hollywood (and elsewhere) runs like this too. To add more to the story the girl didn't even look 13 and if Polanski
was a genuine pedo he'd be hunting kids throughout his career - he had no further troubles. Pity about Sharon Tate though.
 
New Accuser Alleges Sexual Abuse by Roman Polanski

http://www.people.com/people/article/0,,20369437,00.html?xid=rss-fullcontent
http://www.imdb.com/news/ni2447029/

Four years after he fled the United States in 1978 after pleading guilty to unlawful sex with a minor, Roman Polanski "forced himself" on another woman, then 16, in his Paris apartment, the woman alleged Friday.

Charlotte Lewis of London, who appeared in Polanski's 1986 film Pirates, made the allegation in a press conference held at her attorney Gloria Allred's Los Angeles office. Allred described Polanski's alleged behavior as "sexually predatory conduct."

"[Polanski] sexually abused me in the worst possible way when I was just 16," said Lewis, who remained composed while reading a prepared statement. "He knew [how old I was] when he met me and forced himself upon me in his apartment in Paris. He took advantage of me and I have lived with the effects of his behavior ever since it occurred. I've traveled to the U.S. at my own expense to make sure that justice is finally done and that Mr. Polanski gets what he deserves. All I want is justice."

Lawyers for Polanski said in a statement: "We don't have any information about statements made at a Gloria Allred press conference today, but we do know that the District Attorney continues to refuse to provide the Swiss government with accurate and complete information relevant to the extradition issue."

Allred was vague as to what legal remedy her client was seeking, but said Lewis was willing to testify against him. Authorities in L.A. are seeking to extradite Polanski, 76, to the U.S. from Switzerland on decades-old charges he had sex with a 13-year-old girl.

Allred says she and Lewis have already met with an L.A. detective as well as a prosecutor.
 
Why didn't she file charges earlier? 1978? Paris?

Secondly, it's well known that most starlets sleep with their directors/producers. She slept her way to a career.

WTF dude

Don't you also defend those catholic priests by saying loads of other people do it?
 
WTF dude

Don't you also defend those catholic priests by saying loads of other people do it?

WTF dude. I won't even respond to people who make up lies about me. Go away.

1. I never defended child abusers. I defended the Church. You are saying I defended actual molesters. That is a lie. You have many anti-Catholic views. I don't have any views against YOU. You are already prejudiced and that's tatamount to bigotry.
2. A woman who slept her way to a career with a director and now 32 years later comes with stories YET SHE DID NOTHING about is very suspicious. Polanski lived in France. She could have gone to the French authorities. She didn't. Crime was committed in France anyway if a crime occurred, and that's the only place to report it. It does not fall under American jurisdiction.

Did that go over your head?

I will report your post because you are flaming me over my own expression of an opinion. I never attacked you. Your post has been reported.
 
Last edited:
She slept her way to a career.

Unless you have absolute proof to back up that statement, I suggest you STFU. Making slanderous remarks about a person who may have been abused is the lowest of low things to do, and I have reported your post as such.
As for the 32-year "silence" period - if it was abuse then it's understandable she'd want to keep quiet about it, for professional reasons as much as personal. If she made allegations (true or not) about a well-known and well-connected director like Polanski, it would have been quite possible for him to destroy her reputation in the industry and prevent her from ever getting another part.

Regarding the Catholic thing - the Church has defended/covered up for child molesters; by defending the Church you are indirectly doing the same. QED.
 
Pete all i did was ask if it was you defending the catholic priests, i did not attack you in anyway.

I also felt your comments are in very poor taste just as i found you standing up for catholic priests just as shocking.

You are more than welcome to report this post as well but i cannot see where i attacked you. She could have done many things but you forget she was 16, not everyone thinks clearly at 16, yes maybe she kept quiet for her career's sake but that does not make it right does it? People like this take advantage of these type's of situations. Not nice to see people supporting this type of thing.

I bet you think if a chick dresses sluttie (sexy to me) she deserves to get raped? Logic fail in my opinion. Again not an attack and report away dude.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X