#DataMustFall is back – and you’re all still wrong

@Kevin Lancaster, @staff writer, @rpm and whoever wrote the article - interesting and thanks for the info. Also, I get why you would clarify incorrect claims by the public, so kudos on that.

However, in your "About Us" section, you state teh following:
About Us
MyBroadband is the largest IT Website in South Africa with 1 million unique monthly visitors, serving the local market with technology and business tech news and the largest online community in the country.

When was MyBroadband founded?

MyBroadband was started in 2003 (known then as MyADSL) as a forum to address the broadband problems which existed in South Africa at the time. Since then the website grew into an IT News publication and online community, with 1.8 million unique visitors and 8 million page views per month.

Who are we?

MyBroadband has a small team of journalists and marketing staff who are passionate about ensuring that they serve the needs of the South African IT community.

As much as you need to balance views and keep things nice, your article comes off as defending the high prices of the service providers.

I would expect an organisation such as yours to be on the vanguard of forwarding broad-scale implementation of broadband services, fixed and mobile, within the country. You are in a prime position to be a huge proponent of affordable data and internet usage, with your media footprint, readership and advertising links, as well as your partners in the IT industry. Correcting reader misconceptions is all fine and dandy, but this article should include a sit-down with MTN asking the big questions and pushing for cheaper data.

The fact that we have these data prices, combined with horrendous customer service (as evidenced by the multitudinous threads regarding such) should warrant investigation by someone with journalistic tendencies - especially someone working for an IT and Broadband-related media establishment, who gets paid to do such.

I like this site and I like your articles, mostly, but journalism isn't about commenting on the day-to-day scenes of a locale. By your very own words your mission is "ensuring that they serve the needs of the South African IT community."

Our needs are simple:

  • Reliable internet connections that function as intended at an affordable cost
  • Decent customer service that results in minimal downtime
  • Future-proofing technologies and implementation that keep us on par and moving forward

I think we can all agree that the above is absent in out current IT scene. Why not investigate, push and question until we get answers or, dare I say it, results?
 
[QUOTE As much as you need to balance views and keep things nice, your article comes off as defending the high prices of the service providers.[/QUOTE]

Nope. That is not how I interpret the article. All they did is to respond with facts to the different allegations.
 
The facts are the facts, they are being good journalists (wishing they are more often) and just giving the facts.

Yup and that's why I gave them kudos. My point was more that they could be more proactive instead of posting commentary.
 
Fact:

Vodacom Mozambique: 2.5GB prepaid data valid 30 days -> 250MT (+-R54)
Vodacom South Africa: 2GB prepaid data valid 30days -> R249
 
Last edited:
Firstly, the comparison ignores Telkom, which offers 1GB data bundles for R99. It also ignores Afrihost and Crystal Web, which offer 1GB for R99 on MTN and Vodacom’s networks respectively.

Maybe look at the image a little closely - they're poking fun at Vodacom which is R149/gig prepaid. Nothing ignored. Vodacom is one of the bigger players and thus targeted.
 
[QUOTE As much as you need to balance views and keep things nice, your article comes off as defending the high prices of the service providers.

Nope. That is not how I interpret the article. All they did is to respond with facts to the different allegations.[/QUOTE]

You broke something....
 
Personally, I don't think data prices are that much higher than the rest of the world.

What makes data expensive (and here's the contradiction) is the way in which data is sold by the major players.

Data is sold in a fashion that deliberately confuses customers out of money. Bizarre promotions from MTN that expire at weird times. Data from Vodacom that expires after 30 days and not a month, or the end of the following calendar month.

And, of course, the big one. Exorbitant out of bundle rates.

Out of bundle should be opt in. Period.
 
Personally, I don't think data prices are that much higher than the rest of the world.

What makes data expensive (and here's the contradiction) is the way in which data is sold by the major players.

Data is sold in a fashion that deliberately confuses customers out of money. Bizarre promotions from MTN that expire at weird times. Data from Vodacom that expires after 30 days and not a month, or the end of the following calendar month.

And, of course, the big one. Exorbitant out of bundle rates.

Out of bundle should be opt in. Period.

Sounds like you'd be a happy Telkom prepaid customer...
 
Sounds like you'd be a happy Telkom prepaid customer...

I'm a happy MTN/Afrihost customer.

However, that option is available to me as I can pay Afrihost monthly for data via a credit card. There are a lot of people out there who are tied to contracts from the big players and the OOB crime. There are also many who load up small amounts on prepaid. The ripoff for them, even greater.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X